Garlett is blameless. No small forward with pace could have performed well at this atrocious excuse for an VFL ground. Sadly though it goes against his recall which it shouldn't.

Enough already ... siren and thankfully it's over. 

Collingwood VFL 2.2.14 3.2.20 4.8.32 8.11.59

Casey Scorpions 1.0.6 1.2.8 1.5.11 2.7.19

Goals

Casey Scorpions Newton T Smith

Collingwood VFL Cloke 2 Aish Collopy Ferguson Gault Knight Smith 

Best

Casey Scorpions Keilty Michie Hutchins Garland Spencer White

Collingwood VFL Aish Smith Cloke Oxley Howe Wills

Statistics

Colin Garland 14 disposals 12 kicks 2 handballs 2 marks 3 tackles 55 dream team points

Jeff Garlett 8 disposals 4 kicks 4 handballs 7 tackles 46 dream team points

Jack Grimes 14 disposals 12 kicks 2 handballs 2 marks 9 tackles 82 dream team points

Liam Hulett 1 behind 8 disposals 5 kicks 3 handballs 6 tackles 46 dream team points

Max King 10 disposals 5  kicks 5 handballs 1 mark 6 tackles 10 hit outs 61 dream team points

Matt Jones 27 disposals 15 kicks 12 handballs 3 marks 8 tackles 92 team points

Viv Michie 23 disposals 17 kicks 6 handballs 1 mark 4 tackles 84 dream team points

Alex Neale-Bullen 18 disposals 11 kicks 7 handballs 6 tackles 71 dream team points

Ben Newton 1 goal 17 disposals 9 kicks 8 handballs 7 tackles 2 hit outs 84 dream team points

Cam Pedersen 1 behind 10 disposals 6 kicks 4 handballs 1 mark 7 tackles 6 hit outs 59 dream team points

Jake Spencer 10 disposals 9 kicks 1 handball 2 marks 7 tackles 82 hit outs 142 dream team points

Dean Terlich 9 disposals 5 kicks 4 handballs 1 mark 4 tackles 33 dream team points

Mitch White 1 behind 19 disposals 7 kicks 12  handballs 1 mark 10 tackles 86 dream team points

9 minutes ago, KC from Casey said:

I would say that Ben Newton and Jake Spencer (for his ruck work) are the only Demons who earned their pay today.

 

I like Newton's games, of last season.  He looks skilled to me, & handy.

5 minutes ago, martin said:

Garlett is blameless. No small forward with pace could have performed well at this atrocious excuse for an VFL ground. Sadly though it goes against his recall which it shouldn't.

No excuse for zero effort

I'm gald I only tuned in for the last 5 minutes,I don't even want to know what I missed.

17 minutes ago, RalphiusMaximus said:

I don't think it's the sulks so much as the mud.  The whole ground is mud and his pace is virtually useless in these conditions.  The one time I saw him get into some space the kick fell short and was marked by one of the guys running after him.  He gave up one chase that I noticed, but has also caused quite a few turnovers that his teammates haven't been able to score from.  The big issue though is that he's hardly touched the ball.  He can't pick it up in the mud. 

The giving up when things get tough, is a weak character.

try try try again.

Edited June 11, 20169 yr by DV8

3 minutes ago, chook fowler said:

No excuse for zero effort

Disagree. I saw some effort but exercise in complete and utter futility.May as well ask him to chase in a Werribee sewer farm. This game is irrelevant.

No Weed, no Casey?

3 minutes ago, martin said:

Disagree. I saw some effort but exercise in complete and utter futility.May as well ask him to chase in a Werribee sewer farm. This game is irrelevant.

We'll have to agree to disagree 

Imagine being a young player trying to learn the game plan and get some form/fitness when you have to play in conditions like this so often

6 minutes ago, Brayshaw Self said:

Imagine being a young player trying to learn the game plan and get some form/fitness when you have to play in conditions like this so often

I didn't watch the game but the conditions were the same for both sides and we seem to have been unable to handle them, it is after all, a winter sport.

