Shortest list that I've seen for years:-

Robert Campbell (achilles) - 4 weeks

Jordie McKenzie (groin) - 3 weeks

Tom Scully (knee) - 6 weeks

Not sure what the go is with Cameron Johnston who hasn't played yet at Casey. I thought he was cleared to play.

Edited April 20, 201114 yr by High Tower
Scully is 6 weeks

We've had an unreal run with injuries so far this year. Four matches and not one in a game seriously enough to miss weeks.

We've had an unreal run with injuries so far this year. Four matches and not one in a game seriously enough to miss weeks.

Ssshhh!!!!!!!!!!!!

Would the ultimate irony be a player injuring themselves in some obscure manner this weekend?

Surely McKenzie will need a few rounds at casey for his fitness.. But who makes way upon his return?

Its even going to be tougher once Suclly is 110% fit.

Ssshhh!!!!!!!!!!!!

Agree- don't moss us.

Looks like Scully has been rolled back to 6 weeks again. I think we can consider it as 'indefinite' injury now and the club is probably of the same view but maybe doesn't want to start a media fire by officially calling it so

Edited April 19, 201114 yr by Ascobar

Looks like Scully has been rolled back to 6 weeks again. I think we can consider it as 'indefinate' injury now and the club is probably of the same view but maybe doesn't want to start a media fire by officially calling it so

I'd rather call it 'indefinite', or even still, I'd prefer to call it a '6 week injury.'

Just because it has been pushed back does not mean it is indefinite.

I'd rather call it 'indefinite', or even still, I'd prefer to call it a '6 week injury.'

Just because it has been pushed back does not mean it is indefinite.

Correct weight and even C.C stated he maybe back earlier.

Scully is '426' and be done with it

Correct weight and even C.C stated he maybe back earlier.

Thats exactly my point - due to the rare nature of the injury the recovery time is unknown thus indefinite as defined here

Did Jack Fitzpatrick play for the Casey magoos this week? Didnt see him mentioned in the goals or best,and cbf looking up the selected teams from the paper..

Shame that we all really have no inkling on where Scully is at - it seems very mysterious.

6 weeks went to 3 weeks, then back to 6 weeks, to 5 weeks, back to 6 weeks :/

Go figure.

Apart from that, injuries (or lack there of) have been very good to us (TOUCH WOOD!!).

Looking forward to Jordie making his return.

Did Jack Fitzpatrick play for the Casey magoos this week? Didnt see him mentioned in the goals or best,and cbf looking up the selected teams from the paper..

Yep, "Jack Fitzpatrick: Jack only had eight possessions in an OK performance."

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/7415/newsid/111991/default.aspx

Just said this today... we'll get through to the end of week 5 with not a single match-day injury, off the top of my head. I think there was a Davey ankle, and maybe a Garland knee left on the park at some stage in that time, but they went back and found them the following week.

And don't worry. Everything that's not typing is touching wood...

No change yet to the injury list.

Still showing last weeks details.

I doubt much has changed.

All three look long term to me.

No official injury list this week but if you read the match preview on afl.com.au you will notice the injury list and the confusion continues:

Match Preview - West Coast v Melbourne

Injury list 

Melbourne: Robert Campbell (achilles) - 5 weeks, Jordie McKenzie (groin) - 4 weeks, Tom Scully (knee) - 6 weeks

"Melbourne Injury List

Tom Scully (knee) – 5 weeks

Jordie McKenzie (groin) – 2 weeks

Robert Campbell (achilles) – 3 weeks

Updated April 27"

As taken from http://dreamteamtalk.com/2011/04/27/injury-list-ahead-of-round-6/

Not sure what their source is, but good to see scully down to 5 and Jordie only 2 away!

Edited April 27, 201114 yr by Jastone

Surely McKenzie will need a few rounds at casey for his fitness.. But who makes way upon his return?

Its even going to be tougher once Suclly is 110% fit.

We don't want him 110% Fit,,, thats his problem, too much carpet burn! B)