MFC Trade Talk 2020

[Lil_red_fire_engine 11,367]

We need a small defensive stopper to replace Jetta, possibly a second wingman, a second natural small forward and a mature back up key forward. The question is whether we believe these players already exist on our list and the importance of filling the role vs $$$ we’ll spend. If Saad is any chance of leaving Essendon he is where I would prioritise. Possibly the best pound for pound defender in the game and also provides great attacking run. However as raised we dont have draft currency to make it happen. I am a massive fan of Zach Williams and he could also fill this role and provide great variation across our midfield but I question his durability. He is a free agent so we could make it happen if we could convince him and shuffle the cash. Otherwise with list reductions and lower spending I would just be looking for the right player that maybe is not getting opportunity at his to fall our way. Whilst In contract one that I would look at Is Jack Sinclair at StKilda. Seems to be on the outer, offers good carry, speed and polish and Is quality both on wing and as forward, Richo would Also be in the known. As far as tall forwards go I am comfortable to invest in a combo of Weid, TMac, Jackson, Petty and not spend the cash. It is showing more that there is less need to spend big $$$ on your big forwards to gain success.

[58er 6,870]

40 minutes ago, big_red_fire_engine said:

We need a small defensive stopper to replace Jetta, possibly a second wingman, a second natural small forward and a mature back up key forward. The question is whether we believe these players already exist on our list and the importance of filling the role vs $$$ we’ll spend. If Saad is any chance of leaving Essendon he is where I would prioritise. Possibly the best pound for pound defender in the game and also provides great attacking run. However as raised we dont have draft currency to make it happen. I am a massive fan of Zach Williams and he could also fill this role and provide great variation across our midfield but I question his durability. He is a free agent so we could make it happen if we could convince him and shuffle the cash. Otherwise with list reductions and lower spending I would just be looking for the right player that maybe is not getting opportunity at his to fall our way. Whilst In contract one that I would look at Is Jack Sinclair at StKilda. Seems to be on the outer, offers good carry, speed and polish and Is quality both on wing and as forward, Richo would Also be in the known. As far as tall forwards go I am comfortable to invest in a combo of Weid, TMac, Jackson, Petty and not spend the cash. It is showing more that there is less need to spend big $$$ on your big forwards to gain success.

Lockhart Baker Jordan Sparrow and Chandler plus Bedford may solve those issues you feel need solving 

Between Rivers and Lockhart I am certain Jets and Hibbo are covered nearly at present.

The others are unknown with no 2020 form so a work in progress here.

Trade time will be vital and Petty still carries a big white KFP or KDP in the future but Sam and Oscar are taking strong steps to make their careers long and successful.

Time is if the essence day 12 mths and let's see where we are but have eyes open from that trade gem from another Club!

[Ted Lasso 19,586]

Tom Hawkins is a Free agent i believe and the Cats may look to go down the youth path, maybe he's someone we could look at? 

would certainly help accelerate the development of Weid and give Tommy some support. 

[dazzledavey36 56,194]

12 minutes ago, Patches O’houlihan said:

Tom Hawkins is a Free agent i believe and the Cats may look to go down the youth path, maybe he's someone we could look at? 

would certainly help accelerate the development of Weid and give Tommy some support. 

I would personally. Transition into a forwards coach type role.

His leadership would be beneficial on the likes of Weideman and Jackson.

[Timothy Reddan-A'Blew 5,671]

Women's team trades (Sorry to appropriate this men's team thread - and I don't know the protocols there - but I'm not confident to start a thread, and I'm not sure how much interest there is anyway? Alternatively, sorry if this is somewhere already on another thread! Anyway...?

What do people think of yesterday's 'Age' report that 2xAllOz and occasional captain Elise O'Dea and MFC 'royalty' Harriet Cordner, as well as Aliesha Newman, Bianca Jakobbson, Maddy Guerin and Katherine Smith are all 'on the table', to "reinvigorate our list" and "improve our draft position". A fair chunk of the squad! And the first four are linked to specific clubs.

What could this say about the club (if they want out, though I'd be surprised...) or what effect might the shopping around have on the playing group (if they don't)? It strikes me that draft position is a bit of a crapshoot this year anyway, with even less exposed form than usual? And what "reinvigoration" is needed, given the presumable spur of last season's unfinished business?

Thoughts?

[Half forward flank 1,022]

What would we get for Melksham. Its time to replace him.

[dazzledavey36 56,194]

3 minutes ago, Half forward flank said:

What would we get for Melksham. Its time to replace him.

Nothing, because he's not being traded. He signed a 3 year deal last year and is in the leadership group.

Goody loves what he is doing for the forward structure.

