Ling to Melbourne/ Get Cam Ling

[The heart beats true 18,123]

'The bloke was a good player and made some comments on TV I like, so he would be a really good Coach'...?

Dennis Cometti wasn't a bad player and I reckon he'd bring a lyrical game style and a dry humour to our forwards - who clearly need it with the delivery they get.

[DEELIGHTED 16]

yes to ling but if lloyd steps foot in the MFC i would be 1 very angry man.

[RickyJ45 407]

bring him back as a playing coach. put someone out there with some mettle.

[The HuLK 139]

Would love to see him take over our midfield coaching position. Fresh out of the game, and played in grand finals, captained the best football side in our era. Ling has everything we need for our young midfielders to learn from. Has played on the best midfielders the game has seen, and more often than not limited there involvement. If MFC are serious they should get rid of the out-dated "Hack Royal" and target Ling!!! Get Him

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

I think this idea has been raised before, but we could certainly do a lot worse. I would be thrilled if we signed up Lingy.

[hardtack 10,537]

We;re going to need a bigger headquarters if we get all of the people that are being suggested :-)

[dee-luded 2,959]

Would love to see him take over our midfield coaching position. Fresh out of the game, and played in grand finals, captained the best football side in our era. Ling has everything we need for our young midfielders to learn from. Has played on the best midfielders the game has seen, and more often than not limited there involvement. If MFC are serious they should get rid of the out-dated "Hack Royal" and target Ling!!! Get Him

I'd love to see him as a playing midfield coach... Offer him a nice inducement for 1 or 2 years to play, & help onfield setups, as well as at training.

[dee-luded 2,959]

We;re going to need a bigger headquarters if we get all of the people that are being suggested :-)

well we won't get all of them, but we want the best of them.

Just as we do with the players, in it to win it.

[The HuLK 139]

His speech to the GWS players was really good.. Would make our midfield stand taller.

[McQueen 17,864]

Watched a small snippet of pep-talk he gave the GWS kids the other day.

At least get him for one of those...

[rpfc 28,383]

Poor Brian Royal.

To the question of why is the midfield bad, the answer from MFC supporters is 'Brian' and 'Royal'...

Personally, I think it isn't so stupidly simple as the line coach, but that's just rpfc being rpfc.

[rjay 24,917]

I think this idea has been raised before, but we could certainly do a lot worse. I would be thrilled if we signed up Lingy.

Yep, there is already a thread on this.

[jackaub 1,402]

Poor Brian Royal.

To the question of why is the midfield bad, the answer from MFC supporters is 'Brian' and 'Royal'...

Personally, I think it isn't so stupidly simple as the line coach, but that's just rpfc being rpfc.

Dont often agree RPFC but you are absolutely correct

It must be diffficult for any line coach when all you have is 1 Huff no Puff "leader" unfit skinny players poorly skilled players and immature lets all get the ball syndrome

Nobody can work with that lot easily the worst midfield in the league

[The HuLK 139]

Poor Brian Royal.

To the question of why is the midfield bad, the answer from MFC supporters is 'Brian' and 'Royal'...

Personally, I think it isn't so stupidly simple as the line coach, but that's just rpfc being rpfc.

He is The midfield coach yeah? Our stoppage and clearance work is VFL level at best.. Need somebody just out the game.. Not a outdated dino!!

[rpfc 28,383]

He is The midfield coach yeah? Our stoppage and clearance work is VFL level at best.. Need somebody just out the game.. Not a outdated dino!!

Scott West?

lol

Mark Neeld was in charge of Collingwood's midfield when they won the flag in 2010.

Let's get him.

[The HuLK 139]

soooooooooooo Rpfc you would rather Royal, over Cam Ling? righteoooo

[rpfc 28,383]

soooooooooooo Rpfc you would rather Royal, over Cam Ling? righteoooo

I'm sorry. Are you putting him on a playing contract?

Even though Royal is in the Bulldogs Hall of Fame I would play Ling ahead of him...

If we are talking about the midfield line coach - I don't know how he is going, I can't tell you what we should attribute to him in his first year as mids line coach.

I always read on here how bad he is, but never any substance. I want substance.

I'm addicted to substances...

[McQueen 17,864]

Poor Brian Royal.

To the question of why is the midfield bad, the answer from MFC supporters is 'Brian' and 'Royal'...

Personally, I think it isn't so stupidly simple as the line coach, but that's just rpfc being rpfc.

Only for some rpfc.

I too don't consider Royal the crux of the problem but hey, on face value, Ling does have some appeal.

[Biffen 12,942]

Don't really care about Chocos feelings .Just get him out of there and get me results .Cannot comprehend why he is still there .

[rpfc 28,383]

Don't really care about Chocos feelings .Just get him out of there and get me results .Cannot comprehend why he is still there .

I don't think you read my post clearly, I am less worried about Royal's feelings than I am with the thought patterns of Melbourne supporters:

Melbourne + Brian Royal = Melbourne's Midfield is Terrible

Melbourne - Brian Royal = "Sunshine, lollipops and rainbows, Everything that's wonderful is what I feel when we're together"

[rjay 24,917]

Has a lot of respect amongst the younger players, was a good move by GWS to get him to speak with the players after the game. but as has been said he is busy with business and may not have the time. Can always ask the question though.

[Sir Why You Little 37,033]

Is it Royal or the Cattle?? Or both?

I think it is more the cattle who know the end is near.

That said, Cameron Ling's performance in the 2011 GF was all class.

A big battering ram/Sherman Tank.

He communicates well...

[nutbean 8,838]

Poor Brian Royal.

To the question of why is the midfield bad, the answer from MFC supporters is 'Brian' and 'Royal'...

Personally, I think it isn't so stupidly simple as the line coach, but that's just rpfc being rpfc.

Get this coach - get that coach. How about some of the players get some heart and pride in the jumper. It doesnt matter who the coach is - this "stuff" has got to come from inside a player and not be coaxed by some put on a pedestal people trainer

[Biffen 12,942]

Annoys me that Hird has Bomber next to him in games and Neeld has him .

Got any ideas Chocco?

The old Beamer /Jamar thing isn't working .

Nathan Jones is improving every year .

The others seem to be reversing.

[Tatu 416]

Has a lot of respect amongst the younger players, was a good move by GWS to get him to speak with the players after the game. but as has been said he is busy with business and may not have the time. Can always ask the question though.

May be he'd consider a part time roll? He'd be a get for our midfield......