May be offered pick 11 (15) for Judd and Taj though. With something going back their way ?

Edited 23 hours ago23 hr by Viscount Cardwell
added content

4 hours ago, Viscount Cardwell said:

May be offered pick 11 (15) for Judd and Taj though. With something going back their way ?

i doubt very much that they will want woey 2.0

Edited 18 hours ago18 hr by whatwhat say what

6 hours ago, Mouseymoo said:

Does his Lordship deem timing be appropriate to grace us with his decision now?

5 hours ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

Forum members: Windhager is a jet, but only worth a late second rounder.

Also forum members: McVee is a solid contributor, he’s not even that good. But pick 11 will become 15. We need more than that.

Giving the opportunity i imagine him being another Jordan Clarke,that will hurt us next year

6 hours ago, DeeSpencer said:

No one is giving us 11 for an uncontracted McVee, be serious people. Early second is the best we can get.

King has to go pitch him on moving up the ground in a Geelong style game plan that sees the ball shared quickly and skilfully that suits Judd. Give me 2 years and I’ll have you as the next Max Holmes is the message I’d sell if I was King.

I have an eerie feeling Windsor is going to pan out as something similar to Jayden Hunt. Fast but an absolute butcher by foot. I hope like hell im wrong, but there are some worrying signs. I didnt think Holmes was a super good ball user when he was initially drafted so i guess there is hope for the Duke just yet.

1 hour ago, GS_1905 said:

I have an eerie feeling Windsor is going to pan out as something similar to Jayden Hunt. Fast but an absolute butcher by foot. I hope like hell im wrong, but there are some worrying signs. I didnt think Holmes was a super good ball user when he was initially drafted so i guess there is hope for the Duke just yet.

Caleb has a nice hit up kick in him when he has time to process, his terrible kicks come when he runs in to trouble.

Bailey Smith is showing right now how valuable a super quick mid is even if they can’t hit the side of the barn.

If - and it’s a decent if - Caleb can become a genuine ball winning mid he should kick it at least as well as Smith.

But also that’s why Judd is so important to keep because he has excellent decision making and disposal. King has to find a way to convince him he’ll develop in to a star at Melbourne

18 hours ago, 58er said:

Was Juddy at the B and F night?

i spoke to him as the no 1 member of the judd mcvee fan club and he told me he was waiting for the new coach announcement (hes probably lying)

lets hope!

1 hour ago, GS_1905 said:

I have an eerie feeling Windsor is going to pan out as something similar to Jayden Hunt. Fast but an absolute butcher by foot. I hope like hell im wrong, but there are some worrying signs. I didnt think Holmes was a super good ball user when he was initially drafted so i guess there is hope for the Duke just yet.

So either a journeyman or an important player who won a team b+f?

Oh I hope in this binary world - we get the latter. Or put more succinctly:

10011100101011100010100110110101010

That joke works on one level

This mystery should be put to bed pretty soon.

7 hours ago, Viscount Cardwell said:

Agree, Freo will offer pick 29, which may end up pick 35 and a swap of 3rd round picks. Not sure how he's conned ghosty that he is re-signing, its dragged on far too long.

If you’re gonna be an ignorant smartarze at least tag me so as I get to read it. I almost missed this. Judd is not one to con someone. Do you know him at all? Thought not.

Interesting we’ve only offered 2 years.. although a very good player club may see him as tradeable if we can get what we want I think..

18 minutes ago, Jakkaa said:

Interesting we’ve only offered 2 years.. although a very good player club may see him as tradeable if we can get what we want

19 minutes ago, Jakkaa said:

Interesting we’ve only offered 2 years.. although a very good player club may see him as tradeable if we can get what we want I think..

20 minutes ago, Jakkaa said:

Interesting we’ve only offered 2 years.. although a very good player club may see him as tradeable if we can get what we want I think..

Edited 14 hours ago14 hr by doomsday dee
Wrong

His original contract was 4

10 hours ago, Jakkaa said:

Interesting we’ve only offered 2 years.. although a very good player club may see him as tradeable if we can get what we want I think..

Is this true? Have we revised the offer?

I don’t really get how this contract is having so many people up in arms. I love Judd but his performance this year was significantly lowered to past times, unknown why.

