Eishold, Campbell & Yeats - fourth quarter 87 prelim - any one of them could have sealed a grand final berth for us & none were difficult shots - still sticks it my craw ..

oh how that stinging memory comes back. "Tell me why I don't like Mondays"!!

Riewoldt 2010 GF Replay? It was a great smother by Shaw but [censored] me, have some awareness Roo!!

Riewoldt 2010 GF Replay? It was a great smother by Shaw but [censored] me, have some awareness Roo!!

finished the game that one. The camera angle was perfect, we could all see it except St.nick..a great "what if" moment.

Although ive seen the kick, as it was before i was born, can someone please set the scene for me. I know it was a PF, but how long was left and what were the scores...

Wow...that really was bad!

Stephen Powell against West Coast at Suby, can't remember the year....game in the balance, dying minutes (2000?) gathers the ball and tries to pump it long. his kick literally went SIDEWAYS into an unsuspecting Woey (who nearly died of shock) 2 bounces and the ensuing goal was the sealer.

I still smile thinking about Powelly's skills......

There is a fabulous photo of Northey glaring at a crestfallen Stynes in the rooms after the PF. Picture tells a 1000 words.

As I recall, and please correct me if needed, Eishold's inexplicable miss of the match sealer for a behind resulted in the kick-in that went in one or two uncontested possessions to Buckenara who marked out of range. The siren went, Jimma infringed, 15 metre penalty, goal......season over.

Also from distant memory, there was some discussion as to whether the 15m penalty was correct: at the time I don't think crossing the mark automatically resulted in a 15, but time wasting did. Now as the siren had sounded, how could this have wasted time?

Still, had Esihold not missed, this would be a distant incidental nothing.

As I recall, and please correct me if needed, Eishold's inexplicable miss of the match sealer for a behind resulted in the kick-in that went in one or two uncontested possessions to Buckenara who marked out of range. The siren went, Jimma infringed, 15 metre penalty, goal......season over.

Also from distant memory, there was some discussion as to whether the 15m penalty was correct: at the time I don't think crossing the mark automatically resulted in a 15, but time wasting did. Now as the siren had sounded, how could this have wasted time?

Still, had Esihold not missed, this would be a distant incidental nothing.

did buckenara actually mark the ball or was he free-ed?

As I recall, Eishold's inexplicable miss of the match sealer for a behind resulted in the kick-in.

I think it was Campbell's grab for glory - blazing away from 40, with a one-armed Robbie in the square alone.

This is all like a recurring nightmare, I don't know why I'm feeding it.....

did buckenara actually mark the ball or was he free-ed?

Free-ed. Pushed in the back right on 50. Would've had to kick it 65m to clear the pack with a tired leg.

As I recall he was shaping up to kick a barrel when Stynes did the unthinkable.

The essendon player that got tackled in the dying minutes against Carlton ?prelimination final 98.

?Salmon missing the goal and kicking the post

Gehrig trying to kick a goal and being brought down by Carrol ? semi final 2006 Brocks break out game.

For anyone who's interested, just found this rare footage of Swooper Northey being interviewed after the '87 prelim.

He starts talking at 7:59 in.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cBS-HbG-u3U&feature=related

IMHO, the events from "that day on 1987" belong to a category of horror and revulsion equal to Salo or Human Centipede (1 and 2): not to be viewed.

Actually, having been at VFL Park on that day, I'd contend it's more not to be viewed AGAIN. There is no joy at all in remembering that game. None.

Loosely on topic, (excepting "that day on 1987"); our first match at Carrara (umm, in 1987). Shocker. Playing the Bears, we were barely playing. Very ordinary match, but we lead all day. Bears closed in our lead in fast fading light. Deep late in the match leading by a point we worked it hard from the backline running it along the wing. Rod Grinter(?) centres the footy, turn over, David Banfield swoops takes it forward. Dodgy Weezey Skase's Qintex Bears goal and hang on to win in the dark.

OK, not the worst "most important" kick, but a shocker and against very ordinary opposition.

Call me a masochist but I just watched the last 5 minutes of the '87 prelim again. I keep hoping for a different result but it's always the same ... Campbell misses, Yeats misses and then Eishold writes his name into infamy.

I kind of feel sorry for Eishold. He's copped the heat all these years but let me tell you Graeme Yeats is not far behind. Couple of minutes to go and Ricky Jackson burns off his opponent wide on the half forward flank at VFL Park, bounces twice, sweeps a handball to a teammate on 50 ... the crowd roar becomes deafening as the ball is then relayed to Yeats .... who streams into pretty much an open goal and .... inexplicably sprays it wide from 25 metres out on the run.

He kicks that goal 49 times out of 50 at training.

Edited December 5, 201114 yr by Range Rover

I'll paint the picture.

1976 last round.

Bluebaggers playing Doggies. Loser goes out of finals and dees playing pies at Vic park only have to win.

Melb wins Pies get wooden spoon.

Bluebaggers playing doggies.------ Walls marks 2m out on an angle and hits the post.

Both teams get 2 points and Melb miss finals.

Filth supporters are cheering at vic park as if they had just won a final.

Thanks for the 2 above posts. I really needed to read them...NOT!!!

Back on topic - the very same H.Mann, having done the above in the penultimate H&A game, takes a mark about 15 metres out straight in front late in last quarter of GF to put us in front, only to fluff it with a shocker. Fortunately, soon after, an even worse field kick from Brian Dixon fell into the arms of Neil.....and we drift off topic again.

... spilled (or palmed?) by Barassi with crompton getting a nice bounce. the most amazing thing was the kickout by the fullback (which Dixon marked).