Turner

i wonder if he played a good game coz it was against us rather than it being a him factor

plays ahead of worner, banfield and wagner, and honestly chapman is a bit eh too but at least doesnt whinge about doing the team thing and locking down, and he was a top 10 pick! howes is no better than a vfl plodder, and is going to be gifted games on teh basis that everyone around him is falling away, has nothing going for him that suggests he is afl standard. I like the cooper simpson shouts, but LJ is the play here, i think we are a massive sniff if we play our cards right

egg on a few faces in here... 🙈

did he show any improvement this year? isnt tough, isnt good defensively, isnt good aerially, and isnt quick, if howes is a regular next year its a concern for me

i think he'll be strongly tempted with a move home in two years, he seems to always be sniffing around one whiff of midfiekd minutes and he'll be off, likely will be the same time JOM is ready to hang them up for the dockers

which would be so hilarious, and i'd have a tough time feeling sorry for them when its their own doing. Hopefully SOS never comes near our beautiful club

given how well SA went at the carnival im surprised at the lack of noise around a few of theirs LeRay being the main one

has no real strengths, no outstanding phsyical traits, the worst type of player to be as you are the most easily replaceable in the 22 and on the list with a younger prospect. taj has been tried across all three lines and is a serviceable vfl player, i love the romanticism of a FS recruit so hopefully if he survives he can find a niche and thrive on it, the same way a maginess or west has elsewhere

may isnt on the way out unless we find a suitor, so until we do (and so far we haven't) so until we do it isnt good business in my opinion i mean significantly is probably a stretch, he's a caravan and has been for some time now. coming from a lower ceiling than the other two who were all australian defenders and top 20 players in the comp he might've been closer to par but he certainly wasn't "better" than them it was just a closer call. no one was flaming may's first 15 weeks the same way we've criticised his last 8, whereas i'd make the argument McDonald played at the same level most of the season and on the second or third forward (turner took one ahead of him too) but because he was coming top 5 in the league for spoils at one point we're acting like he was robbed of a blazer. can't jump and a liability once the ball hits the ground, may is still the better footballer

if my nan had wheels and all that

wouldn't have been such a problem if we hadn't also recommited to Tommy Mac for 26 as well. For me it should have been one or the other, and when one is already locked in i think we should have given TMac a nudge. How is Adams going to progress if hes playing 3rd banana next year at Casey with May and TMac.

i thought he was taller than 194, if he was 197+ i'd be an extra 20% more excited but none the less i hope we see him R1

go to the rumours thread for that, this thread is a bible

he was playing on irishman mark duffy

a good bridge player for a bottom six side, like cam pedersen was once upon a time to be a battering ram and take heat off some kids, i'm just not sure what he brings to a side already full of seasoned bodies, he isnt a polish cherry on top player like a mannagh or davidson so for mine it was a bit of a nothing selection and if we didn't already have melksham and fritsch (mihoceks recruitment makes it even harder as well) as similarly sized options he'd get more opportunities, the number of games he plays next year will have a direct correlation to how well our season is going. for the teams sake i hope its at or below that 5 mark again, of course I would love to be wrong too

you seem to get a read on these things early, whats prasads range next year? maybe my dovaston love affair is too short sighted

jed walter in darwin would have been my winner

jacob dawson!! you've been watching too much vfl! Jordon dawson is my pick however

i agree with you there, but im saying we had a full list meaning we had excess picks, not necessary that our list was filled with better players meaning we made the right decision to throw away picks, at the very least we should have been pumping them back into the next season and then redeciding then

i think this needs to be put into some sort of perspective. which is we knew how many list spots we had available and we had surplus of picks to spots, therefore we were willing to trade 2 picks (for lions academy points) for one player as we would have passed on the latter pick anyway. likewise why we trade multiple picks for one higher up the order pick, and i like us moving future picks forward as you can always move the ones the next year forward etc etc endlessly forever now

cody curtin kicked 6 goals in the wafl colts granny, i know its not the highest standard of junior comp but given hes probably outside the top 30 prospects, hes 200cm and he wont be too dissimilar to his brother in athletic profile and mentality/professionalism i hope we are seriously considering him

ive been on him all year, tick for mine

Does kiddy coleman get starcevichs spot when he leaves? he was the best player on the ground in the first half of the 23 granny

this narative always confuses me, you mean because he was a less professional athlete for longer hes more likely to last longer as a pro athlete doing the right things to your body? BBB was a mature ager and he barely got to 30. there is no argument here when drafting key forwards they must have mongrel and c*** about them, when theres a pack or a player in front of them or the ball is kicked too them they need to run through anything and everything and attack that ball like they want it. MJ from day 1 has shown no ability to do that, JVR does a little bit but cant get himself higher than any other hands in the pack or enough seperation from his defender. its my biggest concern about White is that he's a basketball two footed jumper, ball on my head and ill mark it because im taller not a see ball recklessly fly at ball KPP

the question probably is do they want to offer him 2yrs or would they prefer howe for 2 years. right now its hard to argue either of them will see '27 at which point is it worth it for 12 months?