Correct, I posted several weeks ago that Grimley is not rated at all by the senior players still Hawthorn. A current Premiership player who is my son's best mate told us that they can't believe he is still on their list.

Would be a certainty that the likes of N Jones must think similarly of about 30 blokes on our list.

He is an overly cocky under talented forward. Dawes, Hogan, Pederson, Gawn, Fitzy and then mccartin leave us pretty covered in this area I think.

I think he's better than Fitzpatrick, but at the same time there's no point having 2 of them.

He's depth at a good club, but not good enough to be more than that at Melbourne.

If we take another tall forward with any of our proper picks we don't need him, even if we don't I'd rather use the list spot elsewhere.

Just another name I have never heard of that some excited poster gets a boner over in hope that we may actually "fluke" one really decent "never has been" reject from another club sometime soon. No thanks.

The MFC of now only hunts good fish thankyou.

Edited November 12, 201411 yr by The Song Formerly Known As

He is an overly cocky under talented forward. Dawes, Hogan, Pederson, Gawn, Fitzy and then mccartin leave us pretty covered in this area I think.

You mean they cover us for "overly cocky under talented forwards"?

You'd have to look at him, but you'd also have to consider that he may be the lesser but taller version of Shannon Byrnes, and that's not a good thing.

You'd have to look at him, but you'd also have to consider that he may be the lesser but taller version of Shannon Byrnes, and that's not a good thing.

He's just a VFL player 'Machsy', really offers not much more than a bit of size.

The one i wouldn't mind is schroder from Geelong, i really think he has a little bit to offer

Now with the draft done, Grimley as a rookie makes sense as a key forward and backup ruck. He kicks goals, has skills and knows how to win !!

Now with the draft done, Grimley as a rookie makes sense as a key forward and backup ruck. He kicks goals, has skills and knows how to win !!

If we can turn him into a defender, then make it happen.

I'd rather look at Luke Lowden, has he found a home yet?

I'd rather look at Luke Lowden, has he found a home yet?

Traded to Adelaide

Forget Grimley unless we want him at Casey.

He's far too light and doesn't appear to have the frame or body type to put on the size.

Rather have Shane Valenti in the ruck!