Changes v West Coast

[thaipantsman 180]

Mfc needs to make an emphatic statement to team composition this week after they did not perform this week. Need to replace under performing players them with Casey players who did perform. We must show we respect and reward players who earn it and those that cannot measure up, need to go back to Casey to earn their place back. Hunger is what we need and most in the side, most of the players mentioned as doing well for Casey this week were noted for that. This week should be a test for those in Casey to see if they measure up and a chance for Senior players who did not measure up to run into form.

Like the keeness

Out: Rodan, Gillies, Byrnes, Pederson

In: Pettard, Rivers, Gysberts, Moloney

The latter 4 left because of Neeld . The other 4 were the only players willing to play under him. Liam Jurrah would arguably be our best forward option right now.

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

delist Jamar

one of the worst games of footy I have ever seen

[S.R.J 418]

At this point i just want us to show some competitive spirit....i hate losing but if we go down but show some bloody spirit

[Dinosaur Rover 197]

Is playing for Casey inherantly more safe than playing AFL?

Well ...that's my laugh for the day. Unfortunately Taggert played in the 2's at Casey and didn't make the best in that match, Magna is back on the rookie list and not available, Barry doesn't like the contest at this stage and Big Max, well he would be a chance but I hope they don't pick him just yet. If Big Max is picked this week then the footy department should be accused of not looking after their players.

He might have to take it into his own hands at training this week.

[Dee Fan 3,247]

At this point i just want us to show some competitive spirit....i hate losing but if we go down but show some bloody spirit

The sad part about all this is that we would probably be happy with a 5 or 6 goal loss this week and that includes the Football Department.

That is how low our expectations have sunk.

[CHAMP 347]

The sad part about all this is that we would probably be happy with a 5 or 6 goal loss this week and that includes the Football Department.

That is how low our expectations have sunk.

A 5 or 6 goal loss would be a whopping percentage-booster

[Benson 254]

It is hard to pick which players to leave out against WC, would not want to see more than 4 changes.

Out:

-Gillies - He has showed very little in the first two games to retain his position (he does not play a structural part in the side, as the side currently has no structure)

-Toumpas - I will only leave him out as he is taking these losses to heart (heart, that many of our players do not have atm), playing a few games @ Casey will help with his confidence and will be able to assist with his development without crushing his spirits in disastrous losses. If Melbourne eventually come to fruition in 2-3 years, he will play a vital role. Very important long term player.

- Sylvia - I have no respect for Sylvia, senior player showing no on field leadership, does not chase, does not tackle, and does not act like a senior player.

- Rodan - He has not shown much on field (neither has many of the other players), however, more is expected from a senior head.

In:

- Spencer - Surely he will play with more intensity than Jamar, watching him at Casey a few times, he chases and tackles and loves the contact. He and Jamar can rest in the forward line. Spencer will play like it is his last game, Jamar plays as though his position is not on the line.

- McKenzie - hard head required

- Kent - I liked him during the preseason and I think he will provide that little spark that is sorely needed

- Bail (Sub) - he may not be 100% fit, but I like the way he goes about it.

Emerg:

- Pederson - May need to play a role down back due to WC's talls

- Jetta - If he plays well for Casey this week, he should come in for the GWS game, he is playing well as a forward and defender, consistency should earn a senior call up.

- Dunn - Only play if a forward is required, do not like him in defence

Magner & Couch seem to be playing very well in the VFL, surely if they continue this form throughout the season then they HAVE earned a promotion in this years draft. Consistency deserves recognition, I am surprised both were overlooked last year to be elevated to the senior list.

Max Gawn - as much as I would love him to come straight in he does need 2-3 weeks to build match fitness, once that is achieved he should play the remaining rounds.

Aaron Davey - keep him in, it seems as though he has turned over a leaf and just needs to play 4 quarters, not the only player needed to play 4 quarters.

Jack Watts - to play up forward AND stay up forward, he is not a defender.

James Sellar - can sit in defence as talls are needed against WC's talls

Luke Tapscott - play 2 more games at Casey, if consistency is required from the players then this is the best way to prove it. Replicate this performance and he deserves a spot in the 22

Jack Grimes - Play him out of defence

Backs: Frawley, Garland, McDonald, Nicholson, Grimes, Terlich

Mids: Viney, N Jones, M Jones, McKenzie, Trengove

Ruck: Jamar

Forwards: Clark, Watts, Howe, Davey, Blease, Byrnes

Int: Spencer, Kent, Sellar, Bail (Sub)

Edited April 9, 2013 by Benson

[45HG 1,559]

A 5 or 6 goal loss would be a whopping percentage-booster

That depends. If we lose by 6 goals but score less than 28% of their score, it'll still go down!

[CHAMP 347]

That depends. If we lose by 6 goals but score less than 28% of their score, it'll still go down!

OK. I should have said 'on the balance of probability'.