Hes a B grade player, with probably A grade ball use.

If we lose him, it’s a shame, however if we get another player or similar caliber then we will be fine.

We also have AMW coming back into the team after his injury and they’re very similar.

So please , where are these contracts details available Are they on line somewhere or is it hear say. A friend of my mate dirt if thing. Or is it from the mouth of thr horse running at Caulfield or will train at Caulfield I hope!

5 minutes ago, GawnOfTheDead said:

I don’t really get how this contract is having so many people up in arms. I love Judd but his performance this year was significantly lowered to past times, unknown why.

Hes a B grade player, with probably A grade ball use.

If we lose him, it’s a shame, however if we get another player or similar caliber then we will be fine.

We also have AMW coming back into the team after his injury and they’re very similar.

I think that underates him considering as a team we lack good ball users. Remember his preseason was largely ruined with a serious hamstring injury and he was playing as a lock down defender which isn't his best position, that's where I hope AMW fits into the team. As a running HB and distributor I think we have a really good player and I'm hoping he stays.

12 minutes ago, Roost it far said:

I think that underates him considering as a team we lack good ball users. Remember his preseason was largely ruined with a serious hamstring injury and he was playing as a lock down defender which isn't his best position, that's where I hope AMW fits into the team. As a running HB and distributor I think we have a really good player and I'm hoping he stays.

I’d value AMW as a far more attacking player than Judd.

Judd is becoming very Salem like with his ball use, it’s safe but not damaging

On 12/09/2025 at 07:52, JJJ said:

there were a few whispers on Tuesday night that we are trying to get back into the top 10 of the draft

lol we are first round junkies

12 hours ago, juddmcveegoat said:

i spoke to him as the no 1 member of the judd mcvee fan club and he told me he was waiting for the new coach announcement (hes probably lying)

lets hope!

Reckon I would be ahead of you for that title !!!🤨

Luci is fan! Got it !!!

Edited 3 hours ago3 hr by Lucifers Hero

17 minutes ago, The Jackson FIX said:

lol we are first round junkies

if we keep future trading up every year then we'll never not have a first round pick...

there's always talented kids available

51 minutes ago, whatwhat say what said:

if we keep future trading up every year then we'll never not have a first round pick...

there's always talented kids available

I think the real issue is when you trade up and give away a lot to get a certain player, you need to actually get that player and then he has to be worthy of what you gave up.

As recent examples, Lindsay looks the goods, while Kolt is looking a little shaky.

To be a successful club we need to nail most decisions and recruiting is an extremely important area for every club.

I do accept that not every selected player will have a long AFL career but the overall aim has to be improving the list every year.

2 hours ago, Lucifers Hero said:

Reckon I would be ahead of you for that title !!!🤨

Luci is fan! Got it !!!

Soz @juddmcveegoat, love you ‘n’ all but Luci’s got you on this one. She’s been Judd’s #1 fan since the beginning. You’ll have to settle on being his #2 fan.

Mind you, she did dump Jayden for Salo, then dumped Salo for Judd, so stick around, she may just ditch Judd for someone else 😅

If she thinks she’s gonna be Luker’s #1 fan, the gloves are off. Word.

1 minute ago, Ghostwriter said:

Soz @juddmcveegoat, love you ‘n’ all but Luci’s got you on this one. She’s been Judd’s #1 fan since the beginning. You’ll have to settle on being his #2 fan.

Mind you, she did dump Jayden for Salo, then dumped Salo for Judd, so stick around, she may just ditch Judd for someone else 😅

If she thinks she’s gonna be Luker’s #1 fan, the gloves are off. Word.

Look below my avatar, Salem and Hunt are still favourites!

Luker is all yours❣️

2 hours ago, BW511 said:

I’d value AMW as a far more attacking player than Judd.

Judd is becoming very Salem like with his ball use, it’s safe but not damaging

Well its to different roles,one is a running back with alot more freedom and the other is a lock where you can't just run off and leave,say Cameron or Bobby Hill alone

2 minutes ago, Lucifers Hero said:

Look below my avatar, Salem and Hunt are still favourites!

Luker is all yours❣️

Your favourite players game is on point… a brilliant selection! ❤️💙