R.I.P. Troy

Yes

Point taken. But I was responding to the idea of trading out Petracca for pick 10-20. Which I believe is unnecessary risk.

I do like your bold thinking, and it could work. But unfortunately risk doesn't always = reward. Expecially not for MFC.

I have reached a point in my life where I am willing to sell my soul to the Devil for this post to come true.

I would have zero faith in our recruiters drafting a player better than Petracca with picks 10-20. Not that I rate Petracca terribly highly, just no faith and too risky. Better the devil you know.

Great in theory, but way too risky. Last thing we need is another big name recruit who can't get on the park. We would have the strongest injury list spine in the AFL with May, Lever & Patton.

Short answer - no But not unreasonable to suggest and explore. Would need to be proven player or pick 1-10.

Out - Everyone who won't be on our list in 2020 In - Just play the kids

Ideally Jones should come to his own conclusion he is cooked and retire immediately. That's not going to happen. Play him deep forward pocket. Might be able to muster a goal or two a game. Nearly every time he touched the ball last night it was turned over (I only saw 1st quarter). I would rather he turn the ball over in our forward line rather than across the middle or half back. Doesn't really matter anyway. Season & MFC in general are fast becoming irrelevant.

Hey Hawthorn, old pal, old buddy. Let's talk.

I'm in over my head. I can't do this. I quit. Effective immediately.

Well Goodwin has promised a better performance. I honestly believe Lynch & Riewoldt will pose no threat to us tonight. We have them covered. Should be a fantastic night for Dees fans!!! Tigers by 113

A fantastic idea. Couldn't agree more. It would certainly give me more time to enjoy life. Only problem, after 5 years of Goodwin coaching there will only be 10 people allowed on this site.

I wouldn't waste my money being a member of this delusional club, so i obviously recieved no email. Did Goodwin really guarantee a better performance against Richmond? That's just laughable if he did. The club is so delusional they probably believe in the existence of God. Let me know when they send out the let's all pray to God for help email. Club needs to start dealing in cold hard facts. The fact is we are the biggest rabble in the AFL. Stop wasting your time on bull [censored] feel good emails, and start looking at the team structure and game plan. Start looking at what new kids to draft in and who will coach our rebuild.

I know what i posted, and i know who you directed your post at. Hence my response to you. But thanks for clearing up the already crystal clear, great wise one.

All bow to the self proclaimed wise one

Very sorry Charlie, You have become very unwelcome, very unwelcome indeed. Maybe try your luck at midget wrestling, or jockey? Not AFL, don't try that again.

Goodwin's contract is like flushing time and money down the toilet. 5 years of hurt awaiting us.

In - Aliesha Newman, Tegan Cunningham Out - Charlie Spargo, Tom McDonald

Come on all the 'it will be ok ers'. Educate me on how it's all ok. I'm all ears. Another bump in road to glory? We'll learn and bounce back on track next week? Stay positive, good things will happen? ???

1. Goodwin can't coach 2. Spargo should never play again 3. Tom McDonald is as bad, if not worse than Oscar 4. WE SHOULD NOT HAVE TRADED JESSE HOGAN

Tony? Not sure who Tony is or if he'll be watching. I will be, but only because I have the Saints in a multi bet. Best of both world. Dees win and I'm happy. Dees lose and I'm rich. p.s. I'd much rather be happy

A must win game. Dees played themselves into a bit of form last week. With Lewis back to add experience and Ronald McDonald finally dropped (hopefully for good) and with a longer break than the Saints, this should be a comfortable Dees victory. Saints by 39

Would rather offer Neitz & Ox 3 year contracts