praha

Why can't we get this guy to coach the club? Come to Dees, Dean!

WAT? We were flogged last week. We lost by 12 goals. Terrible performance, but people compare it to the Geelong game and thing we were competitive and OK... I don't think we'll win this week. Just being a realist. The Eagles are a very solid, well-coached side.

Ewww.... No thanks. Most Geelong fans would laugh at us if we did this. Crows fans, too....

This is the big league. Perform or move on. I understand it's a tough gig, but people have a right to be critical. If you don't do your job, you are taking up someone else's place. We have a right to be critical seeing as though we invest time, money and emotion.

Decent player going to a good team with a good culture. Teams don't just get lucky. It's not just about drafting schoolboy talent.

Essendon have more of a place there than us. They beat Geelong. I'm just looking forward to 2012. Another year.

- Large number of MCC members are club members. They don't venture away from the MCG, especially considering members have to pay to get in this week. - Etihad is rubbish - We've just lost by 186 + 76 points - It's Etihad

Sounds pretty spot on to me... I mean, it's not like the club has been the pinnacle of success. The complete opposite. It's about time we stopped laying the boot into those that lay the boot in. You can't fix a problem without first acknowledging it. The club's a rabble. Sheedy is really just stating the obvious. Accept it and move on. Suggesting he has no truth in his remake is ludicrous.

I thought the same thing when I read it. Very poor choice of words. Anything 9+ goals is a blowout imo.

Lucky to get 12,000 there.

A friend of mine is a social media coordinator, worked alongside Westpac Group in the relaunch of Bank Of Melbourne. Wouldn't be straight up, but wouldn't deny that the bank will be major sponsor of the club next year. Stay tuned.

Desperately need a live stream

Oh my god...

Anyone have a stream?

We are easily a 50,000+ home game team when we are flying. I can't wait until this team starts playing well.

Won't happen.

I think it's the cringe you have that is part of what he wants get out of the club, that sweeping under the rug of issues and problems. You cannot rectify an issue without having first acknowledged there is an issue in the first place.

Hawthorn play 2-3 games a year in Tassie don't they? I have no issue with it. As long as we still get 11-12 games at the MCG a year, home or away.

To pass up on anyone that has come from North's culture would be ridiculous. If he's available and "those" others have been crossed off the list, we should definitely entertain him. We have the skill and talent. Need the structure and grunt. He can bring that. Pagan, too.

The logo is fantastic. The club went from no brand to a little brand. And now you want to get rid of a logo and a club branding that has arguably contributed to what is said to be the biggest sponsorship deal in the club's history? Schwab's position has been to reinvent the brand. He did it, and did it well.

You'll be lucky to get 5-10000 Melbourne supporters there.

Am I one of a few that believes Schwab is worth more than Scully? I mean, are people REALLY being critical of Schwab for spending big cash on high-priced executives with high credentials? Bay 13 has a knack of calling Melbourne a socialist club, but I never really believed. Seems to be the case. Damned if you, damned if you don't. End of the day, Melbourne had no brand a $2.3 million debt with no assets in 2008. How times have changed. Scully can [censored] of if that's the case. I have confident in the club's business administration. However, I am critical of the culture instilled at the club, and I believe this has more to do with player management at the club, as well as those people influential with what happens onfield. Scully is replaceable. People that can turn a brand from nothing to something aren't.

Shall he take the approach always taken by the club, and be unclear, untruthful? Because we've been the pinnacle of success. Weak types must go. Including those in positions that don't contribute that should, and that is not in reference to players.

10 goal win.