dazzledavey36

Time to steer clear. I don't wan't to put up with another Mitch Clark (in terms of in juries that is)

Are the old ' how many AFL games you have played' line. Its almost like one of those nerdy try hard pick up lines that fail.. You are as bad as Saty when it comes to protecting players. Give it a rest 'Chap' I am allowed criticize whoever I wan't especially when im putting thousands of dollars each year into this club.

So you want him based on that one hanger or his footballing ability because i have never seen him play and im guessing you have?

I'm going to cop a wack for this but personally I think Cripps is overrated.. Hear people say he is the best young midfielder in the comp over the last 10 years.. WTF!? Il admit his clearance work is insane but watching him closely over the past 2 months his disposal needs a tidy up and he doesn't damage the opposition enough with them.. Funny how people have been putting up starts of Cripps compared to Judd Selwood etc.. This is Cripps 2nd season of AFL stats VS Other young players in their 2nd years. Patrick Cripps 20 games Ollie Wines 22 (didn't include the 3 finals) Dustin Martin 22 games Jack Trengove 19 games Nat Fyfe 21 games Disposal 471 Disposals 528 Disposals 33 goals Disposals 387 Disposals 527 Tackles 98 Tackles 110 Tackles 73 Tackles Tackles 100 Tackles 85 Goals 6 Marks 58 Goals 33 Goals 13 Goals 18 Marks 64 Goals 9 Marks 78 Marks 92 Marks 111 Paul Roos was right.. Why is their even a debate? The fact is the media have absolutely pumped up Cripps as a dime in a dozen once in a 10 year midfielder is absolutely laughable. Cripps will be a good midfielder like some of those names but the fact that's its a huge debate against Hogan?? A CHF who unlike Cripps had already played 5 games already last year in his debut year where Hogan missed all last year with a serious back injury. This is Hogans debut year. Its his first year of AFL footy end of story. Sorry but if Cripps wins it tomorrow it will be an absolute disgrace and a sham of an award. Not buying into the huge hype surrounding Cripps. Not saying he will be a dud or anything he will be a super player for Carlton but Hogan is by far the best young key forward I have ever seen that's close to the Great Wayne Carey.

Exactly Name and shame this spud.

Hes the Adelaide small defender who has had an exceptional year.

Go up to him and tell him yourself. I am sure he will take it all on board..

Some outright bizarre comments on here. I wish him all the best. His health is 1st priority with footy a daylight second. Hope he recovers well and gets back to playing that exciting footy i love watching.

Of course we do. Who I think will be just as good as Treloar.

He was injured all year with a knee injury mate settle down.. jeez..He has just hit the 50 game mark. He will bounce back strongly next year.

Officially off to the pies. Told gws today he is leaving.

They overlooked Petracca. Enough said.

Hes from Wagga..

Been thinking it 24 hours after the game but was too scared to mention it. Glad you did but lol. Why? He breaks tackles, attacks the contests like a bull, his arieal work is fantastic and he showed he can take a big grab. He also has that speed to clear from the contest. Like Fyfe his kicking needs working but that will come in time. Not saying he will be like Fyfe but has similar traits.

How good was his one on one contest he won on the wing where he ran full pace at the contest and just won the hard ball and just burst away with it. Got the crowd up and going. A good family friend of ours and a genuine top kid.

Oh and Jeremy Cameron in his first year= 29

FKn Oath

No he has a shocking attitude.

Honestly Tomlinson played like a player that wanted to get out of that club as soon as the siren went at the end.

JKH is [censored] load quicker then Bail who some mention has so call pace!? Something I have never seen him use at all in his time at the Dees.

Terry Wallace did a comparison on the TAC show a month ago on who's list he'd rather have and he chose Melbourne over the Saints. Everything he mentioned hit the nail on the head and was absolutely spot on.

Well Robbo mentioned that we were obviously into Treloar and have offered a bit of money to him along with 3 other clubs.When he tried to bait Bucks he played a pretty straight bat. Kept pestering whether Treloar had told Collingwood he wants to come and all Bucks said was he is still a GWS player and we (collingwood) are still going through our season with the exit interviews. Buckley just simply would not budge at all.

It was wasn't it.Whats your personal opinion? I think we will definitely have a chat to him and due a due diligence for sure. Roosy did say he was an extremely talented player the type we need on our list.

He is Collingwood bound no doubt after the way Buckley just carried on.