It's difficult to conceive that WC will have trouble putting quite a few on the board.

[jumbo returns 6,741]

It is hard to pick which players to leave out against WC, would not want to see more than 4 changes.

Out:

-Gillies - He has showed very little in the first two games to retain his position (he does not play a structural part in the side, as the side currently has no structure)

-Toumpas - I will only leave him out as he is taking these losses to heat (heat, that many of our players do not have atm), playing a few games @ Casey will help with his confidence and will be able to assist with his development without crushing his spirits in disastrous losses. If Melbourne eventually come to fruition in 2-3 years, he will play a vital role. Very important long term player.

- Sylvia - I have no respect for Sylvia, senior player showing no on field leadership, does not chase, does not tackle, and does not act like a senior player.

- Rodan - He has not shown much on field (neither has many of the other players), however, more is expected from a senior head.

In:

- Spencer - Surely he will play with more intensity than Jamar, watching him at Casey a few times, he chases and tackles and loves the contact. He and Jamar can rest in the forward line. Spencer will play like it is his last game, Jamar plays as though his position is not on the line.

- McKenzie - hard head required

- Kent - I liked him during the preseason and I think he will provide that little spark that is sorely needed

- Bail (Sub) - he may not be 100% fit, but I like the way he goes about it.

Emerg:

- Pederson - May need to play a role down back due to WC's talls

- Jetta - If he plays well for Casey this week, he should come in for the GWS game, he is playing well as a forward and defender, consistency should earn a senior call up.

- Dunn - Only play if a forward is required, do not like him in defence

Magner & Couch seem to be playing very well in the VFL, surely if they continue this form throughout the season then they HAVE earned a promotion in this years draft. Consistency deserves recognition, I am surprised both were overlooked last year to be elevated to the senior list.

Max Gawn - as much as I would love him to come straight in he does need 2-3 weeks to build match fitness, once that is achieved he should play the remaining rounds.

Aaron Davey - keep him in, it seems as though he has turned over a leaf and just needs to play 4 quarters, not the only player needed to play 4 quarters.

Jack Watts - to play up forward AND stay up forward, he is not a defender.

James Sellar - can sit in defence as talls are needed against WC's talls

Luke Tapscott - play 2 more games at Casey, if consistency is required from the players then this is the best way to prove it. Replicate this performance and he deserves a spot in the 22

Jack Grimes - Play him out of defence

Backs: Frawley, Garland, McDonald, Nicholson, Grimes, Terlich

Mids: Viney, N Jones, M Jones, McKenzie, Trengove

Ruck: Jamar

Forwards: Clark, Watts, Howe, Davey, Blease, Byrnes

Int: Spencer, Kent, Sellar, Bail (Sub)

Benson, your ins are good, but run and carry will upset the Eagles

Couch and Magner are sloggers and slow, slow, slow. Even if they get elevated, you can't play those with Jordie, so tough decisions will have to be made at season's end.

Watts forward and stays there...I agree. Not a backman, now that he's been tagged. That's some solace that he can take away as opposition coaches respect his disposal efficiency.

Gillies - out. Not sure about this chap.

Bail, in....run, run, run.

Swing Nicho, 2 x Jones, 3 x Jacks, Sylvia, Garland, Jordie, Tapscott, Terlich, Howe, Davey and Byrnes. Burst them out for 10 minutes each - I want to see a record number of rotations. There are enough bloody coaches to sort this out.

Mitch to start in the ruck with Jamar forward, then swing around at the 15 minute mark.

Hey, it can't get worse, can it?

[jordie 22]

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/2013-04-08/round-1-vfl-player-review

Magner and Tapscott seemingly dominated according to MFC.com.au

[Benson 254]

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/2013-04-08/round-1-vfl-player-review

Magner and Tapscott seemingly dominated according to MFC.com.au

Are you saying you want both players in against WC? Magner is a Rookie.

Edited April 9, 2013 by Benson

[jumbo returns 6,741]

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/2013-04-08/round-1-vfl-player-review

Magner and Tapscott seemingly dominated according to MFC.com.au

Magner is too slow.

A side can only afford to carry one, slow, inside mid - that's Jordie Mac atm.

Besides, he's not eligible.

Tapscott, 2 more dominating weeks.

