5 minutes ago, Turner said:

eggmolese-smith definitely worth a year. he looked a real player if u give him a chance in the team imo

Yeah really surprised he was delisted.  Thought the games I watched him play he was very impressive with his run and dash off half back.

25 minutes ago, Better days ahead said:

Were those 9 tackles an outlier or is he typically a tackling machine? If typical then he has to get a run in the side sooner rather than later. Forward half pressure is something we’re sorely lacking.

Definitely an outlier, although he's still a fairly prolific tackler. He averaged 4 tackles a game last year in the VFL across 16 games. He was not a prolific ball winner up forward but he was a strong tackler. 

1 hour ago, Turner said:

eggmolese-smith definitely worth a year. he looked a real player if u give him a chance in the team imo

Agree. I was surprised that he was delisted.  I guess that shows you how strong the Tigers are and how RUTHLESS you have to be. He’s worthy of a rookie spot imv.  

Heath Shaw for a year, help Riv and Salo in the backline could be worth a look. 
leadership qualities. 

2 hours ago, spirit of norm smith said:

Agree. I was surprised that he was delisted.  I guess that shows you how strong the Tigers are and how RUTHLESS you have to be. He’s worthy of a rookie spot imv.  

i've said it before but i actually don't think there has ever been a player we've disagreed on

Yep, also surprised the Egg was dropped.

Guess there was no room for him with Short, Houli, Vlastuin, Baker and even Stack when he’s not tucking into kebabs. 

He’s my favourite delisted free agent so far.

Lachie Schultz has been de-listed from Freo,with a promise to re-rookie. I liked his games in the back half of this year. Victorian boy and a small forward.

9 hours ago, ben russell said:

Yep, also surprised the Egg was dropped.

Guess there was no room for him with Short, Houli, Vlastuin, Baker and even Stack when he’s not tucking into kebabs. 

He’s my favourite delisted free agent so far.

Agree. Type of player we need (a creative wing/half back with good skills and good pace) and could be ready to go for 2021.   I thought he looked ok when called up by the Tigers this year. 

jacob townsend is one of the great survivors and the suns are still just the placed to go when no one else will give u a contract. and i thought CEllis, Horlin-Smith, Miles and aaron young out was the end of those type of deals for them but markov, atkins and now townsend are such stinky signings + theyre still carrying hombsch, holman (who has been serviceable) and jordon murdoch (ik who right). they dont need 49 list spots if one of them is going to jacob townsend ffs

The number of players delisted this  year is amazing.  Whilst the lists are being reduced, some clubs have got down to 35 players (pies and Roos) so they can add 9 additional players through DFA, draft or rookie draft lists. I think clubs will use the next few weeks to scan the DFAs or keep a 1-2 spots vacant and add players to train on lists for possible SSP selection prior to the start of the year. 

21 hours ago, Roger Mellie said:

Lachie Schultz has been de-listed from Freo,with a promise to re-rookie. I liked his games in the back half of this year. Victorian boy and a small forward.

I'm not someone who obsesses over DFAs and would generally give an untried kid a spot on the list through the draft, but Schultz is a tackling machine and would be our best defensive forward straight away. He always looks threatening around goal, and at the feet of Brown, Weideman and Jackson, he may get more opportunities than he would at Freo. Surely a 2 year deal, a return to Victoria and a spot on our list would trump a year on Freo's rookie list?

8 minutes ago, Tough Kent said:

I'm not someone who obsesses over DFAs and would generally give an untried kid a spot on the list through the draft, but Schultz is a tackling machine and would be our best defensive forward straight away. He always looks threatening around goal, and at the feet of Brown, Weideman and Jackson, he may get more opportunities than he would at Freo. Surely a 2 year deal, a return to Victoria and a spot on our list would trump a year on Freo's rookie list?

A number of players have been delisted recently as a result of rule changes relating to rookies. I understand that Shultz is one of those players and he will be automatically put on the Dockers’ rookie list with the consent of the player and club. Your suggestion is therefore most unlikely.

1 hour ago, rumpole said:

A number of players have been delisted recently as a result of rule changes relating to rookies. I understand that Shultz is one of those players and he will be automatically put on the Dockers’ rookie list with the consent of the player and club. Your suggestion is therefore most unlikely.

Bummer, it would have been nice to return the favour when Freo rookied Jack Hannath a while back after we had promised to rookie him.

1 hour ago, rumpole said:

A number of players have been delisted recently as a result of rule changes relating to rookies. I understand that Shultz is one of those players and he will be automatically put on the Dockers’ rookie list with the consent of the player and club. Your suggestion is therefore most unlikely.

