picket fence

T Mac, O Mac, Melksham, Spargo, ANB, Hannan, Just for starters!

BANG !! CORRECT!

Yep and should get another contract and continue his development at Melbourne. Hang on did I say DEVELOPMENT??

Whats Jimmy Toumpas doing nowdays??

Ok let me put it this way of those guys mentioned how many are A Grade?? May possibly close but not the other 2 We paid Huge overs for Lever as intercept defender and whilst Langdon had a good year I would want to see him double up. Let me pose another question to you how many of these quoted players would get a game at Richmond or Geelong?? Answer NONE! and I'll stand by my statement Tom Mcdonald had 1 thats right 1 good year and that was 2 years ago. He isnt going to get any quicker or more maneuverable. Oscar even less so. Just my opinion of course!

Because he is not very good. Has about as much flexibility as a Meccano man and the turning circle of the QE 2. His Brother is worse again. If the best we can do is this then we are deep in it. We NEVER were a destination club and NEVER will be. Not in my lifetime anyway!

Agree 100% with this and if we don't land a few this draft ( Ben Brown Ideal) and offload a few (T Mac and Oscar) then we will not improve 1 Iota!

Absolute Joke!!! at least the umpires appreciate and can see the difference between a footballer than an overated Rugby player!

CLARRY in a Sling WTF

BANG ON CORRECT!!!

NO WAY KNOWN!

Richmond everything we are No where NEAR

We would need Jaheesus H himself with our flawed and suspect game style to kick goals and not even then would I be confident!

BANG!! CORRECT! Viney 3rd in B&F?? Seriously look at his stats this year ! I dont even think he should have been in the top 10!! Oliver a clear 3rd maybe even 2nd behind Petracca and probably Max, May 4th and Langdon 5th would have been my assesment.

Well, if this is the case then we are the absolute Titanic mrk 2 Going that far down the Abyss that not even shark droppings are found there. I cannot fathom this, His role is Forward Organiser?? Save me!!! Sheeit Footy ability doesn't count but marshalling other players does? Parkkk Me!?

Mate if this happens I will organise a Picket Fence line around the clubs headquarters and body slam anyone who is remotely connected to this travesty!! ? Can't believe this would happen!!

Well if thats right then which of the coaches has not fixed a "Glaring" Error?? Oh, I get it it must have been Dans problem!!

Just on Melksham.The coach made him Captain for one game. You are correct and why how he continued to get a game is one element of Goodwin playing clear favourites!

If Spargo gets a game at all next year we will not have not improved one miniscule!

Do you know this for fact??

Dawson was close to one of the worst footballers I ever saw, period! so your post is telling!

"Money For Nothing" I want my—I want my MTV [4x] Now look at them yo-yos, that's the way you do it You play your footy on the MCG That ain't workin' that's the way you do it Money for nothin' and your chicks for free Now that ain't workin' that's the way you do it Lemme tell ya them guys ain't dumb Maybe get a blister on your little finger Maybe get a blister on your thumb

Then if that's the case then the MFC Should put an extension to him NOW on top money and lock him away! Why wouldn't they do that unless money is tight. If it is the case and the club have snookered Viney away instead of Oliver, not only have they been shortsighted and negligent but risk a lot of supporters just saying bye bye no more memberships and support is right out the window! Starting with me! We have a once in a generation player dual B&F All Australian potential 250 game plus player who will only get better and we are stuffing around! Do the deal now lock him away for 5 years or more and really put this issue to bed once and for all!!

Dazzle, do you reckon there is more to this story than first thought?

I agree that Brendan Mc Cartney was instrumental in Clarries last couple of years. He still finds the ball but why does he persist in this jockeying for position with another player is beyond me. Does Danger do it does Dusty. I reckon if this is a coach driven thing it is flawed logic, Surely he can stand more or less by himself and let MAX Palm it out.!? I was frustrated that time and again he needed to jostle and bounce of someone, surely the idea is to keep moving with a set strategy for palm outs??