All Australian watch

[P-man 13,366]

Jones is also playing great footy this year but hoping for him to be picked in an AA side is akin to hoping for a lapdance from Natalie Portman.

[Tony Tea 2,809]

Gawn is currently fighting it out with Grundy, with Nik Nat & Lycett pinching each other's credits. Nevvy was fantastic on the weekend, but I'm not sure he's had a better year than last - although I'm also not sure about his back pocket competition. Hogan is playing better than Brown, but has not kicked as many goals, and there is a lot of love for Brown. Oliver is up against some heavyweight competition, and is probably just off the leaders.

[Lucifers Hero 39,755]

I don't rate Fox scribes so I am not surprised that only three Demons in their AA squad of 40 players:  Oliver, Gawn and Hogan  https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/west-coast-dominate-melbourne-snubbed-in-fox-footys-midyear-allaustralian-squad/news-story/bf33ceb30194de6c8ff5e146b61686c8

Because we have had very even performances from our team I can understand we don't dominate in selections.

But amazed they would leave out all of Melksham, Tom Mc and Jetta. 

[Deespicable 2,726]

On 6/2/2018 at 9:46 PM, Wiseblood said:

I'd have just the three - Gawn, Oliver and Hogan.

Why 3?  It's the even spread of contributions from everyone in the side at the moment.  The above 3 are the consistent standouts for me.

Agree on your three, although I reckon Melky is in the mix - his standout games on Rance and against Carlton will have won him points and this year there will be no Betts as the small forward. Bruest, Caddy, De Goey and even Walters are challenging for those spots I think.

As to Jetta, he was a standout on Saturday - I reckon it was the best game I've seen him play - but even then he only went forward 251m. That's the negative wrap on him - he only hurts sides by stopping players. He also started season poorly. But if he keeps playing like he did Saturday, then he'll firm for a spot. Plenty of options in his role. Laird and Tom Stewart are certs and Hurn and Vlaustin must be close as well.  

[What 18,810]

39 minutes ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

I don't rate Fox scribes so I am not surprised that only three Demons in their AA squad of 40 players:  Oliver, Gawn and Hogan  https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/west-coast-dominate-melbourne-snubbed-in-fox-footys-midyear-allaustralian-squad/news-story/bf33ceb30194de6c8ff5e146b61686c8

Because we have had very even performances from our team I can understand we don't dominate in selections.

But amazed they would leave out all of Melksham, Tom Mc and Jetta. 

They even admit in the title they snubbed our players therefore admitting their writers are a joke.

[The Chazz 4,077]

No way Melksham makes the squad.  He's playing very good for us, but nowhere near what it takes to be an AA.  This isn't being critical of his output - his consistency is helping make us a better side.

[whatwhat say what 22,747]

FWIW, Jetta and O Mac were ROBBED

[Lucifers Hero 39,755]

Foxfooty have updated their Squad of 40 somewhat, after Paul Roos rated Shaun Higgins in the top 10 players in the league. 

They added 12 players as 'Unlucky' to be omitted including three very worth Dees:

Neville Jetta: Find a Demons supporter who doesn’t rate Neville Jetta. The small defender goes about his business every week and is one of the club’s walk up starters, such is his consistency and preparation. Rarely has his colours lowered.

Tom McDonald: The reinvented forward is exceptionally stiff to miss out, with an interrupted start to the season to blame. McDonald has kicked 19 goals in six matches and has provided a perfect second foil for teammate Jesse Hogan.

Jake Melksham: Ranked second in score assists and seventh in score involvements, Melksham has rebranded himself into one of the most reliable forwards in the AFL. The former Bomber kicked five goals from 21 touches against Carlton, which AFL player ratings labelled as the best individual game of the season.

https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/north-melbourne-superstar-shaun-higgins-leads-fox-footys-midyear-allaustralian-snubs/news-story/9f11fbb27c398e87b7aebe5ba5dbf94f

That would give us 6 of their 52.

[DeleteUser 638]

On 6/4/2018 at 12:31 PM, P-man said:

Jones is also playing great footy this year but hoping for him to be picked in an AA side is akin to hoping for a lapdance from Natalie Portman.

Are there any female posters here?

[daisycutter 29,613]

12 minutes ago, timbo said:

Are there any female posters here?

doubt it........we are all gender fluid on demonland

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,754]

On 6/4/2018 at 12:26 PM, P-man said:

Jetta runs rings around Laird as a defender, but the media’s obsession with disposal numbers will see Laird get the nod.

Gawn and Hogan are locks barring any drop in form which seems unlikely.

I’m tipping Oliver will make the squad but not the team, with the rationale being he needs to “be more damaging” or “kick it more”. I hope to be pleasantly surprised.

T Mac is the wildcard. If he keeps kicking goals for fun he will be hard to ignore but the delayed start to the season might cost him a spot. Here’s hoping he doesn’t get moved back this week.

How many games did Hibberd miss at the beginning of last year? 

I've always been of the view that AA selections are rather like job interviews in that the "primacy" and "recency" factors have too much influence. "Primacy" means the ones noticed first (for the AA, that means those players who dominate in the first few rounds; for job interviews, it's the first person interviewed) while "recency" refers to the ones noticed at the end (last few games in the home and away series for AA, last person interviewed for the job). If Tom McDonald retains his form, though, particularly if he's strong in the last 2-3 weeks of the season, I doubt the games he missed will go against him.

