Snatching Defeat from the Jaws of Victory

[Dr. Gonzo 22,617]

There was another Sydney game at the G in 1994 I reckon, when Dermie kicked the sealer on the siren.

Looking at AFL tables it could've been the week after the Footscray game mentioned above? Darcy didn't play but Ilija Grhic kicked 6 goals that day and we lost by 3 points.

There was another game I remember being at as a kid at Windy Hill, we led early then the Bombers cane back - bombers led by a goal when the siren went but Steven Clark (ex-Bomber) had a kick from about 50 out to try and draw. The crowd had already flooded on to the ground and Clarks kick was touched right on the goal line for no score.

I'm sure I'll remember more - this thread is giving me PTSD.

 

[Hogan2014 390]

On 4/17/2020 at 9:59 PM, Demonland said:

We were 48 points up early in the 4th. 

So mfc like , I remember that game 1992 & was Northey last season ..

[praha 10,360]

9 hours ago, Dr. Gonzo said:

There was another Sydney game at the G in 1994 I reckon, when Dermie kicked the sealer on the siren.

Looking at AFL tables it could've been the week after the Footscray game mentioned above? Darcy didn't play but Ilija Grhic kicked 6 goals that day and we lost by 3 points.

There was another game I remember being at as a kid at Windy Hill, we led early then the Bombers cane back - bombers led by a goal when the siren went but Steven Clark (ex-Bomber) had a kick from about 50 out to try and draw. The crowd had already flooded on to the ground and Clarks kick was touched right on the goal line for no score.

I'm sure I'll remember more - this thread is giving me PTSD.

 

ahh good old Ilija Grgic. Was a solid player but always found another gear against us.

[Dee Dee 1,050]

9 hours ago, Dr. Gonzo said:

 

There was another game I remember being at as a kid at Windy Hill, we led early then the Bombers cane back - bombers led by a goal when the siren went but Steven Clark (ex-Bomber) had a kick from about 50 out to try and draw. The crowd had already flooded on to the ground and Clarks kick was touched right on the goal line for no score.

 

I was at that game Dr. G, the crowd flooded onto the ground and surrounded Clark, he had no hope. Umpires should have given him a clear run but the crowd would have become unmanageable (or more so than they were). Gee Windy Hill was such a nice place?!

[JV7 2,339]

Daniher's farewell game in 2007... Up by 17 points with 5 minutes remaining only for Essendon to kick 3 unanswered and Lucas to be lurking at the back of the pack to goal with 5 seconds left. A fairly Melbourne way to send off one of our better coaches of the modern era 

[Pates 9,537]

10 hours ago, JV7 said:

Daniher's farewell game in 2007... Up by 17 points with 5 minutes remaining only for Essendon to kick 3 unanswered and Lucas to be lurking at the back of the pack to goal with 5 seconds left. A fairly Melbourne way to send off one of our better coaches of the modern era 

That one broke my heart, I was shattered. I also vaguely remember that we had a clear free kick not awarded in the lead up play. I think I might have actually cried a bit that night, Daniher brought us so many great memories and he deserved a win to send him off.

[Little Goffy 12,770]

Forgive me, I need to mention Neale Daniher's final game. Ripper of a game against Essendon but the taste of ash lingered a long time after that one.

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,533]

On 4/17/2020 at 7:11 PM, Demonland said:

Almost managed to do it here.

Which games have we managed to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory?

Freo game when Farmer kicked the winner?

Round 1 2018 game against Geelong when Maxy missed the goal doesn't really qualify as we were behind when he kicked.

The last quarter effort against the Cats in the return game in 2018 probably just qualifies.

Wasn't there a Freo game recently where Cam McCarthy kicked the winning goal with just a few seconds remaining? Or am I confusing two different games?

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,533]

Slightly off topic, but this article in The Age last weekend about the 1970 Grand Final and its impact not only on the game but on some of the players involved is a cracking read. It's a good reminder that while snatching defeat from the jaws of victory is painful for supporters, it can be even more devastating for the players. Admittedly, this game was a Grand Final, so of course we should expect the impact would be greater. 

[Winners at last 4,847]

51 minutes ago, La Dee-vina Comedia said:

Wasn't there a Freo game recently where Cam McCarthy kicked the winning goal with just a few seconds remaining? Or am I confusing two different games?

Sadly they were 2 different games.

[Jumping Jack Clennett 1,629]

On 4/20/2020 at 10:49 PM, Dr. Gonzo said:

There was another Sydney game at the G in 1994 I reckon, when Dermie kicked the sealer on the siren.

Looking at AFL tables it could've been the week after the Footscray game mentioned above? Darcy didn't play but Ilija Grhic kicked 6 goals that day and we lost by 3 points.

