Everything posted by 58er
-
My 3 word player analysis V Gold Coast
If we win( or when we win) the 23 plus all the balance of players and coaches and FD and Board will all be legends!! Then the status can be apportioned in sounder and saner times!!!
-
CHANGES: Rd 21 vs West Coast
Surely Weid rucking and forward is a better like for like.
-
Finals in Geelong?
Can't play WC in WA as we are higher up. Thought you would know Finals grounds location conditions of higher side with home advantage.
-
Clarko leaves Hawks
It surely is Kennett curse like the Geelong /Hawks on was a decade ago.
-
Clarko leaves Hawks
Hey can't be proven as this years Hawks performances have been all over the shop right up there with the most unreliable in the AFL. Tomorrow night the Hawks could be on the bottom with one wing holding onto the wooden spoon!!!
-
Clarko leaves Hawks
About as shameful as the Melb board that sacked Norm. Hawks won't have 57 years to wait and It is imperitive that we win a flag before Hawkswin their next now.
-
Rd 22 vs Adelaide in Melbourne
That was CAIRNS silly!!!
-
Rd 22 vs Adelaide in Melbourne
What did happen???
-
TEAMS: Rd 20 vs Gold Coast
Fritsch could get injured and our best forward is out for the season Thst made you happy??
-
TEAMS: Rd 20 vs Gold Coast
It's never too late !!! 2nd Ruck and forward pocket trial for Sam should have been done for this game. Maybe Sam can be the Med sub!!
-
TEAMS: Rd 20 vs Gold Coast
Should have been given a rest and Sam an opportunity to shine in the second Ruck and forward role. Clearly Sam a different player when not minded by one defender and is quite creative and skilful with handball etc. Agsin Goody misses a trick and timing is the key. Also go along with other posters who said CHB trial for Sam would be good. Small defenders role ( assuming Bowey plays forward) is still a worry.
-
FIXTURE: Rd 20 2021
Because we play Docklands well Lookat our past 5 years results OD!!
-
What’s Behind Our Form Slump
If there isn't any changes! Surely Sam W should be given a go to be second Ruck and forward just to change things snd also help Jacko get some form back either on the track or once VFL games resume. At the same time just a run on the ball might get Salem back to his best and a change for ANB to refresh him. Is there any point in considering Daw or Declase? Jonesy and Melky must be given a chance and should be fresh to boot. Defence wise we should have a small defender either Lockhart or Bowey to get the ground ball crumbs that are coming in to test our defence. Goody ( and the other Selectors) must react to our drop in form especially disposal and kicking skills. It must be addressed not just wiped away as is our ridiculous forward pocket and boundary obsession for our forward line. Maybe swap Tmac and Petty to make the opposition think more and not just the same old same old! We only need a 10/15% up swing and we can still give this flag a shake as we have no been totally wiped off in any game and been in the game with 10 mins to go in all games!
-
FIXTURE: Rd 20 2021
ItsaHawks scheduled home game really nothing to do with Lions .going home to quarantine.
-
WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - KYSAIAH KROPINYERI PICKETT
That's not true Dr D you predicted he would be a real failure and w"would not make it" this season. Completely different views to what has happened. Yes he can slow down and use more composure and style but nothing can takeaway his skills and ability that have revitalised our forward line and made all opponents scared of Kossie whenever he gets near the ball. Please don't go claiming credit where it's not due. All Dees supporters are thrilled about Kossies development which is fast by any standards and let's see what happens in the next 2 months. His best skills are unmatchable and excitement unparalleled and he is still just a teenager.
-
Dees vs Bulldogs This Week
Exactly what I am asking. Looked the same. Complete over reaction but we must start getting some cohesion going to build up for Finals snd to launch from Top2 or if not then Top4 to give ourselves a rest in the second week if necessary.
-
Dees vs Bulldogs This Week
My understanding is that its mainly ( and only) the Sunday 3.20pm game that Channel 7 (FTA) AFL coverage is not available. Some other games may have to be altered by about 2 hours forward to fit into the Olympic broadcast schedule.
-
Dees vs Bulldogs This Week
Because they haven't finalised the details YET obviously.
-
52,421 Members - All Time Record
Amazing effort in Covid ravaged year however success on the field is always the catalyst for membership no's. Hopefully the 12,000 new members this season are half new and half resigning from previous years. If so it gives confidence for the future to reach day 60,000 next season with hopefully A big new Cup and Flag to add to our dozen already coveted. Congratulations to every member who has helped the Club achieve this ground breaking target.
-
Premiership Points
I Disagree. You can only go on total wins otherwise you may as well start splitting Each Premiership from 1900 to 1964 on its merits ie games win or lost etc with W snd L. Being The salient solo figure. Each season is different and a total of wins/ losses is always going to be crucial but that is the stories that lay behind the records that books etc can keep us informed about snd fascinate us fans.
-
Premiership Points
My understanding is 16 wins 6 losses in 2004 and no finals wins being beaten by Bombers in their last finals win in the elimination Final. In our glory years 1956 I believe we won 16 and lost 2 in home and away round then won the 2 finals ( 2nd Semi and Grand Final) and the flag of course. Where you get your 17 game information from is mystifying.You only need to consider years we have made the Top 4, 5, 6 and 8. A total of 18 games was the normal number except in years which were affected by the World Wars from 1914/18 and 1941/45 with not all Clubs participating in each season. The AFL season has been a total of 20 and 22 games for the last 30/40 years and only 2020 was shortened to 17 Rounds as we all know due to Covid impact. So the 16 record for home and way wins can be broke as can the 18 wins total for 1956 including Finals as our most winning season. We are a great chance to break both IMO. If any D/Lander has any other figures to contradict this summary pleas feel get to offer your contribution as I am going on general knowledge rather than consulting record books.
-
FIXTURE: Rd 19 vs Gold Coast & Rd 20 vs Bulldogs
There has been nothing from Our board/Perty about our commitment so it's not a split or even us making up for the lost game previously and .$ 800k. Purely a good chance to get national exposure on FTA TV and to show off our brand and skills near the pointy end of the season.
-
Toby Bedford
Thanks CF sometimes a bit of composure is what Locky needs!
-
Toby Bedford
Locky is a small defender specialist who is a very good chance of becoming a real defender in the AFL once say Hibbo slows down or retires. Has pace snd skill and takes the game on.
-
Toby Bedford
Weeds has ability BUT continually fails to IMPACT himself on the game when he played only as a forward. Plus his good kicking is no longer reliable but a myth esp. at AFL level. That's why I think he is a Jacko replacement more than BBB or Tmac. Running around the ground he gets quite good involvement in the game and contests in the ruck adequately. Itcwas in complete contrast with BBB on Thursday night as he ensured that Port had to mind him and looked dangerous with ball on hand. He also took 2 marks which are normally given!! Forward line looks best for weeks and dalmost best for season. Inaccuracy body is agsin as about 4/5 set shots were squandered by perennial offenders.