Coaches' votes

[Eth 4]

Interesting seeing the votes from the game on the weekend.

Melbourne v Fremantle

8 Brad Green (Melb)

5 Dustin Martin (Melb)

5 Jordie McKenzie (Melb)

4 Tom Scully (Melb)

3 Nathan Jones (Melb)

3 Jack Watts (Melb)

2 Nathan Fyfe (Fre)

First, that's copied and pasted off the AFL site, not the HUN as you might have guessed from the wrong name in second place.

Second, Green BOG and Jones got votes...that's odd. Must've gone something like this:

Dean Bailey

5 Jordie McKenzie

4 Brad Green

3 Jack Watts

2 Tom Scully

1 Nathan Fyfe

Mark Harvey

5 Stefan (or Dustin) Martin

4 Brad Green

3 Nathan Jones

2 Tom Scully

1 Nathan Fyfe

Would've assumed McKenzie and Martin would have been high up in the voting from both coaches but it doesn't look possible.

[Striker475 696]

Jordie is massively, massively underrated by a lot of opposition coaches IMO.

Well, except Neil Craig.

[hardtack 10,187]

Jordie is massively, massively underrated by a lot of opposition coaches IMO.

I think you will find that Jones is massively, massively underrated by many posters on the forums, but coaches see what he is creating with his plays and acknowledge him for it. Just because he isn't flashy doesn't mean he isn't having a big impact on the game - it is often Jones who is getting the hard ball out to the likes of Scully who are then able to dazzle with their free running play. But, I'm a Jones fan, so that probably devalues my comments :-)

[Bang Bang Bang 5,605]

I reckon Mark Harvey would have given Jordie Mac the 5. Firstly, because he kept Pavlova out of the game (Harvey's only real asset on the day). Also I think Bailey was quoted as saying he wasn't too pleased with the overuse of the handball by some of the midfielders. Jordie had 2 kicks 26 handballs.

[mrtwister 650]

It is hard to kick on all fours or from under a pack of players.

[Chook 14,701]

It is hard to kick on all fours or from under a pack of players.

But it's easy to kick when Jack Watts handballs it to you four times in 30 seconds. Eventually the penny should drop that you should kick the damn thing before you get caught with it.

[Mac7 309]

I think you will find that Jones is massively, massively underrated by many posters on the forums, but coaches see what he is creating with his plays and acknowledge him for it. Just because he isn't flashy doesn't mean he isn't having a big impact on the game - it is often Jones who is getting the hard ball out to the likes of Scully who are then able to dazzle with their free running play. But, I'm a Jones fan, so that probably devalues my comments :-)

Yeah I'm a Jones fan too. Think he does a lot of the hard stuff that often goes un-noticed. Its all about playing your role within the team.

[DeeSpencer 23,642]

Could have gone like this:

Bailey Harvey

5 - Green Martin

4 - McKenzie Scully

3 - Jones Green

2 - Fyfe Watts

1 - Watts McKenzie

We'll never know. I know that personally it would have been a hard game for me to give votes in. At the ground on the day I liked the work of Scully early and thought Watts was very clean and Fyfe was very good for Freo. I probably would have thrown in Martin for some of his brilliance and especially after I saw the stats difference of McKenzie v Pav he'd have to get votes, but that was harder to see at the game.

[Supermercado 2,682]

Broken hearted by the lack of love for the Stef Martin Experience from Bails.

[hardtack 10,187]

Broken hearted by the lack of love for the Stef Martin Experience from Bails.

What gives you that impression?

[rpfc 27,678]

Broken hearted by the lack of love for the Stef Martin Experience from Bails.

You do realise that that is how the poster thinks they voted...

I wish the posters who like to do these wouldn't give their "this is how it might have worked" - it is so pointless.

Why? Because you then extrapolate from an assumption.

And that is literally pointless.

[satyricon 267]

I tried to extrapolate an assumption once, but I ended up surmising on a spread of statistics instead, metraphorically speaking of course

[hardtack 10,187]

I tried to extrapolate an assumption once, but I ended up surmising on a spread of statistics instead, metraphorically speaking of course

Don't tell me, you disappeared up your own fundament?

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

Yeah I'm a Jones fan too. Think he does a lot of the hard stuff that often goes un-noticed. Its all about playing your role within the team.

there was one unbelievable moment where he emerged froma pack and about 5 blokes tried to bring him down in heavy traffic but he just kept shrugging them off until he could fire of a handball to a passing teammate, ball was near the centre, we were kicking to the city end, got a huge recognition from the faithful

[Supermercado 2,682]

You do realise that that is how the poster thinks they voted...

I wish the posters who like to do these wouldn't give their "this is how it might have worked" - it is so pointless.

Why? Because you then extrapolate from an assumption.

And that is literally pointless.

Cheerfully withdrawn. I'll assume there is much love.

[Nasher 33,246]

Broken hearted by the lack of love for the Stef Martin Experience from Bails.

I'd be stunned if Bails doesn't love The Experience.