drdrake

Get GC pick 4, use pick 4 and 5 for a tall and a classy mid. Harmes, Tomlinson, Jordan and Grundy gone, McAdam comes in, bundle up picks to improve our draft positions.

Hard, you go in throw him to the ground, umpires reverse the kick. You have to wait, kick the goal then like viney did go at him.

How about we get some players that can hit a target. Our 2 best kicks play off half back in Salem and Bowey rarely put the ball inside 50. Langdon, Hunter, Viney, Oliver, Petracca, Gawn, Brayshaw all good players just aren't great kicks

Correct, if Maynard didn't elect to turn his body and bump it would have been a down the field free kick and both players continuing on. The moment he turned his body he elected to bump, he had a choice, he choose to turn his body and hit Brayshaw with his shoulder flush in the head.

Same story for a very long time, we are terrible by foot, add in the wet we just have no idea how to hit a target. So long bomb to a contest, numbers around the contest is our plan A. Collingwood just sat behind the ball and the sling shot, win the footy and sprint forward. It was a hard game to watch MFC just so bad by foot, 3 blokes jumping for same mark and for 3 qtrs the pies cleared to ball from our forward line with ease.

Will be interesting, the pies stance will be he turned to protect himself, other he turned to bump. Either way he instigated the contact that was head high, high impact. Finals, past player heads up mro he will get off

3 shots on goal out on the full in the last. We lost due to player stupidity.

A completely ineffective forward line v a very efficient forward line. We are cooked

They want it more, the ball just comes straight out of our forwardline with no pressure

Spargo more if it does rain and we are struggling to mark the footy up forward. He is clean and skilful the type of player you need in the wet

Good call Tommy in, I reckon Spargo will be the Sub. Start with 3 tall forwards, Smith can go back if Turner struggles. Wouldn't surprise me if Hibberd took Turners spot

For clubs outside of Qld and NSW, NGA is a complete waste of time. Clubs in other states did but some effort in prior to the rules being changed, now it is a couple of training runs not much more. Lucky for us we have a father son in the GCS academy, hopefully they are developing him for the 2025 draft.

I hope it isn't an ACL and wish him well. On the flip side I don't think having him and Fritsch in same forward line works.

The issue isn't Grundy or Max. We need that mobile CHF hitting up at the ball, a B Brown hitting up from deep inside 50m then the resting ruck is your third tall forward closer to goal from the long dump kick. Issue is, TMac has been injured again, B Brown being asked to play way to high and JVR still learning leaning his craft. Grundy nor Max are key forwards, neither was Luke Jackson but as third option tall forward they will be effective as long as we get the right structure around them. We also need to note that both aren't young anymore there will be a lot of games where one isn't available or managed.

The clubs aren't going to let GC walk away with their Academy players and another top 6 pick. I don't think the club will go after the no 1 pick, we have options to do so if they want to but I reckon we would be happy with 2 top 10 picks plus Brown later in the draft

Pick 15 and 24 straight to Gold Coast for pick 6, then decide whether pick 5 and 6 go to West Coast for 1 and 19, add in second round pick as well. Gold Coast needs points not early picks. Pick 1, 19 and Brown be a pretty good get

It is the same problem we have had for many years, we can't kick. We play a game style that suits our players skill level. Put the ball long to a contest get numbers to the contest win the ball with numbers. Issue is every team knows where we are kicking the footy, they are getting numbers to the contest. We are predictable and unfortunately don't have enough players that can hit that low hard 30 to 35m kick to a dangerous lead or into the middle of the ground.

You can't have B Brown and the resting ruck in same forward line. Our small forwards work so high up the ground that they can't get back at the feet of our forwards. Pickett is looking for easy goals out the back. I would give Grundy a spell this week, bring in JVR, have Brown, Smith, JVR. Bring in Laurie or debut Sestan.

His ball drop last year was terrible, so high and the more stressed he got about missing he tensed up and just shanked it. He focused so hard that it actually made his ball drop higher and worse. Sometimes you need to stop tinkering and let it flow. If Oliver and Petracca kick 35 goals, don't worry about brownlow, we are walking away with premiership

You cant compare the game back 20 to 30 years. Plugger, Lyon, Dunstall may at tops had to compete with 1 player and maybe some one sitting in the hole in from of them. I would dare to say they had a lot more shots from 35m out directly in front or on a slight angle. I'm not overly concerned about our set shots, outside Petracca. Our field kicking is our biggest issue, we couldn't hit targets which lead to a no risk down the line and then long bomb to a pocket. Safe football worse case we force a stoppage and set up again. Boring predictable football, the which the cause of the straight sets exit. Hopefully, we get confidence in our kicking to go back to taking risks, that was the difference from 21 to 22, not goal kicking

With the new Sub rule, I think we might start tall, 2 key forwards plus resting ruck, then Fritsch, Kosi, high small forward mid role. Have a small mid size as your sub

I think a few a discounting B Brown, terrible year last year but was asked to play a role that he struggled with. Bring in another tall to do the work further up the ground and get him back closer to goal and he is still capable of kicking 40 plus goals for a season

Add in FS selection that will most likely fall outside our first 4 picks, we have a strong hand to trade and draft

If Schache starts round 1 we are in serious injury trouble for the start of the season. Same with Melksham.

No question he made his mind up at some stage through the year. I don't think he was every coached to leave, in fact he was given a lot more ruck time in the back half of the year. Max was injured and struggled after queens birthday, Luke was having little impact as a forward mainly due to Tmac being injured and B Brown completely out of form, Luke couldn't be that third tall option. With Grundy and Max, I think the club is thinking we might only get 15 games home and away where they both play, we can rest one knowing the other can have the same impact. We can manage the 2 to ensure they are flying together for finals, I reckon that was the reference to Geelong, player management.