Cant we offer him a senior spot? If he is any good. Could be an upgrade on a few small forwards we already have

From Chris Doerre (Knightmare) The ultimate transfer of wealth - the AFL delisted free agents clubs should target

Forgive me if this has been posted before

Edited November 26, 20204 yr by TRIGON

4 hours ago, Tough Kent said:

I'm not someone who obsesses over DFAs and would generally give an untried kid a spot on the list through the draft, but Schultz is a tackling machine and would be our best defensive forward straight away. He always looks threatening around goal, and at the feet of Brown, Weideman and Jackson, he may get more opportunities than he would at Freo. Surely a 2 year deal, a return to Victoria and a spot on our list would trump a year on Freo's rookie list?

he is purely a victim of circumstances, well and truly entrenched in the best 22 this season but they only had very few OOC players after their initial list changes.no doubt players like giro, switkowski, colyer etc had they been ooc would have been move instead but as he was ooc he had to drop down. theyll find a way to take him straight back up next season

4 hours ago, TRIGON said:

From Chris Doerre (Knightmare) The ultimate transfer of wealth - the AFL delisted free agents clubs should target

Forgive me if this has been posted before

But some of these blokes are already claimed - Hateley to the Crows - or will be rookied by their club Birchall, Gleeson, Ballenden, Kennedy.  Strange analysis by the Knightmare!

21 hours ago, spirit of norm smith said:

The number of players delisted this  year is amazing.  Whilst the lists are being reduced, some clubs have got down to 35 players (pies and Roos) so they can add 9 additional players through DFA, draft or rookie draft lists. I think clubs will use the next few weeks to scan the DFAs or keep a 1-2 spots vacant and add players to train on lists for possible SSP selection prior to the start of the year. 

I think that clubs will probably keep a spot for the supplemental place like we did with Mitch Brown and Bennell.  Get them to train over the summer and see who excites.  Given the nature of the draft, there might be some that have higher risk that dont get drafted that need to be closely looked at over the pre-season.  Hopefully we can find a diamond in the rough and hold one spot for SPP and get them to prove themselves over the summer.  It nearly worked with Bennell. I would then use mid season draft to top up from mature leagues to cover any injury gaps.

Is there a current list of DFA's for perusal?

adelaideBrisbaneCarltonCollingwood

Rory Atkins (FA)
Ben Crocker (del)
Brad Crouch (FA)
Jordan Gallucci (del)
Bryce Gibbs (ret)
Kyle Hartigan (trd)
Riley Knight (del)
Myles Poholke (del)
Ayce Taylor (del)
Patrick Wilson (del)

Jacob Allison (del)
Connor Ballenden (del)*
Grant Birchall (del)*
Allen Christensen (ret)
Cedric Cox (del)
Matt Eagles (del)
Mitch Hinge (DFA)
Corey Lyons (del)
Stefan Martin (trd)
Rhys Mathieson (del)*
Sam Skinner (del)
Alex Witherden (trd)
Toby Wooller (del)

Hugh Goddard (del)
Matthew Kennedy (del)*
Matthew Kreuzer (ret)
Darcy Lang (del)
Harrison Macreadie (del)
Callum Moore (del)
Finbar O'Dwyer (del)
Fraser Phillips (del)
Cameron Polson (del)
Ben Silvagni (del)
Kade Simpson (ret)

Flynn Appleby (del)
Dayne Beams (ret)
Atu Bosenavulagi (trd)
Tim Broomhead (del)
Lynden Dunn (ret)
Tom Phillips (trd)
Ben Reid (ret) 
Matthew Scharenberg (del)
Jaidyn Stephenson (trd)
Adam Treloar (trd)
Travis Varcoe (ret)
Rupert Wills (del)

EssendonFremantleGeelongGold Coast

Josh Begley (del)
Tom Bellchambers (ret)
Dylan Clarke (del)*
Henry Crauford (del)
Joe Daniher (FA)
Orazio Fantasia (trd)
Marty Gleeson (del)*
Noah Gown (del)
Mitch Hibberd (del)
Conor McKenna (ret) 
Shaun McKernan (FA)
Kobe Mutch (del)
Adam Saad (trd)
Jacob Townsend (del)

Bailey Banfield (del)*
Brett Bewley (del)*
Isaiah Butters (del)
Jason Carter (del)
Hugh Dixon (del)
Jesse Hogan (trd)
Brandon Matera (del)
Cam McCarthy (del)
Tom North (del)
Dillon O'Reilly (del)
Jarvis Pina (del)
Lachie Schultz (del)*

Gary Ablett (ret)
Nakia Cocktatoo (trd)
Lachie Fogarty (trd)
Jacob Kennerley (del)
James Parsons (del)
Jack Steven (ret)
Jake Tarca (del)
Harry Taylor (ret)

