Who should we pick up?

[Grimseyisgod 378]

Isn't a Goddard type at Carlton. Don't see why he'd be any better at Melbourne.

He was a goddard type all of last year...i believe hed fit in really well with Jack Watts. Peoople are underrating Gibbs

[Grimseyisgod 378]

My only issue with Goddard is that he's a angry player, but not in a good way.. Goddard will be tough to play with if we are a little down, i saw that with him and the saints at the start of last year

[old55 23,687]

BigFooty has us into Rischitelli

[Cheap Seats 3,310]

BigFooty has us into Rischitelli

Wow, he is a handy player when fit.....

I am expecting some suprises in who we target this year!!! Looking forward to it

[MadAsHell 4,215]

BigFooty has us into Rischitelli

Wouldn't expect that to happen.

Ritschitelli chose Gold Coast ahead of Carlton when he left Brisbane because he didn't want to leave Queensland.

Good player, but don't expect that one to happen.

[GRUN DEE 69]

Now that Jurrah has set his intentions on playing in Adelaide.

Could we trade him to Adelaide for Aidan Riley? Andy Otten or Ricky Henderson as my 2nd preference. I can see us trading him for Chris Knighs.

He could walk to Port Adelaide in PSD. So I cant see Port trading with us.

If we were to trade. Matt Thomas & Justin Westoff would be ones I would target. Ben Jacobs most likely though.

Edited September 3, 2012 by GRUN DEE

[Grimseyisgod 378]

Jacobs could be good, Id love Clinton Young, Knights, Riskaaaaaaaaaaa

[Brian Wilson 331]

Ben Jacobs is a ball magnet in the making (and we are hardly overloaded with em). He will improve and he is very keen to return to Melbourne for next season. I'm very keen to get him on board.

[mdemonski2 403]

So what pick would we have to give up for jacobs?

Would really like him at the dees.

[Grimseyisgod 378]

Port Adelaide will want a good pick for him, no doubt.. i reckon we should push for second round draft pick.

Look i know there are heaps of young players around, like josh toy.

But we should look at some older players. like 2 year olds

[GRUN DEE 69]

Jordan Gysberts & 3rd rounder too Geelong for there 1st rounder (Pick 15ish) & Josh Walker (Drafted via Rookie Pick)?

Is that asking too much?

Maybe this is a bit more realistic;

Gysberts for Geelongs Pick 15?

or

Gysberts for Geelongs 2nd rounder (Pick 33) & Josh Walker?

Edited September 3, 2012 by GRUN DEE

[Brian Wilson 331]

So what pick would we have to give up for jacobs?

Would really like him at the dees.

He's in Melbourne as we speak. I hope that the FD are in his ear.

I'm still (naively?) hoping that Viney will be our second round pick. If that's the case, we can only offer first or third round picks to Port. The former is overs, the latter will not be enough to get the job done. I think that we'll have to offer a player plus third/fourth round pick. Can we throw in Jurrah?

Anything other than a first round pick will do for me. He'll be a big get. Two seasons in, his whole career ahead of him and he's keen to come home.

[Grimseyisgod 378]

I dont believe Melbourne can even trade Jurrah, thats what i heard maybe im wrong.

Viney will go father sun 2nd round no doubt

[rpfc 28,775]

I dont believe Melbourne can even trade Jurrah, thats what i heard maybe im wrong.

Viney will go father sun 2nd round no doubt

We can. But he will most likely get through to whatever club wants him in the draft.

So trade possible but unlikely.

[Biffen 12,947]

Whoever we get will sit around injured for a year and then go home or go to jail most likely .

I really dont care about individuals anymore.

I want 20 games a year out of a recruit.

With SOME good games.

Thats all.

[Grimseyisgod 378]

Whoever we get will sit around injured for a year and then go home or go to jail most likely .

I really dont care about individuals anymore.

I want 20 games a year out of a recruit.

With SOME good games.

Thats all.

although you make some good points, i believe Jurrah had something to offer Melbourne. I think that Melbournes situation is alot worse than we all think due to the vast number of changes and players we need to come back and to get into the club. Viney will take 3 years before he can really start destroying and the same with our other draft picks.

I seriously hope our pickups from other clubs really impact us, as much as Mitch Clark. I reckon we need 5 mature aged players or players from other clubs. Chris Knights, Clinton Young, Goddard, Andrew Embley and i really like the look of Daniel Pearce so he could be a good trade with Moloney in it. Than there is sharrod wellingham where we will have to give up a pick probably and stefan Martin.

ohh well, Its for the best!

[MadAsHell 4,215]

So what pick would we have to give up for jacobs?

Would really like him at the dees.

Jacobs was taken at Pick 16 in the 2010 draft, so there's a very good chance that they'd be wanting at least our Pick 13 for him.

Maybe we could secure him through Moloney, our 3rd round draft pick and a guarentee that we wont re-draft Jurrah in the PSD to spite our face, but I reckon that's a bit more unlikely.

Edit: Having said that I don't think Jurrah will play AFL next season.

Edited September 3, 2012 by Tall Defence

[old55 23,687]

Jurrah's got no trade value. If only Port wants him he just goes through the draft.

[Hannibal 5,814]

Maybe this is a bit more realistic;

Gysberts for Geelongs Pick 15?

Gysberts can't get a game at one of the worst teams in the league and the worst Melbourne side I've seen since 1981, so he's hardly worth a first round selection in a good draft.

There may be an exchange of picks involved, but I can't see him being worth a pick under 50 in the ND.

Or we may be able to do a deal that involves one of their fringe players.

Edited September 4, 2012 by Ben-Hur

[old55 23,687]

We need players not picks anyway.

[olisik 4,060]

We payed pick 11 for him, in my opinion the deal wont get done as i would not accept anything less then a 1st rounder

[Slartibartfast 17,625]

Gysberts can't get a game at one of the worst teams in the league and the worst Melbourne side I've seen since 1981, so he's hardly worth a first round selection in a good draft.

There may be an exchange of picks involved, but I can't see him being worth a pick under 50 in the ND.

Or we may be able to do a deal that involves one of their fringe players.

Moloney couldn't either and apparently there are 6 clubs interested in him. We'll get market value for Gysberts and that will depend on how many other clubs rate him. He won two rising stars in just a few games. He can clearly play but would seem not to fit Neeld's vision.

We may get something a bit better than you expect.

[Hannibal 5,814]

If there's competition we may do better, but the RS nominations won't increase his value.

Slow, no tank, no hunger, no hurt factor. Good in close, but an average to poor kick. Good VFL player who could probably play 50 - 100 AFL games.

No loss and just another wasted pick. He wasn't expected to be a first rounder and is a mile off being traded for one. Lucas, Gysberts and Melksham have all been disappointing, although the latter gets regular games.

[Demon Disciple 12,274]

And to think we could've taken Talia at #11 at the time. BP has to go down as just about the worst recruiting manager of all time.

People cannot overstate the importance of this upcoming draft for us, i'm just relieved that we don't have someone as inept as BP was in the job leading us now.

[sugar33 1]

You can wipe David McKay from the Crows off the list, Melbourne were into him big time but he resisted and is going to sign up with the Crows. It is going to be very difficult to get anyone to our club given that we are so bad at the moment.