dazzledavey36

Pedersen is due back at the start of the VFL finals

No reports had them as aggressive, you just made that up.

If thats the case i think he is gone.

How can you make that staggering comment if you haven't even watched him play. Doesn't even dominate TAC level.. i will be very surprised if we rookie him. Go for the best available talent.

Parish for sure.

What are you on about you absolute peanut!? Col showed nothing in his first couple of years to suggest he was on the verge of being a superstar. What did you like about his amazing 1 handball debut game? Hogan has already shown he has the makings of the next J Brown. Like all young players he has flaws he needs to work on but he has the right attitude and work ethic to do.Col doesn't and never did. Is that to much for your pea little brain to work that out? FMD!

Wow.. quoting yourself.. Yea comparing a first year player who is only 20 years old and played only 14 games to a guy that kicked his missus in the face and got on the turps hard every weekend.. plus the laziness and lack of work ethis Col showed his whole career.. right..Try again

Pfft rightio mate.Hogan has already achieved more in one season then Col did in his whole career

My biggest pet hate and one thing that pisses me off is that we bring in the likes of Harmes Riley Vandenberg ANB Newton and even Brayshaw who are all good inside attacking midfielders and they leave them on a half forward for majority of games. give the likes of VandenBerg and Harmes a decent crack in the middle even ANB aswell. They have proven at VFL level they can win big numbers of the ball yet they think its better to plonk them on a half forward and leave them there for most of the game..! Look at Vandenberg when he played as an on baller all game against WB. 29 Disposals 10 tackles and a big reason why we won the game because of his ferocity at the contests and hardness.

Have you even watched him play..? Absolutely nothing like Bont. Infact he is a complete opposite.He needs a fair bit of work on his disposal and cleaness of the ball. No thanks we have enough of them

18 months into his tenure and I feel we still haven't improved much from 2014.. yeah are one win ahead but his game plan is simply pathetic. Club like GWS WB and St Kilda are ahead of us in development and game style. They play a fast and free flowing game where we still play a very one minded defensive game plan. Roosy needs to seriously consider whether he wants to go on ahead next year. I was a big advocate for him going around again but i can't simply see us improving much at all next year if he keeps going the way he is. I seriously hope Goodwin brings in a much more attacking style.. This St Kilda is the last straw for me this year. Not watching any more games. Why should supporters sit through this and watch us stink it up with a dull and boring game plan.

Jeez would it hurt to throw Vandenberg in the middle to get him into the game? We drafted him as an inside ball winning machine and the Einsteins think its best to plonk him in the forward line.. unbelievable Btw this game plan is a bag of horse [censored]

Been saying ever since we recruited him.. Chris Dawes is plain and simply a spud! How he manages to get a get is pathetic.

Good golly we are a pathetic football club.. Garland played way too loose on Reiwoldt and showed no respect whats so ever! Pathetic

So much for stretch being tired last week.. would have been ideal for a sub and conditions suit Michie.. Disappointing again

Coming from a bloke that wants to trade Christian Salem because he gets injured all the time.... Riiiight cant take you seriously

Very very shallow draft.. if its one year to trade out an early pick it would be this year.

For a midfielder its unfortunately not good enough.Personally i think we will overlook him.

Or just do us all the good favour and ban the F log

Greatest comeback in games history? Lol kidding right? Good on him if he comes back but bit thats a bit of a stretch mate.. Our very own David Schwarz came back from 3 knee recos and won a best and fairest. Daniel Menzel is another who has been through absolute hell with his knee injuries is another who is defying the odds at the moment. Mitch Clark missed more games then trenners.. just saying..

Just stop..Max ain't getting traded and that's simple.

Is that your personal opinion or you have inside knowledge?

Your sources are usually spot on so i believe this 100%

And to think some idiots last week wanted him dropped. Classic Demonland..

So you rate him as a A grader now