There was another game I remember being at as a kid at Windy Hill, we led early then the Bombers cane back - bombers led by a goal when the siren went but Steven Clark (ex-Bomber) had a kick from about 50 out to try and draw. The crowd had already flooded on to the ground and Clarks kick was touched right on the goal line for no score.

I'm sure I'll remember more - this thread is giving me PTSD.

 

I was at that Windy  Hill  game.( at the outer, opposite ,end).

I think Clark’s mark  was about on the 50 m line, so he had to clear 55m at least. He tried a torp, and got hold of it ,but it fell a metre or so short.

Can Demonlanders remind me of games where we’ve won with a kick AFTER the siren. ?   I can think of a few wins JUST before the siren ( eg Gold Coast last  year, Schwartz knock to Leoncelli in Adelaide, TMac v West Coast on the MCG), but no wins after the siren come to mind(unlike several losses AFTER  the siren.)

[gs77 3,424]

12 hours ago, Little Goffy said:

Forgive me, I need to mention Neale Daniher's final game. Ripper of a game against Essendon but the taste of ash lingered a long time after that one.

Not a close one, but our 111 point capitulation to the Cats for Paul Roos's last game as coach was a pretty disappointing send-off for one of the game's titans.

[Jumping Jack Clennett 1,629]

2 hours ago, gs77 said:

Not a close one, but our 111 point capitulation to the Cats for Paul Roos's last game as coach was a pretty disappointing send-off for one of the game's titans.

I persuaded my mate to accompany me to that game.

He wasn’t happy with me!

[Jumping Jack Clennett 1,629]

On 4/21/2020 at 9:34 AM, JV7 said:

Daniher's farewell game in 2007... Up by 17 points with 5 minutes remaining only for Essendon to kick 3 unanswered and Lucas to be lurking at the back of the pack to goal with 5 seconds left. A fairly Melbourne way to send off one of our better coaches of the modern era 

I have been watching old games on YouTube while on the exercise bike.

So few wins, I'm watching a few losses now.

I  just saw that  2007 Ess game at Docklands,Danners last as coach.

Yes....we were 17 up with 4  min 25 sec to go.

Then the UMPIRES!!!. made three diabolical decisions.   Lucas's first was a result of a very definite throw.

The next came after Bruce was tackled by the legs, in what the commentators described as a "professional free" ("cynical foul" in soccer).....NOT PAID.!!

The other goal came as a result of a dubious holding the ball("?dragged it in") in our forward line, when the umps had otherwise "swallowed the whistle".

Melbourne had fought back brilliantly after being 30 points down early.

I remember walking away from that match feeling absolutely cheated. Otherwise, I had eradicated it from my memory.

[MyFavouriteMartian 572]

4 hours ago, Jumping Jack Clennett said:

I have been watching old games on YouTube while on the exercise bike.

So few wins, I'm watching a few losses now.

I  just saw that  2007 Ess game at Docklands,Danners last as coach.

Yes....we were 17 up with 4  min 25 sec to go.

Then the UMPIRES!!!. made three diabolical decisions.   Lucas's first was a result of a very definite throw.

The next came after Bruce was tackled by the legs, in what the commentators described as a "professional free" ("cynical foul" in soccer).....NOT PAID.!!

The other goal came as a result of a dubious holding the ball("?dragged it in") in our forward line, when the umps had otherwise "swallowed the whistle".

Melbourne had fought back brilliantly after being 30 points down early.

I remember walking away from that match feeling absolutely cheated. Otherwise, I had eradicated it from my memory.

Yes, woe is us.

But if you look again at the last Qtr,  see if you can tell when we lift our foot off the accelerator pedal.  IIRC,  that was apparent to me during the game.  We had a habit of doing it a lot around that period of this list.

Don't  "watch"  the game...  bu studiously look for our intensity levels throughout the game,  and mostly the last Qtr.

We were habitually taking foot off the pedal for years,  trying to save our leads...   instead of powering offensive pressure, to maintain the scoreboard pressure. 

Its too late to refire after surrendering healthy leads,  due to easing off.

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,533]

16 hours ago, Jumping Jack Clennett said:

I have been watching old games on YouTube while on the exercise bike.

So few wins, I'm watching a few losses now.

I  just saw that  2007 Ess game at Docklands,Danners last as coach.

Yes....we were 17 up with 4  min 25 sec to go.

Then the UMPIRES!!!. made three diabolical decisions.   Lucas's first was a result of a very definite throw.

The next came after Bruce was tackled by the legs, in what the commentators described as a "professional free" ("cynical foul" in soccer).....NOT PAID.!!

The other goal came as a result of a dubious holding the ball("?dragged it in") in our forward line, when the umps had otherwise "swallowed the whistle".

Melbourne had fought back brilliantly after being 30 points down early.

I remember walking away from that match feeling absolutely cheated. Otherwise, I had eradicated it from my memory.

You've been no help. I had successfully eradicated it from my memory, too, until your "helpful" reminder above.