58er

SCOTT can see another Final after half time Being overrun due to the old brigade in Cats colours too slow and Unfit.

Just feels it sends the wrong message to young players when playing well. Melksham is the elephant still but it's hard work fir BBB and Weid as Tmac Snd LJ are performing a pivotal role as well as a team first role and no way should this be tampered with. Strange combo Tommy marks at a high Level as his long arms are straight up and Jacko has those ground skills plus improvement in marking potential now as a forward. Then where do we start with his ruck role priceless for the Gawn effect all over the ground!!!

2019 we burnt him as a result of 2018!!

Not a subscriber to the get back on the horse principal.? Thats what is better For Bayley who needs some tough love not molly coddling.

Ridiculous did U watch The game ? Or replay. Does things so Unobtrusively that you don't notice inc. handballs tackles and fits in with the mids as scpoibbof difference.

I'll be surprised if T MAC is playing in spite. That is not the only motive he is displaying ( if at all) He is just super fit and playing dangerously and can see the big picture. He may not have liked the edict but has responded superbly and is a giant reason why the forward line is a force to be reckoned with. He has always been a Club person and I believe as a Life Member is undoubtedly still!

Cwood were not in Perth ( I am certain ) during red zone period. They flew out last Friday week or arrived home on Sat.week.

Yes yes yes upgrade ASAP

The WA Govt are not involved any more! Norh have received permission to fly home and have already arrived. The Vic Govt have asked them to isolate for 2 weeks but Players can train together at appointed times. The next decision is up to The Tasmanian Govt. and AFL negotiating an outcome. The advice from Dub Dee in this forum that the game may be moved is HIS opinion only based on no firm evidence from Authorities who are trying to ensure that the game go ahead at Blundstone on Sunday. Too much money hinges on this for the State and AFL has to come up with a safe Covid plan so that the fixture will proceed. Some awaiting for advice of a change in location are no more informed and the longer silence is continued is an indication that the arrangements will remain as per the fixture,

The old adage of if it ain't broke don't fix it. So if Melkshsm is dropped and BBB or a Weid are Full forward that is fine. But don't switch Tmac Our forward structure is based around Tmac and he is delivering, as long with the others. When the whips are cracking BBB will be there and firing. Weid will also get a chance not certain about both on the same forward line though. Plenty of time for all to state their case. but NO TOMMY or TOMLINSON for the wing. Angus is doing just fine also.

At the end when Tigers fans left and we sang the Club song plus the presentation to Trac there was IMO 30,000 Demons fans minimum. The MCC members was 2/3 Demons and Really good no 's in The Southern Stand upper. All I can say is any one not gong now just can't expect to rock up and get Finals tickets Especially if we play Tigers again. Get your GF guarantee also if you are serious. Covid has placed some small hardship for fans but no more than going to coffee shops with the QRCode and it has been point by point provided by the Club on our website. Reserved seat holders and friends sitting together are being slightly disadvantaged but not prevented under the Priority 1,2 and 3 system of linking up. What some people don't think about is their own safety and others. Contact tracing is not just about you it is any one in the crowd. Simple but effective and safe.

Agree Titan

Natural form and Injury Plus hopefully not suspension generally intervene so no use forcing an issue at present. Once you are also ensconced in say the top rungs you can look at health and niggles etc. Or a player say like Chandler who I believe is really close to best 23 emerge as up to AFL standard then it's The time to reward this achievement.

The answer is you DONT TRY TO FIT IN players unless there is a good reason !!

Play players on merit and form and health ( fitness) Don't flirt with selection for selection sake!!

We don't need Tmac on the wing ! How many times have you suggested this mythical change in our structure? Isn't his form good enough ? Let the bloke do what he does best . The Mark McLure role in the forward line Marking kicking goals and making ways for and protecting our smalls. It's going well and honestly both Weid and BBB are not that same type of player to assist others. Just wanting to play certain players to fit them in is not team football. They must all gel and right now Melksham is probably the elephant in the room. Plus Angus is owning his wing with great support for the defenders and also a good feeder to the leads from Our forwards. We don't need to experiment and risk mucking up Tmac'a form and the Forward line and centre line synergy.

Not Jordon really on current form.

DD we are all liable to change our minds on this great game. Nearly every Melb player Is rewriting his CV this season. Thats why we are improving as a team and Club.

Absolutely right Cheesey !!!

Absolute rubbish. Tommy isn't a winger he is a key position player ie FF or CHF. And a beast and a competitor in the same mould that Mark McLure was in those great Carlton sides in 1979, 81 and 82: Makes Kossie ANB and Charlie play taller. Move him at your peril !! That doesn't mean BBB or Weid aren't good enough.

And it's just the start of a defence type dynasty with a couple of others on the way when we get the odd injury or suspension!

They have to make available SOME Away members tickets And it's generally a stand alone time for say 2 hours to get. We should (The Club) have the info on their MFC website earl that week. Why would it be any different under a Covid plan?

Disagree.

He finished last season with about 4/5 games where he impacted the fortunes of our team towards a win. Watch the GWS win in Round 17 and its the same as 2021 all out commitment and running for the team. Congratulations Christian.

Definitely nearer to Lovett than Whelan which prob makes Christian an A-to A+. As Brett was an A+ no doubt. At seasons end I believe he will be without doubt an A+ and may even have a medallion around his neck!