am i one to believe he is actually part of the tribunal commitee?? if so jeez james thought u were better then that..

You're being a bit silly, dazz.

how

I guess we didn't realise how upset he as at being sacked last year.

yes because James McDonald is that type of person

Aren't there a few available, and they rotate around?

yes because James McDonald is that type of person

Do we know if he actually sat on the Tribunal tonight? I would doubt he did being a former teammate of the accused player.

Great thead, moves my Dean Bailey thread from the most despised of the week.

Just love a good conspiracy theory... shame this is a less than ordinary one.

Edited May 10, 201114 yr by hardtack

Here

Here

You would think that having been Jack Trengove's captain and a former teammate that Junior would have excused himself.

There's a legal principle which applies to such matters and the Tribunal is an administrative body which should uphold such a principle as the right to a fair hearing where an adjudicator has no conflict of interest.

conflict of interest.

You would think that having been Jack Trengove's captain and a former teammate that Junior would have excused himself.

There's a legal principle which applies to such matters and the Tribunal is an administrative body which you would expect to abide by such a principle.

You could see a potential conflict of interest - if Jack had gotten off

To be clear.. MRP.

...

The Tribunal tonight was Emmett Dunne, Wayne Schimmelbusch and Wayne Henwood. Henwood played a few games with the Dees.

The Tribunal tonight was Emmett Dunne, Wayne Schimmelbusch and Wayne Henwood. Henwood played a few games with the Dees.

Schimma.....

Schimma.....

Ahem! Ahem! Who did he play for/coach? Would have thought he would have to excuse himself?

The Tribunal tonight was Emmett Dunne, Wayne Schimmelbusch and Wayne Henwood. Henwood played a few games with the Dees.

"Moose" Henwood played 1 Game for Melbourne.