Redleg

Can we do it 8.30 Wednesday night? It might help me with my vote.

I am coming around to the Baghdad Bob way of thinking on deals. That basically is if you get what you want, the actual specifics of the deal is not important. For example, if you want a particular player and you don’t get the pick you would like, but still get the player with the pick received, what does it matter? We can get hung up on numbers, when it is really the full deal outcome that is important.

Fair enough and thanks for replying.

Keep posting, most of us enjoy it.

Whose word? If the Hogan deal is done the May deal would follow in minutes.

Just by the way, Oscar's field kicking is actually very good. He does what his brother couldn't do in the backline, kick to a team mate.

Well then you better follow another team.

I didn't know that May had toured the Dogs facilities. Are you sure of that?

If the deal is done that will happen as GC have apparently put 5 as their price for May and Neale deal will get it done. It’s the rest of the deal that has not been established. Sounding like the deal will be done Tuesday allowing a day to do other deals for all concerned.

For a fit Jesse Hogan, with good attitude and no other issues that is a fair price. Maybe he doesn’t fit my description.

The main indicator to me of the Jesse deal being done, is that we have said we are doing it to get May and May does not seem to be panicking and talking to other clubs as a fall back position. If May is comfortable with what is happening, it’s because we have probably told him the deal will be done and to just hang in there. That suggests to me that Jesse will not be a Demon Wednesday night and May and KK will. What the deal is, who knows, depends who blinks first.

2 Sams Edmund and Landsberger.

Should we be manning the airport to see if he is going to GC, just for a day or two, to check out the surf?

There is so much misinformation around it is just laughable. On the 2nd back page of the Sun today one journo says Langdon staying with the Pies. Underneath another Journo says Pies want Beams, who wants to go back, but have no picks, so will use what they get in the Langdon trade.

Yet they still don’t have Lobb or anyone for that matter.

They could have got picks later on and we would have given some back for 5. & 6.

And the Neale deal can be done in 10 seconds, if they want to.

But they are the ones not doing the Neale deal. If they do they have 5 and 11. They also had 6 and knew we wanted it and then traded it. That was not an accident.

So would the FD but we can’t get May and a top 10 pick for him. Have you read the previous 100 pages on here or any newspaper or any trade article on the net?

Freo had 6 and will get 5 for Neale. If Neale is traded they would have had both picks. Freo chose to get rid of 6.

With all of the diverse opinions and predictions posted on this thread, I am still to see any post more accurate than my early post, which was” we will either do the Hogan for May deal or we won’t”.

Depends who is the one that gets the call on whether it was right.

If he does it will be for less than 2 first rounders.

To be traded for pick 53. Is that for real?

I get the feeling a number of clubs and managers are not going to forget Freo’s behaviour in this trade period.