Jump to content

whatwhat say what

Life Member

Everything posted by whatwhat say what

  1. thanks to peggy o'neal and neil balme, plus benny gale who - all things being equal - should be the next ceo of the competition
  2. gotta say, i find the constant referencing to gambling odds on this forum a bit yuck i have no trouble with people gambling, and i understand a lot of people love wagering, but given the dees' stance of 'love the game not the odds' i am not a huge fan of it
  3. a decade worth of senior coaching experience it also helps that the cats have so many experienced players out there on the park - they were apparently talking at 3/4 time about how it was 'win every quarter by two goals and we'll be back' i don't like the cats, but they are super organised, super professional
  4. that would've required us interviewing him... $cully and trengrove were the consensus 'can't fail' top two picks that year melbourne fc: hold my beer...
  5. the only thing i think i have ever agreed with leigh montagna about is that there's a LOT of very ordinary footballers on decent coin absolutely you should pay yr best 10 players big bikkies, but really everyone in that 11-30 range is interchangeable and should be lowballed at contract time
  6. nick riewoldt really sounds like a saints supporter
  7. essentially they rated trac higher as a player but he 'failed' one of those idiotic psychometric tests whereas mccartin 'passed' with flying colours in terms of the leadership he displayed etc article also says we were picking brayshaw and lever if trac went at #1 there's nothing in this story that hasn't been discussed on these boards in the past
  8. i agree he would bring a real work ethic to that side on the training track he was an inside mid his junior career, but i can definitely see him replacing the wantaway ratkins on the wing
  9. i for one welcome our new insect overlords
  10. don't care, my own eyes tell me ratkins is a lesser player
  11. atkins? no thank you - awful user of the ball by foot and soft as butter norwood and sturt should be fighting it out for his signature
  12. i think the denigration of membrey is ill-founded he's a pretty good forward, and would be starting 22 for most sides - certainly ours
  13. i wish! bassett is going to the crows as an assistant according to a mate of mine who tends to be right on these things thompson, bishop, and bassett were all huge losses to the mfc to the south oztrayan sides
  14. he's definitely a midfielder not a forward-type these days when he was in the forward rotation for the tigers he was in and out of the side, and was really inconsistent since becoming a permanent mid with edwards injured / not in the hub he's been outstanding he's worth a first round pick to the tiges i would think as he's a vital part of their side and i doubt very much that they'd give him up
  15. unrelated injuries tho more similar to the way he came back in rd 1 where he looked seriously underdone if it's a pcl then he definitely shouldn't be playing
  16. great to hear tom lynch getting booed everytime he touches it
  17. right until we trade it for [insert player here]
  18. poor adelaide oval coach's box - gonna get fully clarko'd
  19. peptides on fire
  20. Patton looks to have done his Achilles That’s both him and Sicily out for hawks for the majority of 2021 you’d think
  21. if ever there was a show to put you off a polyamorous life it was that one
  22. Credited with winning premierships everywhere he went EXCEPT Melbourne
  23. Yeah that’s the thing, I think it’ll be a sliding scale based upon the total amount that the Kangas contribute to his salary