Jump to content

A Two-Tiered AFL Competition

Featured Replies

  On 08/06/2011 at 12:13, tonatopia said:

I agree 100%. Its just a matter of time until a 2 tier system comes into play.

+1. Despite the lashings of paranoid negativity and horrible squealings about the 'ORIGINAL' club (proto-British elitism at its finest) not being able to play off for a premiership in any given year, there WILL be a divisional separation of the AFL in the future. Given that there will be a Tasmanian team and an ACT team at some point not too distant, a 20 team competition becomes unworkable based purely on the dilemmas of fixturing and dead rubbers. That will NOT generate interest in games and won't foster patronage, sponsorship, and general growth of the game. It's simply a stagnant approach to a changing competition.

The AFL has put in place the best systems of interclub fairness of any elite sporting competition in the world, being the national draft, the salary cap, and division of profits (outside the home game gate receipts system). In fact, they even financially assist clubs where needed, and strangely enough, we have benefited. So I suspect they're not out to bury us, or North Melbourne, or Port Adelaide, or whoever. Whether we like/hate Demetriou and his tribunal mangling minion Anderson, it is an impressively democratic sporting competition.

It is clear this 2 tier idea has provoked a polarity of opinions, but I think the detractors are being emotionally driven by our own club's poor showing over the past 45 years, and the not unfounded fear that we will lose touch with the more successful clubs and continue to be starved of success. Lack of success will do that to you. That emotion directs itself to the AFL, who somehow become responsible for wanting to keep us (and other non-successful clubs) down. This is paranoid conspiracy theory nonsense.

It is pure logic for the AFL to want more clubs, which represent the broadest scope of this country, and to do EVERYTHING they can to fertilise support for each and EVERY one of these clubs. I think it is the best approach, and is exciting to watch it unfold, particularly GWS! They would look back on the loss of Fitzroy with some regret for this reason. They know that the larger percentage of Fitzroy supporters lost the passion for the game borne of loyalty, and by implication more gate receipts, and they will not want to repeat that.

The two-tier system that Brendan Schwab has devised will anger a lot of people, as shown here, but these people will NOT stop supporting their clubs. In total honesty, how many posters here would stop supporting the Demons because we found ourselves in tier 2?, as that is the worst scenario that can come from this idea. You're in tier 2. What happens then? You get higher draft picks, the salary cap means you won't get all your best players stolen (and that's what the salary cap ensures), and you have a fresh chance of being promoted that year. EVERY year. And when you're in tier 1, you have a better chance of winning the flag.

If the cap/draft/profit share system proves nothing else, it is that you create a rotation of success through the competition, and whilst not ALL clubs win the premiership during their rotation, they will all get the best possible opportunity. I love the Melbourne Football Club, and it deserves this opportunity. Some of us on here believe Schwab's system would do nothing to damage this opportunity, some of us don't.

Vive le difference!

 
  • Author
  On 08/06/2011 at 22:34, Webber said:

+1. Despite the lashings of paranoid negativity and horrible squealings about the 'ORIGINAL' club (proto-British elitism at its finest) not being able to play off for a premiership in any given year, there WILL be a divisional separation of the AFL in the future. Given that there will be a Tasmanian team and an ACT team at some point not too distant, a 20 team competition becomes unworkable based purely on the dilemmas of fixturing and dead rubbers. That will NOT generate interest in games and won't foster patronage, sponsorship, and general growth of the game. It's simply a stagnant approach to a changing competition.

The AFL has put in place the best systems of interclub fairness of any elite sporting competition in the world, being the national draft, the salary cap, and division of profits (outside the home game gate receipts system). In fact, they even financially assist clubs where needed, and strangely enough, we have benefited. So I suspect they're not out to bury us, or North Melbourne, or Port Adelaide, or whoever. Whether we like/hate Demetriou and his tribunal mangling minion Anderson, it is an impressively democratic sporting competition.

It is clear this 2 tier idea has provoked a polarity of opinions, but I think the detractors are being emotionally driven by our own club's poor showing over the past 45 years, and the not unfounded fear that we will lose touch with the more successful clubs and continue to be starved of success. Lack of success will do that to you. That emotion directs itself to the AFL, who somehow become responsible for wanting to keep us (and other non-successful clubs) down. This is paranoid conspiracy theory nonsense.

It is pure logic for the AFL to want more clubs, which represent the broadest scope of this country, and to do EVERYTHING they can to fertilise support for each and EVERY one of these clubs. I think it is the best approach, and is exciting to watch it unfold, particularly GWS! They would look back on the loss of Fitzroy with some regret for this reason. They know that the larger percentage of Fitzroy supporters lost the passion for the game borne of loyalty, and by implication more gate receipts, and they will not want to repeat that.