[poita 3,902]

Gawn, Hogan & Oliver are certainties for me, although Oliver probably needs a couple of stand out games in the next month to keep himself in the picture given his relative lack of profile. 

Jetta is coming from a long way back given his first month, but there isn't a lot of competition for his spot either.

Tom McDonald would need to play every game from here to make the team. 17 of 22 games would be borderline to make the team, 6 of 11 at present is not even close, regardless of form.

Grundy should be in the team as well. I have no issue with two rucks being named, particularly in a year where there haven't been a lot of standout midfielders.

[poita 3,902]

1 hour ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

Foxfooty have updated their Squad of 40 somewhat, after Paul Roos rated Shaun Higgins in the top 10 players in the league. 

That fox squad is a complete w*nk. Webster, Seedsman & Pearce in the backline; three Hawthorn forwards; the entire Collingwood midfield. 

[P-man 13,366]

2 hours ago, timbo said:

Are there any female posters here?

Yes.

[What 18,810]

On 6/4/2018 at 1:01 PM, Lucifer's Hero said:

I don't rate Fox scribes so I am not surprised that only three Demons in their AA squad of 40 players:  Oliver, Gawn and Hogan  https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/west-coast-dominate-melbourne-snubbed-in-fox-footys-midyear-allaustralian-squad/news-story/bf33ceb30194de6c8ff5e146b61686c8

Because we have had very even performances from our team I can understand we don't dominate in selections.

But amazed they would leave out all of Melksham, Tom Mc and Jetta. 

 

Garry Lyon On The Couch last night was asked to pick his All Australian backline, and Gerard Healy said surely Jetta will be in there..  he wasn't.   Garry then explained he wanted him in there but Jetta wasn't in the 40 man squad he was given to choose from.

Which i assume was the squad from that joke of a Fox article.

Edited June 5, 2018 by Petraccattack

[P-man 13,366]

It’s also crazy not to have Tarrant in the squad of 40. Of course Rance is in there though. Permanent marker.

[Tony Tea 2,809]

On 6/4/2018 at 12:47 PM, Tony Tea said:

Gawn is currently fighting it out with Grundy, with Nik Nat & Lycett pinching each other's credits. Nevvy was fantastic on the weekend, but I'm not sure he's had a better year than last - although I'm also not sure about his back pocket competition. Hogan is playing better than Brown, but has not kicked as many goals, and there is a lot of love for Brown. Oliver is up against some heavyweight competition, and is probably just off the leaders.

According to Round Robbo, I am close to the mark. Well, his mark, for what it's worth.

[Tony Tea 2,809]

Are there any women here?

[What 18,810]

On 6/4/2018 at 12:47 PM, Tony Tea said:

Gawn is currently fighting it out with Grundy, with Nik Nat & Lycett pinching each other's credits. Nevvy was fantastic on the weekend, but I'm not sure he's had a better year than last - although I'm also not sure about his back pocket competition. Hogan is playing better than Brown, but has not kicked as many goals, and there is a lot of love for Brown. Oliver is up against some heavyweight competition, and is probably just off the leaders.

Hogan has only kicked 4 less goals than brown, despite Brown parking himself in the Roos forward 50 all game.

Hogan averaging 20 disposals and dominating all over the park to go with his 31 goals.

Hes a way better player than brown...   in fact Judd said on Footy Classified last night that Hogan is the best player in the comp at the moment.

But thats irrelevant to the AA team -  Hogan and Brown arent fighting for 1 position.  Hogan could be named in any of the 6 forward spots ..  Brown is a full forward only, and if hes not careful could be displaced by Josh Kennedy whos still kicking a lot of goals and climbing the Coleman leader board fast.

[Dee Zephyr 19,267]

An AFL article today lists players from each club that are in All-Australian contention mid-season. 

Ours according to Ben Guthrie are, Oliver, Hogan, Gawn, Jetta and this bloke. I tend to agree.

Oscar McDonald
This might be one from left field but Demons supporters will know how important Oscar McDonald has been this season. Would be top five in the club's best and fairest award, making giant strides in his role as Melbourne's No.1 key defender.

Edited June 6, 2018 by Dee Zephyr

[What 18,810]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-06-14/kane-cornes-team-of-the-week-most-appearances

[What 18,810]

Kane Cornes midseason AA team.  Three Demons including two of the starting forwards.

Oliver stiff, and Jetta should be back pocket instead of Whitfield. 

 

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,754]

9 hours ago, Petraccattack said:

Kane Cornes midseason AA team.  Three Demons including two of the starting forwards.

Oliver stiff, and Jetta should be back pocket instead of Whitfield. 

 

Just looking at that picture...is it Kane Cornes' or Matthew Lloyd's team? (Not that it matters.)

[What 18,810]

27 minutes ago, La Dee-vina Comedia said:

Just looking at that picture...is it Kane Cornes' or Matthew Lloyd's team? (Not that it matters.)

Lloyd does a weekly team but he was away for some reason, so Cornes took over and did a midyear AA team.

[What 18,810]

Gawn, Oliver and Hogan surely will all be in the AA team.

Pretty sure the MFC has never had three All Australians in the same season, this could be the year.