Edited July 25, 2020 by dazzledavey36

[Adam The God 30,687]

4 hours ago, big_red_fire_engine said:

We need a small defensive stopper to replace Jetta, possibly a second wingman, a second natural small forward and a mature back up key forward. The question is whether we believe these players already exist on our list and the importance of filling the role vs $$$ we’ll spend. If Saad is any chance of leaving Essendon he is where I would prioritise. Possibly the best pound for pound defender in the game and also provides great attacking run. However as raised we dont have draft currency to make it happen. I am a massive fan of Zach Williams and he could also fill this role and provide great variation across our midfield but I question his durability. He is a free agent so we could make it happen if we could convince him and shuffle the cash. Otherwise with list reductions and lower spending I would just be looking for the right player that maybe is not getting opportunity at his to fall our way. Whilst In contract one that I would look at Is Jack Sinclair at StKilda. Seems to be on the outer, offers good carry, speed and polish and Is quality both on wing and as forward, Richo would Also be in the known. As far as tall forwards go I am comfortable to invest in a combo of Weid, TMac, Jackson, Petty and not spend the cash. It is showing more that there is less need to spend big $$$ on your big forwards to gain success.

I'm happy to back Weideman, Jackson, TMac and Petty for the moment, but Richmond just won a flag by spend big $$$ on Lynch.

[Half forward flank 1,022]

16 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Nothing, because he's not being traded. He signed a 3 year deal last year and is in the leadership group.

Goody loves what he is doing for the forward structure.

Well, he dont play like a leader.

[Lil_red_fire_engine 11,367]

12 minutes ago, A F said:

I'm happy to back Weideman, Jackson, TMac and Petty for the moment, but Richmond just won a flag by spend big $$$ on Lynch.

And they won one before that (and should have been 2) without spending big $$$. I reckon would have won the last one with or without him. 

[Adam The God 30,687]

6 minutes ago, big_red_fire_engine said:

And they won one before that (and should have been 2) without spending big $$$. I reckon would have won the last one with or without him. 

Fair enough.

[whatwhat say what 23,747]

52 minutes ago, Timothy Reddan-A'Blew said:

Women's team trades (Sorry to appropriate this men's team thread - and I don't know the protocols there - but I'm not confident to start a thread, and I'm not sure how much interest there is anyway? Alternatively, sorry if this is somewhere already on another thread! Anyway...?

What do people think of yesterday's 'Age' report that 2xAllOz and occasional captain Elise O'Dea and MFC 'royalty' Harriet Cordner, as well as Aliesha Newman, Bianca Jakobbson, Maddy Guerin and Katherine Smith are all 'on the table', to "reinvigorate our list" and "improve our draft position". A fair chunk of the squad! And the first four are linked to specific clubs.

What could this say about the club (if they want out, though I'd be surprised...) or what effect might the shopping around have on the playing group (if they don't)? It strikes me that draft position is a bit of a crapshoot this year anyway, with even less exposed form than usual? And what "reinvigoration" is needed, given the presumable spur of last season's unfinished business?

Thoughts?

i will fair dinkum suntan terry it if o'dea gets traded

loves aliesha newman too

craziness!

[adonski 13,201]

Polec for a 2nd rounder

[spirit of norm smith 16,676]

18 hours ago, whatwhatsaywhat said:

i will fair dinkum suntan terry it if o'dea gets traded

loves aliesha newman too

craziness!

Agree. Wtf. 

[Lucifers Hero 40,684]

19 hours ago, Timothy Reddan-A'Blew said:

Women's team trades (Sorry to appropriate this men's team thread - and I don't know the protocols there - but I'm not confident to start a thread, and I'm not sure how much interest there is anyway? Alternatively, sorry if this is somewhere already on another thread! Anyway...?

What do people think of yesterday's 'Age' report that 2xAllOz and occasional captain Elise O'Dea and MFC 'royalty' Harriet Cordner, as well as Aliesha Newman, Bianca Jakobbson, Maddy Guerin and Katherine Smith are all 'on the table', to "reinvigorate our list" and "improve our draft position". A fair chunk of the squad! And the first four are linked to specific clubs.

What could this say about the club (if they want out, though I'd be surprised...) or what effect might the shopping around have on the playing group (if they don't)? It strikes me that draft position is a bit of a crapshoot this year anyway, with even less exposed form than usual? And what "reinvigoration" is needed, given the presumable spur of last season's unfinished business?

Thoughts?

Hi TR-B.

AFLW chat is in another DL forum:  https://demonland.com/forums/forum/37-afl-national-womens-league/

There are some threads on draft etc.  One that might cover your post is

I've copied your post to that thread m and will post response there.

Not many DL's venture to the AFLW side which is a bit of a shame.