Turner

what do we do in this sitution? "ignore duffield i broke it and had to go back so thats CDT" sharp? grjl? lindsay? dovaston? pickett? trade?

oskar ainsworth linked to us and also the tigers at 38, can;t find much on him but seems to be a really similar type and build to nairn, having also gone tholstrup recently i hope we look at someone with a bit more POD even a smaller mid like a sam allen or addinsall if we dont go for a true small like byrne just to sort of round out the list. theres something about a side of 18 186-189cm blokes that just appears to vanilla even if they are all slightly different somewhat, you need that game changing player to really spark your side sometimes

surely if the tigers live grjl and he is going to be on the board at our pick then we can do a deal to get ahead of essendon and get a run at robey or taylor and even have a sniff of cdt you just know he becomes a star and allows weddle to go inside or just dominates for them once impey/amon finish up wed, the wiz and siz: hawks need for speed headline when he has 20 and kicks one on the run on debut

both players have shown form in multiple roles, i think that is a must for JT at the top of the draft as it gives them a second wind in their careers and less chance at failing, if you take dovaston you might be able to tell in 15 games if he's going to make it or not, its just the nature of the role, whereas you can find a 188cm player and they can play a variety of roles, look at sparrow, didnt hit his ceiling of burst inside mid but has still eeked out a role, windsor, lindsay tholstrup also all have that same capability even langford has shown some craft forward

taylor byrne i think has enough, leon kickett and latrelle pickett i think do too other smaller players bob, dalton, mcguane, kneipp, im less sure on as they arent natural crafty small fwds and dont necessarily have either the goal nous or the agility to really show up bigger stronger or even quicker opponents

“The Demons haven't nominated Next Generation Academy prospect Toby Sinnema, with the Dandenong Stingray a chance to be a train-on option after the draft if not selected”. From Cal Twomey’s Phantom Draft

pick 7 - fwd/mid (nairn) pick 8 - back/mid (farrow/lindsay/sharp/xtaylor) pick 37 - this pick will surely be to add another mid type, i can't see us going tall whilst we still have a stack on the list and defensively theres none in this range so rules out hetherton also can't see us taking a ruck so its small fwd or mid, Sam Allen, Matt LeRay Rory Wright Sam Swadling are the names that excite me the most, and Beau Addinsall if we can put a bid down we've obviously seen a heap of him whilst watching KW this year FS white - tall rookie - small fwd or best available, Taylor Byrne, Aaron Sharkie, Tom Burton, Jackson Voss?, Felix Kneipp

see i think ess is trading up for farrow at 11 because surely we wouldn't let sharp slide past us given our need for midfielders, but it is true we like versatility in which case if we hate sharp and grjl then i don't have a clue who we take with nairn other than farrow but if the dons know that and go him early then i am just so confused coz it wont be pickett/dovaston/schubert so maybe lindsay?

current read i think we might end up with XTaylor WCE: Duurs CDT RIC: Robey Grjl ESS: Sharp Cumming DEES: Taylor Nairn gives us a fwd connection piece and a versatile defensive piece both with good offensive and defensive games for the modern transition footy is it my preferred outcome probably not but it is seemingly most likely

hodge comparrisons fair? has the toughness and a bit of the overhead stuff without being a weapon

with our live rookie pick, assuming we take Kalani with 65 or whatever sharkie or jackson voss would be my go as a young smaller defender OR you take byrne if he isnt the choice at 35 other than that i'm not sure who excites me the most that could go undrafted that isnt club tied but HB is definitely a spot we should look to strengthen

the zerohangar or truefooty guys are way more insightful tbh, he's actually not very knowledgeable pommy bit of a passion merchant and just regurgitating other peoples thoughts

its a pretty heavy duty bit of software, so yeah would recommend whipping out the lappy

https://pommyinoz.shop/pages/draft-simulator get yourselves on this tool, hours of fun also @sotaram afl on youtube is also building out a sleeker more comprehensive one but it is not yet publicly available

would be interesting if taylor slides, im hoping cumming doesn't eagles: duursma sharp/cdt rich: robey/grjl cdt/taylor ess: sharp cumming/robey dees: taylor farrow/cumming seems like how itll play out

yep like him more than BOB and fred rodriguez, really depends what we take at 7/8 what i like here, leray, swadling, allen, byrne, pickett not sure

isn't sam allan like 182cm, so nearly the complete opposite of tall winger

max holmes is who i see with a floor of blakey if his midfield game doesnt progress, even has enough about him to be a zac bailey

isn't she the gws recruiter who used to work in the media?

is there enough of a difference between nairn and leray to justify one at pick 12 over the other at 34? to me, no. leray is the same size, good overhead and a nice kick but maybe it was nairns two week block at the back end in the guts that is what we really liked, so they could u go cumming and nairn? probably not when u already have tholstrup idk much to weigh up

i dont think jack ison knows his own game, hes more of a dusty mould than a cyril or kox

r12 was so much more impressive than r13 less fumbles better attack and just a more solid game especially early

feel like this is appropriate at this time, particularly looking at the ranking of the players without the club tied talent, it sort of puts it in perspective, leray at 33 is rated as the 23rd open pick, so pascoes placement of greeves at 50 is basically 35th

honestly i'm not supper excited by him, i think he doesnt have a heap of scope for improvement and has probabky bullied some smaller players at stoppages across this year a little too much, prefer sharp or farrow i think they have more traits that would translate

i just watched his highlights and i actually think contested footy and close attention were his strengths, he was clean one touch and always able to get his hands free to dish the ball out when under pressure and importantly was hitting chests with his handballs they were accurate and intended. wasnt able to see enough about his running but he showed enough burst, would probably start at HF rather than HB but looked neat enough. Don't know if its a lazy comparison but Rivers did come to mind Looked through some other profiles too, Sam Allen the small mid who has an acl atm, he looks a likely type i can see why people havent forgotten him Mikunda might be around there, BOB all probably start as HF types and could finish there too but are on the smaller side