My god.

Last time I looked at a Scully thread before this afternoon, the closed thread was only at 28 pages in length.

I've now (god knows why) read all of it.

It began hilarious, but by the end I was left depressed... by the stupidity of some of our supporters.

I think I've now reached the point where I don't even care!

I just want the season to end so we can conclusively find out the result.

Stepping away from the contract situation for a minute...

How bad is his haircut? Would have to be the worst in the league at present.

Since when have Richmond been in the running to get Scully?

Can someone please inform me why they would stand a chance? We could offer him more salary wise?

I know he was a supporter, but that means jack! Pendles, Judd and Buddy were avid Melbourne supporters, but I see them at other clubs?

Can someone inform me why we have turned away from GWS to Punt Road?

Received my $200 raffle ticket in the mail today. LJ and Skull are on it, surely the Dees wouldn't market this Player if they knew he was leaving. I'm a firm believer he will stay and am very disappointed with the amount of negativity directed towards him. He will be a part of our great team for years to come!

Since when have Richmond been in the running to get Scully?

Can someone please inform me why they would stand a chance? We could offer him more salary wise?

I know he was a supporter, but that means jack! Pendles, Judd and Buddy were avid Melbourne supporters, but I see them at other clubs?

Can someone inform me why we have turned away from GWS to Punt Road?

adds more pages to the thread???

essendon signed 6 today, including their best young kid heppell.. its not that hard tom, either you want to be here or you dont.. simple

The one Essendon player constantly linked with GWS is Michael Hurley who comes out of contract end of next year. Trust me thats the signature that Essendon really want.

The one Essendon player constantly linked with GWS is Michael Hurley who comes out of contract end of next year. Trust me thats the signature that Essendon really want.

There are 16 other teams that would move the earth to get his signature. Imagine Watts and Hurley in the same forward line, with Howe and Jurrah bobbing up around them... Be better then the buddyroughcyril

Tom scully to Richmond for Dustin Martin and everyone is happy

Tom scully to Richmond for Dustin Martin and everyone is happy

I'm not

By your logic it is obvious the Gary Ablett Jnr rates GC17 as a better prospect than Geelong. Can you see any flaws in your logic ?

Nutbean,

Well, no. Ablett did indeed go to GC17. As a 10 year player, with a Brownlow, two premierships, a fight with his previous coach, a sense of job-well-done at Geelong, and a golden chance at a superannuated juicy payday, he obviously did rate GC17 as a better prospect than Geelong.

On the other hand, Kreuzer & Scully, two gun players of similar pedigree and experience, have their whole careers in front of them. Kreuzer rates the West Sydney Ramraiders a worse prospect than Carlton. Will Scully rate Melbourne a worst prospect than the West Sydney Ramraiders (or one of the big Melbourne clubs)?

Again, Melbourne Bigger Clubs?

Why? Why has this new speculation started?

OK Judd and Buddy to Demons .Dunn and Bate to Carlton , D.martin to Demons for Morton.. Done .

OK Judd and Buddy to Demons .Dunn and Bate to Carlton , D.martin to Demons for Morton.. Done .

More than reasnoable i would say Walter Dude!!

Stepping away from the contract situation for a minute...

How bad is his haircut? Would have to be the worst in the league at present.

Have you seen Dustin Martin's haircut??

Jurrahs was nearly as bad as Danny Southern .

if/when he does eventually sign, whenever that glorious moment will be, who wants to join me for a quiet celebratory drink or '31' at crown?

i will be ecstatic if he signs, stick it up all the journalists who think he will leave

just a note also on the guys who were concerned with his expression during the singing of the song, tom isn't the kind of bloke who expresses himself that much after a win, he is so focused on footy he'd rather be doing his warm downs. He's a kid who hasn't touched a drop of alcohol or tobacco once in his life in order to pursue his goal, he loves the sport and I honestly can't see him betraying a club like Melbourne, he's not the kind of kid

Again, Melbourne Bigger Clubs?

Why? Why has this new speculation started?

Because we feel inadequate when compared to others.

Really wish we could just arrogantly sit back and say we will keep him.

Other clubs' supporters would.

We are going to be fracking relevant very soon, if Tom decides to stick around we will be absolutely fracking relevant.

if/when he does eventually sign, whenever that glorious moment will be, who wants to join me for a quiet celebratory drink or '31' at crown?

i will be ecstatic if he signs, stick it up all the journalists who think he will leave

just a note also on the guys who were concerned with his expression during the singing of the song, tom isn't the kind of bloke who expresses himself that much after a win, he is so focused on footy he'd rather be doing his warm downs. He's a kid who hasn't touched a drop of alcohol or tobacco once in his life in order to pursue his goal, he loves the sport and I honestly can't see him betraying a club like Melbourne, he's not the kind of kid

i for one would love to be there...

Can`t believe how much "trash Scully talk" is going on here!! lmaoo To Collingwood now?? Matter of time wasn`t it?? Everyone needs to take a deep breath!

Really wish we could just arrogantly sit back and say we will keep him.

Other clubs' supporters would.

As if. There were plenty of nervous nelles at Collingwood, Carlton, Essendon, etc.

Rpfc suffering from a bout of MFCSS himself..?

Haha couldn't resist.

Jurrahs was nearly as bad as Danny Southern .

Davey reckons that he looks like he's got a possum stuck to his head...

if/when he does eventually sign, whenever that glorious moment will be, who wants to join me for a quiet celebratory drink or '31' at crown?

i will be ecstatic if he signs, stick it up all the journalists who think he will leave

just a note also on the guys who were concerned with his expression during the singing of the song, tom isn't the kind of bloke who expresses himself that much after a win, he is so focused on footy he'd rather be doing his warm downs. He's a kid who hasn't touched a drop of alcohol or tobacco once in his life in order to pursue his goal, he loves the sport and I honestly can't see him betraying a club like Melbourne, he's not the kind of kid

Drinks will be served...absolutely...we must organize a night.

The "whisper" is that Scully not happy with direction of club.I am wondering exactly what about the 'direction' is being referred to. Is it about the coach, is it a rumour is it baseless. At the end of the day, supporting the Dees is a victory of faith. When I see what belief Jimmy Stynes has instilled into the club combined with our great playing list I have great confidence in our direction. We have other clubs seeking to mimic our debt demolition strategy: Footscray, Port Adelaide, Richmond, but can they emulate what we achieved? When Grimes, Tapscott, Jamar, Bail and Davey are fit, whose place do they take? That is the true picture of where we are at.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/has-seaford-given-the-saints-a-sinking-feeling/story-e6frf9jf-1226079424137

The "whisper" is that Scully not happy with direction of club.

Ralph's been reading Demonland posts talking about singing the club song and orange powerade.