Tatu

Good get..... 2013 might be worth watching.... Now we need to shark Young from under the pies nose lol......

I would prefer Stringer.....than Wines..... I wouldn't be disappointed if we pick Wines, but I think Stringer looks a better player...

His best is very good...... But he's definitely passed his best..... Can his body hold up? A rookie spot maybe......

It's pretty hard to remember trades that didn't happen.... I can't even remember last years trades that didn't happen.....

i meant the type of role he played, as a player for Collingwood......

IF a deal is done.... And we manage to get Dawes and Pederson....... Than I'd think that Clark would take up a Leigh Brown type role....

Martin is the next Jolly.... Great player, just not at MFC....

nice post......

Any more than pick 20 is to much....... It's nice to have a player say they want to play for us....... But don't pay overs!! If we want a fair deal, then we shouldn't deal with Collingwood...... Pederson looks a better option, for a fair trade....

why would we? I hate if we payed that much.....

I would rather plant Jamar at full forward....... Keep Martin as number 1 ruck...... Than get Dawes as a stop gap forward, til we can play Hogan....

IF we hang on to pick 20..... And IF he slides that far, than Stringer is a must pick..... Too big a risk at pick 4, but at a steal at pick 20.... Don't think he'll be there......

Davey has had a bad couple of years..... But he is a proven experience AFL player..... He has till the end of next year for me, when his contract runs out.... I'd love to see the Davey of old running around next year.....

My vote would go for 3 and 3.... That way we have 6 backs, 6 mids, 6 forwards and 6 on the bench...

your right..... It seem like a fair deal for all, so Collingwood won't go for it....

Three way deal.... Collingwood Lose- Wellingham + Dawes. Gain- pick 13 + WC 2nd rounder West Coast Lose- 2nd rounder + Koby Stevens. Gain- Wellingham. Melbourne Lose- pick 13 Gain- Dawes + Stevens. C'mon Dees get it done!!

I think about add West Coast into the deal ... I don't want Wellingham...... Pick 13 for Dawes and Koby Stevens, I'd do that ...

Don't mind the idea of Dawes and wellingham, but not at that price..... Pick 13, id say yes..... Pick 13 and Martin, I'd say maybe...... Pick 4, NO WAY!!!

Would love to have young play for us next year.... I'd also like to have Ellis as well.... we need both, be nice to get both....

Ellis is the type of target I'd hope we where at least attempting to get.... As well as Clinton Young..... I'd also hope we where trying to be a third party in any deal.... That involves Stevens.... He'd be a good get for us.... Martin seems a bit rich for Stevens... But I would be happy to have him at the Dees...

id prefer to keep Martin than Jamar..... But Martin is the asking price for Dawes...... MFC want Dawes..... Hopefully No one bids for Viney and we get him at pick 100, but we know its not going to happen.... Grundy is Martins replacement.....

If GWS or GC bid for Viney..... MFC will pass.... Pick 2 & 3 in this years draft is to good to pass up..... MFC want Grundy, as a replacement for Martin..... I'm shattered because I was looking forward to watching young Viney next year....

Rivers is an underrated player..... He'll look a lot better at the cats...... The Geelong players and culture, will lift Rivers to new heights in the game.... His solid player and it will seem that he has improved his game, but really it will be the new culture and new start that improves his game.... Much like the Josh Gibson transformation, from north too the hawks.... He's not a devastating loss for us..... But he'll be great gain for the cats....

Personally I'd be shattered if MFC traded Jack..... When players play in the red and blue, i become attached...... i like to think of them as my own...... I've grown to really like Watts and I hope he becomes a really good/great one club player.... I'm already attached to Viney and he hasn't played one game.... I can't help but attach myself to anyone in red and blue.... At the moment it's the youth in our list that gives me and my kids hope.... Losing Scully hurt..... Losing Jurrah made my kids cry.... Losing Watts would mean, me and my kids losing passion for this club.... I would be done trying to convince my kids, that the MFC is the best club..... It's been bloody hard work to keep them in red and blue, over the last few years.... Take away our hope, than you can forget about me trying anymore.... This may seem silly to some but Jack Watts means more to me and my kids than Just number one draft pick..... Watts represent hope for the future..... Even if he fails as player..... At least he failed as demon..... Nothing would hurt more than Watts becoming another Carlton Champion.... I would rather keep Watts, than gain Cloke or buddy or Judd..... because to me and my kids Watts is Melbourne.....

Brock definitely has an agenda against the MFC...... When will he stop stabbing us in the back...... He's lucky he still walking..... [censored] OFF DOG MCLEAN!!!!