Jacob Dawson (del)
Corey Ellis (del)
Sam Fletcher (del)
Pearce Hanley (ret)
Jacob Heron (del)
George Horlin-Smith (ret)
Jesse Joyce (del)
Anthony Miles (ret)
Mitch Riordan (del)
Josh Schoenfeld (del)
Peter Wright (trd)

GWSHawthornMelbourneNorth Melbourne

Jye Caldwell (trd)
Jeremy Cameron (trd)
Aidan Corr (FA)
Jackson Hately (del)
Sam Jacobs (ret)
Zac Langdon (trd)
Sam Reid (del)*
Heath Shaw (del)
Tom Sheridan (ret)
Zach Sproule (del)
Zac Williams (FA)

James Frawley (DFA)
Conor Glass (ret)
Will Golds (del)
Ricky Henderson (ret)
Harry Jones (del)
Darren Minchington (del)
Dylan Moore (del)*
Paul Puopolo (ret)
Jackson Ross (del)
Isaac Smith (FA)
Ben Stratton (ret)
Mat Walker (del)

Harley Bennell (ret)
Kyle Dunkley (del)
Mitch Hannan (trd)
Kade Kolodjashnij (ret)
Oscar McDonald (del)
Aaron Nietschke (del)*
Braydon Preuss (trd)
Corey Wagner (del)
Josh Wagner (del)

Paul Ahern (del)
Ben Brown (trd)
Joel Crocker (del)
Majak Daw (del)
Sam Durdin (del)
Shaun Higgins (trd)
Lachie Hosie (del)
Ben Jacobs (del)
Jamie Macmillan (del)
Tom Murphy (del)
Jasper Pittard (del)
Will Walker (del)*
Ed Vickers-Willis (del)
Marley Williams (del)
Mason Wood (del)
 

Port AdelaideRichmondSt KildaSydney

Joe Atley (del)
Wylie Buzza (del)
Tobin Cox (del)
Brad Ebert (ret)
Riley Grundy (del)
Jake Patmore (del)
Cam Sutcliffe (del)
Jack Watts (ret)
Justin Westhoff (ret)

Derek Eggmolesse-Smith (del)
Luke English (del)
Jack Higgins (trd)
Oleg Markov (trd)
Fraser Turner (del)

Ryan Abbott (del)
Logan Austin (del)
Jack Bell (del)
Nathan Brown (ret)
Nick Hind (trd)
Doulton Langlands (del)
Jonathon Marsh (del)
Jack Mayo (del)
Shane Savage (del)
Matthew Parker (del)
Ed Phillips (del)
Shane Savage (del)

Aliir Aliir (trd)
Zac Foot (del)
Robbie Fox (del)
Sam Gray (del)*
Michael Knoll (del)
Jack Maibaum (del)
Harry Reynolds (del)
Brady Rowles (del)
Ryley Stoddart (del)
Jackson Thurlow (del)

West CoastWestern Bulldogs  

Hamish Brayshaw (del)
Tom Hickey (trd)
Lewis Jetta (del)
Mitch O'Neill (del)
Nic Reid (del)
Will Schofield (ret)
Anthony Treacy (del)
Francis Watson (del)

Ben Cavarra (del)
Tory Dickson (ret)
Billy Gowers (del)
Fergus Greene (del)
Will Hayes (del)
Brad Lynch (del)
Callum Porter (del)
Roarke Smith (del)*
Matt Suckling (del)
Jackson Trengove (del)
Lachie Young (trd)

  

On 11/26/2020 at 8:27 AM, Roger Mellie said:

Lachie Schultz has been de-listed from Freo,with a promise to re-rookie. I liked his games in the back half of this year. Victorian boy and a small forward.

Isn't Venables from  WC in the same  position?

Why can't another club offer these guys a senior contract what's the rule here?

9 minutes ago, Kent said:

Isn't Venables from  WC in the same  position?

Why can't another club offer these guys a senior contract what's the rule here?

I think they can:

https://www.afl.com.au/news/525883/confirmed-hinge-on-crows-list-after-rejecting-brisbane-deal

 

19 minutes ago, Kent said:

Isn't Venables from  WC in the same  position?

Why can't another club offer these guys a senior contract what's the rule here?

venables has long term concussion symptoms like KK but is still on the senior list but theyll be able to make him inactive and then replace him with a SSP pick

3 hours ago, Roger Mellie said:

I think they can:

https://www.afl.com.au/news/525883/confirmed-hinge-on-crows-list-after-rejecting-brisbane-deal

 

So we could offer Shultz a 2 year deal

23 hours ago, Kent said:

So we could offer Shultz a 2 year deal

No point now that Hogan’s gone...