The two-tier system that Brendan Schwab has devised will anger a lot of people, as shown here, but these people will NOT stop supporting their clubs. In total honesty, how many posters here would stop supporting the Demons because we found ourselves in tier 2?, as that is the worst scenario that can come from this idea. You're in tier 2. What happens then? You get higher draft picks, the salary cap means you won't get all your best players stolen (and that's what the salary cap ensures), and you have a fresh chance of being promoted that year. EVERY year. And when you're in tier 1, you have a better chance of winning the flag.

If the cap/draft/profit share system proves nothing else, it is that you create a rotation of success through the competition, and whilst not ALL clubs win the premiership during their rotation, they will all get the best possible opportunity. I love the Melbourne Football Club, and it deserves this opportunity. Some of us on here believe Schwab's system would do nothing to damage this opportunity, some of us don't.

Vive le difference!

Nicely written. I am definitely in the "do it" camp.

Whether tier one or tier two, I'll still be red and blue!

 
  On 08/06/2011 at 07:40, Dappa Dan said:

Use the NFL model. Two Conferences... you play the teams in your conference twice, and the teams in the other conference once (roughly. Works out that you still play everyone once, and a few teams twice)...

Top 4 teams from both conferences advance to finals. Works a treat over there. In fact they have twice as many teams, so to sort it out they have 2 conferences, and those two 16-team conferences have 4 divisions of four... winner of each division advances, plus the two next-best performed teams.

I love it, personally. It takes a few minutes to soak it all in... but then so does our comp, when you look at finals.

If you do it this way, you get conference or division rivals... Which become MASSIVE games... like this one. One of the top 3 things I've ever seen in sport.

+1 Dan. Much better option than relegation which AFL will never consider and is not even worth discussing. Details would need to be worked out but other than that.... BRING ON THE CONFERENCE!!!

  On 08/06/2011 at 23:06, rpfc said:

I'm more driven to hate the idea because it is awful.

SWEEEEET RP..... and even that's more than it deserves! :lol:


  On 08/06/2011 at 22:56, Range Rover said:

Nicely written. I am definitely in the "do it" camp.

Whether tier one or tier two, I'll still be red and blue!

When creating a 2 - tier system, it must allow for further expansion, and also maintain 22 rounds per season. 25 rounds would be too taxing on the players. I think the conference system of the NFL would work a treat.

Future additional teams in the AFL would include;

Tasmania.

Canberra

Northern Territory

Cairns

*** Kangaroos should represent Regional Victoria.

I'm sorry if I sound condescending but it is the height of naivete to think that Canberra can support an AFL side.

There is no market for it.

None.

Raiders struggle.

Brumbies own the place and they can't compete in the S15's.

So, sorry, no 19th club up here.

  On 09/06/2011 at 00:03, rpfc said:

I'm sorry if I sound condescending but it is the height of naivete to think that Canberra can support an AFL side.

There is no market for it.

None.

Raiders struggle.

Brumbies own the place and they can't compete in the S15's.

So, sorry, no 19th club up here.

Sorry for condescending ?..hardly you thrive on it.. so lets pass on the pleasantries.. We can al lsee through them.

Canberra like most other infrastructure richcities will grow. Australias population will require it do so. They all cant live in the Melbournes and Sydneys of this land. Its currentpopulation of over 350000 will grow easily to 1/2 Million within the same forecasted developmental period being applied to GWS. Yes the raiders struggle...newsflash....the NRL is struggling.. one begets the other. The AFL is flourishing in the very same environments. Dont be so quick to write off a Canberran team within 10 yeras. Arguably AFTER GWS and a Tassie team have taken root.

A Tier 2 team would slot in quite well . it would be another generational project. It will also be a prestige project as eventually the AFL will need to have a team of ITS code in the Nation's capital....Its bragging rights. The AFL wants to punish and bury the NRL. ( and so it should, cr@p game) Just an opinion

 
  On 09/06/2011 at 00:42, belzebub59 said:

Sorry for condescending ?..hardly you thrive on it.. so lets pass on the pleasantries.. We can al lsee through them.

Canberra like most other infrastructure richcities will grow. Australias population will require it do so. They all cant live in the Melbournes and Sydneys of this land. Its currentpopulation of over 350000 will grow easily to 1/2 Million within the same forecasted developmental period being applied to GWS. Yes the raiders struggle...newsflash....the NRL is struggling.. one begets the other. The AFL is flourishing in the very same environments. Dont be so quick to write off a Canberran team within 10 yeras. Arguably AFTER GWS and a Tassie team have taken root.

A Tier 2 team would slot in quite well . it would be another generational project. It will also be a prestige project as eventually the AFL will need to have a team of ITS code in the Nation's capital....Its bragging rights. The AFL wants to punish and bury the NRL. ( and so it should, cr@p game) Just an opinion

I am a very pleasant person.

And, Canberra's infrastrucutre is rich? That's rich...

