MFC & Casey Inside Football player ratings & comments (Round 6)

[Wilson7 2,662]

MFC & Casey Inside Football player ratings & comments for Round 6

Melbourne v Sydney, Round 6, MCG

7 - Tom McDonald - Super duel with Franklin. Held him goalless but both players had an impact

7 - Christian Salem - Best game so far running off half back. A few errors but impressive night

6 - Jesse Hogan - Despite poor supply continued to work hard to find the footy

6 - Daniel Cross - Tried hard and gave 100% at the contests but wasnt a big factor

5 - Jeff Garlett - A spectator in first half then came alive after main break

5 - Dom Tyson - Hasnt been able to break free this season and was well held again

5 - Nathan Jones - Wasnt able to generate his normal drive from the middle

5 - Aaron vandenBerg - Tore in and used frame to advantage but couldnt swing momentum

5 - Bernie Vince - Tried to latch onto a few different Swans with moderate success

5 - Heritier Lumumba - Battled on but wasnt able to get his typical running game going

5 - Ben Newton - Kicking was unusually off at times but at least got into the game

5 - Billy Stretch - Goalled with first kick in league footy and didnt look out of place

4 - Angus Brayshaw - Quietest game at senior level so far. Couldnt get into it

4 - Lynden Dunn - Tippett got him early with three goals but continued to fight hard

4 - Colin Garland - Rough night on a few different opponents. Lacked confidence

4 - Jeremy Howe - Just padding at the moment down back. A move forward might re-ignite him

4 - Cameron Pedersen - Backed up Spencer in ruck but wasnt much of a factor in attack

4 - Jimmy Toumpas - Got a bit of the ball but lacked incisiveness. Ability to cover ground a worry

3 - Chris Dawes - Unsighted until final term when he started to get his hands on ball

3 - Jake Spencer - Made Pyke look like Dean Cox at times. This level appears beyond him

2 - Jay Kennedy-Harris - Dropped a sitter in opening minute and didnt recover

2 - Jack Watts - Sub. At least was clean with ball when he came on

Casey v Sandringham, Round 4, Casey Fields

Max Gawn - Combined with Jamar to dominate hitouts. Took some good marks

Jack Grimes - 31 possessions and a goal into the wind. Battled hard

Mark Jamar - Won the ruck battle but wasnt a standout performer

Viv Michie - One of the Scorpions most consistent performers. 25 touches

Matt Jones - Huge first three quarters then cooled late. 31 possessions

Jordie McKenzie - 20 hard-fought touches in loss to Sandringham

Aiden Reilly - Battled hard but lacked class on a windy day

Dean Terlich - Had trouble tracking Saad who was one of Sandys best

Jack Fitzpatrick - Struggled in defence to cope with Mitch Browns movement

Oscar McDonald - Kicked a late goal after a good mark. Showed a bit

Alex Neal-Bullen - Used ball well when he got it and showed a bit

Mitch White - Did some nice things down back but is still learning

James Harmes - Struggled to have an impact

Casey - Development League

Max King - Three goals in development league win

Jayden Hunt - Made return successfully in development league victory

Did Not Play

Rohan Bail - Senior Emergency

Christian Petracca - Injured

Jack Viney - Injured

Dean Kent - injured

Sam Frost - injured

Neville Jetta - injured

Jack Trengove - injured

[whatwhat say what 22,700]

What match were they watching?

Howe was forward by early second quarter, and Brayshaw was pretty impressive.

[deanox 9,898]

Super harsh on Watts who was good when he came on.

Stretch is higher than he should be.

[spirit of norm smith 16,292]

Tom Mcdonald was a 9 surely. Leader in B&F for sure.

[Je Roos Salem 661]

Agree, while Stretch didn't harm his prospects, he did seem overwhelmed.

I think Bail and M.Jones will be right in the mix for selection this week