1 minute ago, Young Blood said:

This is somewhat comforting from Cal in his late mail re the Sharp conundrum:

Cumming, Robey, Taylor and Farrow are all in the Bombers' mix for their pair of picks, as well as Dyson Sharp, who could be available at their third pick but the Bombers would run the risk of the Demons snapping him up or trading the pick to a suitor like Adelaide if they do that. Essendon will be waiting to see who the Tigers grab as they remain keen on the same batch of players.  

Glad to see it spelled out that we would threaten to trade the pick to others keen on Sharp (Adelaide/Pies). First time I've seen Cal mention any possibility that we would consider Sharp when he mentions we might be 'snapping him up' if they don't get him with their first two picks but I think thats just a throwaway line.

I will be stoked with Farrow he looks like he could be a gun.

Don't think Essendon can risk not taking Sharp if they really rate him

I hate how Twomey knows exactly how the top 10 or so will go. Where’s the fun in that!!!!

It’s like knowing what you are getting for Xmas 😡 😡

What would Richmond want for (what becomes) Pick 7?

Edited 12 hours ago12 hr by The Taciturn Demon

22 minutes ago, The Taciturn Demon said:

What would Richmond want for (what becomes) Pick 7?

Too much; look what they charged for pick ~25 in last year’s draft

41 minutes ago, adonski said:

Cal's late mail still has us with Farrow and Nairn

LATE MAIL PHANTOM DRAFT

Pick 1 – West Coast: Willem Duursma
Pick 2 – Gold Coast: Zeke Uwland (matching West Coast's bid)
Pick 3 – Carlton: Harry Dean (matching West Coast's bid)
Pick 4 – West Coast: Cooper Duff Tytler
Pick 5 – Gold Coast: Dylan Patterson (matching Richmond's bid)
Pick 6 – Brisbane: Daniel Annable (matching Richmond's bid)
Pick 7 – Richmond: Sam Cumming
Pick 8 – Richmond: Sullivan Robey
Pick 9 – Essendon: Xavier Taylor
Pick 10 – Essendon: Dyson Sharp 
Pick 11 – Melbourne: Jacob Farrow
Pick 12 – Melbourne: Cam Nairn
Pick 13 – Essendon: Lachy Dovaston
Pick 14 – Hawthorn: Sam Grlj
Pick 15 – North Melbourne: Latrelle Pickett
Pick 16 – Sydney: Harry Kyle (matching GWS's bid)
Pick 17 – Greater Western Sydney: Oskar Taylor
Pick 18 – Gold Coast: Jai Murray (matching West Coast's bid)
Pick 19 – West Coast: Beau Addinsall
Pick 20 – Western Bulldogs: Josh Lindsay
Pick 21 – Adelaide: Mitch Marsh
Pick 22 – Carlton: Jack Ison (matching Geelong's bid)
Pick 23 – Geelong: Blake Thredgold
Pick 24 – West Coast: Tylah Williams (matching Fremantle's bid)
Pick 25 – Essendon: Adam Sweid (matching Fremantle's bid)
Pick 26 – Fremantle: Aidan Schubert
Pick 27 – Hawthorn: Liam Hetherton
Pick 28 – North Melbourne: Harley Barker
Pick 29 – Sydney: Lachie Carmichael (matching Western Bulldogs' bid)
Pick 30 – Western Bulldogs: Louis Emmett

Can I propose that when Nairn scores a goal dees fans all start singing:

Nairn, Nairn, Nairn na na na Nairn, na na na Nairn, hey Cam

Anyone not convinced Farrow will be a superstar needs to remind themselves we will select him with what was originally St. Kilda's draft pick

Ha ha. Fair.

Gosh, Matt Whitlock would want to be good.

I wonder why Sam Grlj dropped down a few rungs?

The Hawks will love him if it drops that way.

I thought his highlight package looked exciting.

11 minutes ago, Roy Boy said:

I wonder why Sam Grlj dropped down a few rungs?

The Hawks will love him if it drops that way.

I thought his highlight package looked exciting.

