Bring-Back-Powell

Can someone please explain to me why Frost was a mistake riddled disaster at times for the MFC, but as soon as he puts on an HFC jumper he turns into a slick, skilful and reliable defender?

He once turned a game around against GC in 2017 with 3 sausages up forward. Not as silly as it sounds.

What’s the equivalent of the Coleman leader board for behinds because Fritta would be leading that comfortably with 6. Hopefully it’s just a phase but he’s not a pure set shot sort of player unfortunately.

I’ve fallen for the wet conditions so many times. Trust me we’re even worse in the wet weather and I can’t recall us winning a game in recent years on a genuine wet day. At this stage they’re only predicting a shower or 2 on Sunday so it might not even rain during the game.

Our next 3 game will be on the channel 7 3:20 timeslot.

How did you watch training? Behind the fence? Or are you allowed into the stadium? As for Zac Jones, yes we should've gone for him irrespective of Nate. I wanted him last off season because of his pace and us having a sever lack of it. St Kilda's trades really paid off the other night, but it's just one night.

I wonder if any MFC members would be entitled to a ticket for this one?

I can't believe people have suggested Hunt to be dropped. Carlton would've killed for forward to bang home 3 goals on the weekend.

I picked up on that too. All winning clubs don't leave the ground until the last player has been interviewed - particularly the captain!

Not an overly big issue but I can't imagine a professional organisation such as Richmond or Collingwood accidentally allowing this to happen. It was cringe worthy watching the song on live TV with the knowledge that the skipper was still on the ground. #Melbourne

May was horrid on the weekend. We’re entitled to expect much better from him. His kicking was way off and a costly marking attempt resulted in a Carlton goal.

I don't think I've ever come across a game where both sets of supporters were ropeable with the result - including the winners.

Some of the above questions and claims are valid, however dropping Hunt next week has been one of the more perplexing suggestions over the last couple of years.

What happened to the player that once managed a 37 possession/3 goal game in 2018? How does someone go from potential stardom to an average plodder? Is he being played out of position, is he being poorly coached or did he peak as a player way before his prime years.

On form Melksham should be dropped. Hasn't fired a shot since the Gold Coast game last year. Disappointing as I really rate him. Jones had his career worst game on the weekend. Not good signs for an old player such as him. Having said that, ANB didn't do much in the second half. Both Jones and Melksham have far more upside than ANB by way of contributing to a win. ABN's stiff but he was the player to replace Pickett, and will likely make way for him unless they want to make an early season statement like they did with Hibberd.

Essendon's win over Freo was as poor as our win on Saturday. They fell to pieces in the last quarter and only the siren saved them. I can recall their supporters were as savage as ours after that win over Freo They played pretty good footy yesterday against Sydney, but unlike the premier sides, they kept on giving Sydney a sniff right to the end. Essendon are a 7th-10th side this year, but will be had to beat with their pace and run.

Agree with that. Their only tall is McKernan who I rate and killed us last year with 4 goals despite playing out the game with a pinged hammy. Certainly a lot shorter than Carlton's fwd line, but Stringer, McDonald-Tippa, Smith and Fantasia (if selected) will provide a handful. Therefore next week might not be the week to bring back O Mac because they ain't dropping Lever or May. On the flip side, we may need to go for some height up forward as Hooker and Hurley could mark everything given our sub-parinside 50 entries. Maybe bring in Weed and retain Jackson or drop Jackson to also include Brown.

I can't fathom how anyone would even contemplate dropping Hunt. He was in our top 5 for the day. Kicked 3 goals, made a classical lead and took the resultant mark like a genuine full forward because of his explosive pace. No one else seems capable of doing this in our forward line aside from Fritsch who can't hit the side of a barn at the moment. And as you mentioned, put in some important 1 per centers including a crucial late game tackle and shepherding that long Petracca goal in the third quarter. We must persist with him as he some fantastic attributes as a modern day forward eg- explosive off the mark and a reliable kick for goal. Meanwhile I reckon Melkham's in trouble and probably would have been discussion after round 1 whether he retained his spot. I'd back him in one more week as he's a gun on his day.

I would think Shiel also needs attention. Come to think of it Essendon have traded really well over the last couple of years with the likes of Stringer, Smith, Shiel and Saad. I wrote them off at the start of the season due to their off season surgeries but the COVID 19 period has worked well in their favour. They will probably play finals.

Fritsch needs to also take responsibility for his performance. Has kicked 1.6 this season. Missed way too many set shots and undid his excellent contested marking on Saturday - particularly the grab he took to boot the "winning" point. We'd all be celebrating his performance if he kicked 4.1 not 1.4. I'm happy for him to keep playing full forward as 5 scoring shots justifies his position deep in the fwd line. Just needs to start converting.

I'd be more confident if this game were at Marvel as we usually beat them there, while at the G they're too fast for us. They've beaten us the last 3 times there. Ins - Pickett, Weidman, O Mac Outs - Jackson, Smith, ANB Pickett for ANB although Jones and particularly Melksham should be dropped based on their poor starts to the season. Melksham hasn't played well since getting injured in round 8 last year. O Mac for Smith is obvious. Smith was an obvious liability as he directly cost us 2-3 goals. Either play him forward or don't play him. The Jackson inclusion didn't work in terms of having a cohesive forward line after half time. Weideman needs to come in and hopefully T Mac will benefit from having a more experienced co-key forward. I hope Bennell's minutes increase this week. I'd imagine him playing just 50% of game time wouldn't be helping our overall rotations, although Carlton lost a bloke early and ran the game out far better,

And the same question for AFL members?

Is it possible T Mac cracked the sads that his bother got omitted and hence came in with a poor attitude?

Melbourne don’t win that game without Petracca - Jason Dunstall on fox footy. Hats off to Petracca on a magnificent performance. He’s approaching gun status.

Problem is we don’t seem like the sort of club that learns from their performances.