The place is tired and old, and the territory has no money for projects. The rental market is the worst in the country as there is little development to keep up with the modest population increases through students, and public servants.

Outside of the public service and the servic industry that feeds the public service, there is no other market to attract people up here.

Coz the weather ain't gonna get people to move up here...

The population is not going to be big enough to support an AFL side with the Raiders and the Brumbies in existence.

I can get you 30k members overnight. I cannot get you sponsors and corporate support.

Not going to happen.

  On 09/06/2011 at 00:59, rpfc said:

I am a very pleasant person.

And, Canberra's infrastrucutre is rich? That's rich...

The place is tired and old, and the territory has no money for projects. The rental market is the worst in the country as there is little development to keep up with the modest population increases through students, and public servants.

Outside of the public service and the servic industry that feeds the public service, there is no other market to attract people up here.

Coz the weather ain't gonna get people to move up here...

The population is not going to be big enough to support an AFL side with the Raiders and the Brumbies in existence.

I can get you 30k members overnight. I cannot get you sponsors and corporate support.

Not going to happen.

Never?


  • 1 month later...

Zero chance. Not in this broadcasting rights deal, not in any where they want to get a fat wad of cash for showing the games.

Unless Channel 31 are going to pay a mil to show a 2nd Division R24 dead rubber between us and Port.

  On 06/08/2011 at 12:10, Range Rover said:

BUMP

It's coming. Just a matter of time.

under what format?? Can't we just leave the game alone for a decade or so?? Let it settle.

The AFL changes weekly now!!!!


  • Author

In fact it's already here, only it hasn't been formalized into two leagues yet. We simply have the haves and have not and about 50% of season's matches are meaningless dead rubbers.

  On 07/06/2011 at 23:40, Range Rover said:

http://www.theage.co...0607-1fr2x.html

I have always thought that this is the way the AFL will eventually go and think Brendan Schwab is on the right track with his model outlined in that article.

With an ever expanding competition, relegation and promotion provides fans with that great intangible that keeps us all coming back year after year .... hope.

We absolutely must create a system where interest remains until the very last round of the year, and where effort is rewarded to sides who are battling to get back up the ladder.

It will also dilute this unhealthy obsession we all have with gaining high draft picks.

No. Just get rid of all these rotations, and the game will settle back down to what we had in the 90's football.

We either have to reduce the bench further to 2 interchange, Plus 1 sub, Plus 1 Emerg, on call.... If not this then we have to reduce the number of players onfield to 17. But we have to stop the amount of ground covered today, which ends up being used to clog up the space, instead of playing "man on man".

The game has become rubbish.

  On 06/08/2011 at 12:22, Range Rover said:

In fact it's already here, only it hasn't been formalized into two leagues yet. We simply have the haves and have not and about 50% of season's matches are meaningless dead rubbers.

A two tier system or a relegation system is a VFL/VFA all over again.

Those who are in the lower half will die slowly of financial strangulation.

Poor old WCE...

Wouldn't be a chance for the top 4 this year if we had a two-tier system...

  • Author
  On 06/08/2011 at 12:30, rpfc said:

Poor old WCE...

Wouldn't be a chance for the top 4 this year if we had a two-tier system...

An aberration here or there doesn't halt the trend.


Lets have a 3 tiered competition. 3 teams in one, 11 teams in the next and 4 in the last.

  On 06/08/2011 at 12:36, Range Rover said:

An aberration here or there doesn't halt the trend.

AFL sides in the second tier will die....how can this be a good idea?

  • Author
  On 06/08/2011 at 12:38, Redleg said:

Lets have a 3 tiered competition. 3 teams in one, 11 teams in the next and 4 in the last.

Hope is the currency which keeps the punters coming through the turnstiles year after year, But it's a finite quality.

Honestly, with the way things are headed in an expanded 18 team competition (and quite possibly a 20 team competition in 10-20 years), how much hope to Melbourne supporters, Richmond supporters, Port, the Dogs etc really have of ever seeing their

team take home the elusive silverware?

Are we just pi$$ing in the wind here? I'm beginning to wonder. And for the first time in my life my reserves of hope are wearing a bit thin.

 
  On 06/08/2011 at 12:44, Range Rover said:

Are we just pi$$ing in the wind here? I'm beginning to wonder. And for the first time in my life my reserves of hope are wearing a bit thin.

Now this is a different argument...

We will get there.

  On 07/06/2011 at 23:40, Range Rover said:

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/afl-relegation-plan-20110607-1fr2x.html

I have always thought that this is the way the AFL will eventually go and think Brendan Schwab is on the right track with his model outlined in that article.

With an ever expanding competition, relegation and promotion provides fans with that great intangible that keeps us all coming back year after year .... hope.

We absolutely must create a system where interest remains until the very last round of the year, and where effort is rewarded to sides who are battling to get back up the ladder.