Edited April 9, 2013 by jumbo returns

[DeeSpencer 26,070]

FB: Garland Frawley Pedersen

HB: Terlich McDonald Grimes

C: Evans Jones M. Jones

HF: Howe Clark Byrnes

FF: Davey Gawn Blease

Foll: Jamar Viney McKenzie

Int: Trengove Watts Tapscott

S: Toumpas

In: Pedersen, McKenzie, Evans, Gawn, Tapscott

Out: Gillies, Nicholson, Rodan, Sellar, Sylvia

AIMS:

1. Fortify the backline, thats where most of our action happens - Pederesen, Grimes down there helps

2. Get some ruck ascendency by playing Gawn along with Jamar, it takes run from the forward line but we can't get slaughtered in the ruck. Trial Evans on a wing

3. Some forward pressure in the forward line - Tapscott, Blease, Byrnes, Davey please help!

4. Midfield can not be saved. Shuffle the deck chairs and hope Trengove and Evans can do something

5. Give poor Jimmy Toumpas a break before we cook him.

[Barney Rubble 1,576]

[censored] Gillies, jamar and sylvia off, if we are going to be beaten might as well get some experience into young players

That's called tanking

[Richo31 20]

Agreed! If Gawn is fit get him in! Any wise people have some answers re: the following...1/ Will Sylvia and Toumpass be retained for WC. ( I feel both should play R 3 especially Sylvia)2/ I know this is contentious but here goes? How many games will Neeld survive if Melbourne continues to be flogged. (Flogged = 50 point loss). Note: I like him and he obviously has passion but does he have anything else? After reading all the commentary on this one I'm torn.3/ What's the progress on Taggert and Gawn. A Fit Gawn similar to the one I saw V Tigers 2 years ago is badly needed to replace an ageing and slowing Jamar. IMO. Taggert looked very promising before getting injured.4/ Is Barry any good and if so is he ready for a call up given desperate times?

Taggart a good honest toiler, fit following back injuries. Dom 'Hollywood' Barry fast and flash would bring some excitement with him. Probably a fraction light at this stage.

Joel Macdonald?

[45HG 1,559]

Out: Schwab

In: Teamwork?

[Barney Rubble 1,576]

Watts should spend time at Casey until he learns how to dominate football.

That is what should have happened from day 1.

Based on what he has shown he would not have played more than 10 games.

[TheoX 1,222]

what is with Spencer love - didn't even make the best players at Casey whereas Gawn was second best.

Anything is better than what Jamar dished up. Dom Barry would've been just as effective in the ruck. That's why the Spencer love.

[Deecisive 1,709]

I just hope those players being given a chance to recover some form in the VFL accept the challenge and fight hard to regain their spot in the team, even Gillies, then we will have a side capable of winning a few games.

[Benson 254]

FB: Garland Frawley PedersenHB: Terlich McDonald GrimesC: Evans Jones M. JonesHF: Howe Clark ByrnesFF: Davey Gawn BleaseFoll: Jamar Viney McKenzieInt: Trengove Watts TapscottS: ToumpasIn: Pedersen, McKenzie, Evans, Gawn, TapscottOut: Gillies, Nicholson, Rodan, Sellar, SylviaAIMS:1. Fortify the backline, thats where most of our action happens - Pederesen, Grimes down there helps2. Get some ruck ascendency by playing Gawn along with Jamar, it takes run from the forward line but we can't get slaughtered in the ruck. Trial Evans on a wing3. Some forward pressure in the forward line - Tapscott, Blease, Byrnes, Davey please help!4. Midfield can not be saved. Shuffle the deck chairs and hope Trengove and Evans can do something5. Give poor Jimmy Toumpas a break before we cook him.

Watts?

[spirit of norm smith 16,574]

This weeks plan

1. tag Priddis (mandatory). He got 38 possessions last time we played the weagles.

2. Clark, Davey and Howe inside fwd line.

3. Do not allow weagles a loose man in defence

4. Jamar to compete and run to crunch the opposition.

5. 2nd efforts

6. Let Frawley run, run and run. play him as a HBF.

7. Tapscott in.

8. Direct footy & fast(no going backwards ever).

9. Tackling a priority.

10. Kick to 15 metre hotspot from goal (not to the pocket ever).

[Goodvibes 3,596]

IN: McKenzie, Tapscott, Pedersen, Jetta

OUT: Gillies, Nicholson, Rodan, Toumpas

I strangely/morbidly want to see how Watts and Sylvia respond to the week of media they've had.

[spirit of norm smith 16,574]

Our personnel is like shuffling deckchairs. Neeld has words but I would like to see TANGIBLE improvement or signs.

"Tough Love". We need more than that. Neeld said "No idea. Didn't see it coming in round 1"... why ?? I saw them agst the Suns and we were lacklustre.

[w00dy 146]

Key backs: Frawley, Macdonald, Garland

Running Backs: Terlich, Dunn

Ruck: Gawn

Midfielders: N. Jones, Viney, Jetta, Grimes, Watts, Kent, Trengove, Blease, Sylvia, M. Jones

Key Forwards: Clark, Pedersen (2nd ruck)

Running Forwards: Byrnes, Howe, Davey

Sub: Bail

Emergency: Evans, Strauss, Sellar

Watts to play on a wing, and drop forward when pedersen is in the ruck. Sellar or Pedersen, I'm not too bothered which one plays. Would like to see some different players run through the middle, Jetta and Strauss when he plays.

Pick guys on form, see Gawn and Kent.