Yes agreed. Grlj has pace to break the lines and plenty of repeat efforts. He can turn defence into attack really quickly. Not sure why he wouldn’t suit the new King style of play. Maybe clubs see him more as Billy Hartung than Zac Butters !!

Genuinely know very little about this years draft crop but we’ve really missed Pig since he retired. If we take Farrow, I’m hopeful that he can play a similar role.

Hard working HB with a decent leg and intercept mark. Sign me up.

Structurally we’ve missed a player in the back half who switch play aggressively and with distance.

We also miss another small forward who can convert chances into goals.

32 minutes ago, Roy Boy said:

I wonder why Sam Grlj dropped down a few rungs?

The Hawks will love him if it drops that way.

I thought his highlight package looked exciting.

As likely to be Oskar Baker as he is Zak Butters

21 minutes ago, JJJ said:

Genuinely know very little about this years draft crop but we’ve really missed Pig since he retired. If we take Farrow, I’m hopeful that he can play a similar role.

Hard working HB with a decent leg and intercept mark. Sign me up.

Structurally we’ve missed a player in the back half who switch play aggressively and with distance.

We also miss another small forward who can convert chances into goals.

Hibs leg was good but it's not what made him great.

He was all heart and grit. Hated losing a contest. Thats what we miss.

Pig was seriously underrated. He could defend on a small or tall, had great physicality, a lethal boot and loved to attack.

[censored] we had a great defence in 2021.

1 hour ago, Roy Boy said:

I wonder why Sam Grlj dropped down a few rungs?

The Hawks will love him if it drops that way.

I thought his highlight package looked exciting.

Because he plays his best footy off the half back, mid who can go fwd or fwds who can develop into mids are much more valued

2 hours ago, adonski said:

Don't think Essendon can risk not taking Sharp if they really rate him

We may well be interested in Sharp especially as our 2 prime inside bulls are now Vines and Steele heading towards the twilight but right now still strong contributors.

Langford will likely be a very strong inside player in a year or 2.

I would not be surprised if we pick up Sharp is available at our picks.

I am hoping for Farrow and Nairn.

Edited 10 hours ago10 hr by manny100
accidently left off last sentence.

On 13/11/2025 at 17:17, Demongirl35 said:

if we can convince Eagles to trade for a pick in the 20s.

1 hour ago, binman said:

Can I propose that when Nairn scores a goal dees fans all start singing:

Nairn, Nairn, Nairn na na na Nairn, na na na Nairn, hey Cam

Now I really hope we get him. That'd be an amazing chant.

6 hours ago, DeeSpencer said:

Whilst they might not be express pace McCluggage and Ashcroft are 2 of the best at exploding out the front of stoppages. And Brisbane often add Bailey on ball or up at stoppages.

Neale and Dunkley I’ll give you but Brisbane maximise their value/minimise their disadvantages by Neale dominating in close and Dunkley locking down on the oppositions best mid.

If we do draft Sharp I’d try to utilise him just as the Lions do Dunkley. As a defensive mid at stoppages and stretching opponents in space with good work rate and overhead marking.

Sharp is nothing like a defensive mid. He's a see ball -get ball player. Hits the contect running. More Rowell like than most others

12 minutes ago, stinga said:

Sharp is nothing like a defensive mid. He's a see ball -get ball player. Hits the contect running. More Rowell like than most others

So is Josh Dunkley but he sacrificed his game because his ball use and movement aren’t as dangerous as others.

3 hours ago, fr_ap said:

Hibs leg was good but it's not what made him great.

He was all heart and grit. Hated losing a contest. Thats what we miss.

The unbridled ecstasy and joy Pig exhibited racing around with the Cup is indelibly stamped in my memory.

Twas glorious..

Could we find another of such ilk..... id be ecstatic.

I have no idea whether our impending picks are good bad or meh... I do have a suspicion someone is going to throw a couple of spanners early.

King and Co have a game in mind. Im hoping JT etc understand the brief maybhave changed from 12 months ago.

Not expecting much in 26bfrom anyone drafted..... but I want them to push and incentivate those already encamped.

Go us