 

I watched the game from the warm comfort of home on the television set and found it hard to believe that Casey was the top side of the competition. They fumbled, dropped marks, disposed poorly, rarely getting distance or accuracy with their kicks and turned the ball over constantly. That sort of play is usually a recipe for disaster and that's exactly how it turned out today.

6 minutes ago, Dante said:

I didn't watch the game but the conditions were the same for both sides and we seem to have been unable to handle them, it is after all, a winter sport.

 

I'd hate to be a marking forward or a rebounding defender learning my craft and playing on that windswept ground every second week. Those conditions are not reflective of the conditions they will play in 9 weeks out of 10. I watched young Liam Hulett run around like a lost lamb today. He got nowhere near it and had very little chance to be honest.

Edited June 11, 20169 yr by Tough Kent

5 minutes ago, Tough Kent said:

I'd hate to be a marking forward or a rebounding defender learning my craft and playing on that windswept ground every second week. Those conditions are not reflective of the conditions they will play in 9 weeks out of 10. 

10 out 10.Trying to recall a muddy,BOG AFL game in recent memory? It's a winter sport played in pristine conditions. Slippery at worst. MFC should dump the alignment asap.

Like Arctic Park ( Waverley) - Casey Fields is in the rain - and wind -belt . Not a good place to develop your skills.

What happened to Grimes? He was off for effectively all of the last quarter- and he wasn't in playing gear when shaking hands after the game?

 

6 minutes ago, martin said:

10 out 10.Trying to recall a muddy,BOG AFL game in recent memory? It's a winter sport played in pristine conditions. Slippery at worst. MFC should dump the alignment asap.

Try the Swans Gold Coast game recently.

4 minutes ago, #11-TonyAnderson said:

 

Try the Swans Gold Coast game recently.

Was wet,not a bog like this crap hole. Monsoonal rain made it a slippery nonsense,should have been called off. One in a thousand.Metricon  Stadium would now be perfect.Casey Fields will only continue to deteriorate,horrible.No comparison.

3 hours ago, DavidNeitz9 said:

How long is he out Saty ?  He's having a horrid run with soft tissue injury

McCartney told me, didn't elaborate

30 minutes ago, Whispering_Jack said:

I watched the game from the warm comfort of home on the television set and found it hard to believe that Casey was the top side of the competition. They fumbled, dropped marks, disposed poorly, rarely getting distance or accuracy with their kicks and turned the ball over constantly. That sort of play is usually a recipe for disaster and that's exactly how it turned out today.

In one WJ just outplayed in the conditions

How the hell any of our listed players will develop in Casey whilst playing on this boghole astounds me!

Apart from the wind gusts, the ground is in shocking condition.

Watching the game much worse, zero skills and just a rugby scrum in the mud.

1 hour ago, DavidNeitz9 said:

Garland 9 possies, Terlich 6. How many times has Michie turned it over today, another who should be delisted

4 times from 26 disposals in atrocious conditions. At least he gets the ball and delivers into the forward line. It was a awful game from Casey. The worst I have seen from them. Not worth the 2 hour round trip but the bacon rolls were good.

1 hour ago, wizardinoz said:

No Weed, no Casey?

Yeh, tough match to watch. Even though our depth has improved relative to past years when best 22 players such Brayshaw, Salem & Lumumba (+ Melksham) are unavailable our depth is tested. On a positive note, Spencer stood out today and didn't give up

43 minutes ago, Tough Kent said:

I'd hate to be a marking forward or a rebounding defender learning my craft and playing on that windswept ground every second week. Those conditions are not reflective of the conditions they will play in 9 weeks out of 10. I watched young Liam Hulett run around like a lost lamb today. He got nowhere near it and had very little chance to be honest.

I hate being a supporter traipsing out to Casey in conditions like that every second week. And nest week is in Bitter Cold Ballarat (with no bacon rolls). Ah well could be worse, could live at Casey (is it actually a suburb?). Today is one of those games you just forget because you are right they are unlikely to play in such conditions the rest of the year. 

1 hour ago, Emerald said:

I'm gald I only tuned in for the last 5 minutes,I don't even want to know what I missed.

nothing

As soon as Garlett signed his new 3 year deal he stopped trying.  Didnt he do a similar thing at Carlton?