My 3 word player analysis V the Lies

[joeboy 3,166]

Brown - continued his reformation

Carroll - solid under fire

Holland - outstanding until injured

Bell - loose until injured

Ferguson - was surprisingly composed

Johnstone - played without passion

McDonald - inspired by occasion

Bate - disappointing yet again

Davey - continued poor season

Robertson - had little influence

Pickett - aggressive but unfit

Neitz - truly captain's game

Jamar - better second half

Sylvia - penny finally dropped

Dunn - some exciting moments

White - disappointed when needed

Jones - superlatives keep coming

Green - showed his class

Newton - showing his versatility

Wheatley - always under pressure

Bode - played his part

McLean - needed more involvement

[Guest unstable punt]

Brown - continued his reformation

Carroll - solid under fire

Holland - outstanding until injured

Bell - loose until injured

Ferguson - was surprisingly composed

Johnstone - played without passion

McDonald - inspired by occasion

Bate - disappointing yet again

Davey - continued poor season

Robertson - had little influence

Pickett - aggressive but unfit

Neitz - truly captain's game

Jamar - better second half

Sylvia - penny finally dropped

Dunn - some exciting moments

White - disappointed when needed

Jones - superlatives keep coming

Green - showed his class

Newton - showing his versatility

Wheatley - always under pressure

Bode - played his part

McLean - needed more involvement

Bate, Davey and Robbo were playing injured

[drdrake 3,187]

Bit harsh on TJ, I thought when he came on he worked his backside off and was one of our better players. White and Jamar got beaten by to very average ruckman tinight, Jeff White is one of the most selfish footballers at the MFC, would be nice if he put his body on the line like our skipper does week in week out and not just get easy touches standing by himself on the wing.

[Gorgoroth 13,021]

Brown - continued his reformation (of what turning the ball over, handballing to someone in a worse position, the guy is terrible)

Carroll - solid under fire (agree)

Holland - outstanding until injured (agree)

Bell - loose until injured (didnt notice him, but didn't notice didak either so thats ok)

Ferguson - was surprisingly composed (still should be delisted)

Johnstone - played without passion (do not agree, set up quite a few shots on goal for us)

McDonald - inspired by occasion (i think neitz was right by aying give junior the captaincy for 2 years then to brock)

Bate - disappointing yet again (ducks his head when someone is behind him and then drops the mark)

Davey - continued poor season (he was ok early, but like last week they need to tell him to stay around the F50)

Robertson - had little influence (should not have played, and i hope he doe not for the rest of the year)

Pickett - aggressive but unfit (was good at times, i think the injuries affected him most due to not getting a rest which is not good enough for AFL level)

Neitz - truly captain's game (if only the players gave as much as he does)

Jamar - better second half (useless, couldn't beat their dud ruckman)

Sylvia - penny finally dropped (pray he gets over the op, he will be a gun if he does)

Dunn - some exciting moments (i like the idea of him through the midfield, will bneed time to adjust)

White - disappointed when needed (stood up for his own milestone, pity he doesn't for others)

Jones - superlatives keep coming (only 1 problem, need to slam the ball onto the boot instead of trying to break tackles)

Green - showed his class (playes in the backline early on, why????)

Newton - showing his (agree, his attack on the ball through the pack from the wing was great to watch)

Wheatley - always under pressure (his desicion making in the last few weeks has only been better than browns, which is terrible)

Bode - played his part (did well on medhurst, who was ok against the tigers)

McLean - needed more involvement (needs to get fit, when he came on got some nice clearances, but is not up to running a game out)

[titan_uranus 25,043]

Brown - continued his reformation

Carroll - solid under fire

Holland - outstanding until injured

Bell - loose until injured

Ferguson - was surprisingly composed

Johnstone - played without passion

McDonald - inspired by occasion

Bate - disappointing yet again

Davey - continued poor season

Robertson - had little influence

Pickett - aggressive but unfit

Neitz - truly captain's game

Jamar - better second half

Sylvia - penny finally dropped

Dunn - some exciting moments

White - disappointed when needed

Jones - superlatives keep coming

Green - showed his class

Newton - showing his versatility

Wheatley - always under pressure

Bode - played his part

McLean - needed more involvement

Robbo - poor coaching. Needed to go deep forward when we were being slaughtered to give us another option so we weren't Neitz-centric. And then when he got injured he could hardly move, Thomas got a goal becuase he couldnt move to take a mark. He had to be put at FF or benched

White & Newton - completely agree

Bode - what part is that? had no influence at all really, but not his fault its only his second game