It will also dilute this unhealthy obsession we all have with gaining high draft picks.

And the Weagles would have no hope of playing in the big time this year - so much for rags to riches stories, however achieved!!

Every club does have its lows - no way that the AFL would allow Collingwood to play in division 2, nor to miss out on their favorites each other playing twice in a season at OUR home ground.


Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Featured Content

  • GAMEDAY: West Coast

    It's Game Day and the Demons have a chance to notch up their third consecutive win — something they haven’t done since Round 5, 2024. But to do it, they’ll need to exorcise the Demons of last year’s disastrous trip out West. Can the Dees continue their momentum, right the wrongs of that fateful clash, and take another step up the ladder on the road to redemption?

      • Clap
      • Haha
      • Love
      • Like
    • 43 replies
    Demonland
  • FEATURE: 1925

    A hundred years ago today, on 2 May 1925, Melbourne kicked off the new season with a 47 point victory over St Kilda to take top place on the VFL ladder after the opening round of the new season.  Top place was a relatively unknown position for the team then known as the “Fuchsias.” They had finished last in 1923 and rose by only one place in the following year although the final home and away round heralded a promise of things to come when they surprised the eventual premiers Essendon. That victory set the stage for more improvement and it came rapidly. In this series, I will tell the story of how the 1925 season unfolded for the Melbourne Football Club and how it made the VFL finals for the first time in a decade on the way to the ultimate triumph a year later.

    • 0 replies
    Demonland
  • PREVIEW: West Coast

    Saturday’s election night game in Perth between the West Coast Eagles and Melbourne represents 18th vs 15th which makes it a tough decision as to which party to favour. The Eagles have yet to break the ice under their new coach in Andrew McQualter who is the second understudy in a row to confront Demon Coach Simon Goodwin who was also winless until a fortnight ago. On that basis, many punters might be considering to go with the donkey vote but I’ve been assigned with the task of helping readers to come to a considered opinion on this matter of vital importance across the nation. It was almost a year ago that I wrote a preview here of the Demons’ away game against the Eagles (under the name William from Waalitj because it was Indigenous Round).  I issued a warning that it was a danger game, based on my local knowledge that the home team were no longer easybeats and that they possessed a wunderkind generational player in Harley Reid who was capable of producing stellar performances playing among men a decade and more older than he.  At the time, the Eagles already had two wins off the back of a couple of the young man’s masterclasses and they had recently given the Bombers a scare straight after their Anzac Day blockbuster draw against the then reigning premiers.

    • 1 reply
    Demonland
  • NON-MFC: Round 08

    Round 08 of the 2025 AFL Season kicks off on Thursday with a must-win game for the Bombers to stay in touch with the top eight, while the struggling Roos seek a morale-boosting upset. Friday sees the Saints desperate for a win as well if they are to stay in finals contention and their opponents the Dockers will be eager to crack in to the Top 8 with a win on the road. Saturday kicks off with a pivotal clash for both sides asthe Bulldogs look to solidify their top-eight spot, while Port seeks to shake their pretender tag. Then the Crows will be looking to steady their topsy turvy season against a resurgent Blues looking to make it 4 wins on the trot. On Election Night a Blockbuster will see the ladder-leading Pies take on the Cats, who are keen to bounce back after a narrow loss. On Sunday the Sydney Derby promises fireworks as the Giants aim to cement their top-eight status, while the Swans fight to keep their season alive. The Hawks, celebrating their centenary, will be looking to easily account for the Tigers who are desperate to halt their slide. The Round concludes on Sunday Night with a top end of the table QClash with significant ladder implications; both Queensland teams are in scintillating form. Who are you tipping this week and what are the best results for the Demons?

    • 173 replies
    Demonland
  • PREGAME: West Coast

    The Demons hit the road in Round 8, heading to Perth to face the West Coast Eagles at Optus Stadium. With momentum building, the Dees will be aiming for a third straight victory to keep their season revival on course. Who comes in and who goes out?

      • Clap
      • Like
    • 563 replies
    Demonland
  • REPORT: Richmond

    The fans who turned up to the MCG for Melbourne’s Anzac Day Eve clash against Richmond would have been disappointed if they turned up to see a great spectacle. As much as this was a night for the 71,635 in attendance to commemorate heroes of the nation’s past wars, it was also a time for the Melbourne Football Club to consolidate upon its first win after a horrific start to the 2025 season. On this basis, despite the fact that it was an uninspiring and dour struggle for most of its 100 minutes, the night will be one for the fans to remember. They certainly got value out of the pre match activity honouring those who fought for their country. The MCG and the lights of the city as backdrop was made for nights such as these and, in my view, we received a more inspirational ceremony of Anzac culture than others both here and elsewhere around the country. 

    • 0 replies
    Demonland