Most FF don't rack up disposals like midfielders.

In Hale's case that includes goals.

what makes me hopeful is the quotes coming from Prendergast indicate we are not desperate for any player. Desperation is what will lead us to being ripped off.

If we get Hale for a fair price... great. If we miss out bc some other club offers something we can't match... that's ok too. We do have an All Australian ruckman, and a forward line consisting of Watts, Jurrah, Pettard, Green, Wona and Sylvia... we'll survive without Hale very easily.

If we give more than pick 32 i'd be dissapointed

^^^ Here here

So one comment from that hack Hutchinson puts everyone here into 17 pages of lather? And we all cast aspersions on the competence of the FD?

So one comment from that hack Hutchinson puts everyone here into 17 pages of lather? And we all cast aspersions on the competence of the FD?

well.... it is the off season !! lol I dont hink many necessarily take Hutchy's comment as gospel but look upon it as a point for starting comparisons of worth etc.

I would tend to feel with the recent efforts of the FD in mind these past years that many are more than assured the FD will do its utmost to secure a fair deal for a player it regards as more than handy to us going forward.

Hale's going to be a role player not a world-beater and our trade offer is valued at this. A picks in the early 30s is hardly premium. If we add a 1st round swap it'll be because BP thinks this draft is very even through that area and we're likely to still get a player we want. Posters are carrying on like we're giving away 2 first rounders.

We've got a dozen recently drafted young players who have hardly played and currently aren't in my best 22:

Gysberts, Maric, Cheney, McNamara, Tapscott, Gawn, Jetta, Spencer, Bail, Blease, Strauss, Fitzpatrick

So one comment from that hack Hutchinson puts everyone here into 17 pages of lather? And we all cast aspersions on the competence of the FD?

Where does this idea that a discussion on the merits of recruiting David Hale translates to a lack of faith in the football department come from?

We're merely talking about what our observations of the player are, whether he's suitable for a Demon team about to move back into the top eight and what we think he's worth. I don't think anyone has said "I know better than the people in charge."

Personally, I enjoy reading multiple opinions based on multiple perspectives. Yes, some people are frothing at their virtual mouth, but I think it's mostly been 17 pages of pretty good debate rather than "lather".

I guess the other alternative is to close down football forums entirely because "the club knows what they're doing" mandatorily trumps every single other opinion.

Edited October 6, 201015 yr by The Albino Warrior

Where does this idea that a discussion on the merits of recruiting David Hale translates to a lack of faith in the football department come from?

We're merely talking about what our observations of the player are, whether he's suitable for a Demon team about to move back into the top eight and what we think he's worth. I don't think anyone has said "I know better than the people in charge."

Personally, I enjoy reading multiple opinions based on multiple perspectives. Yes, some people are frothing at their virtual mouth, but I think it's mostly been 17 pages of pretty good debate rather than "lather".

I guess the other alternative is to close down football forums entirely because "the club knows what they're doing" mandatorily trumps every single other opinion.

What self-righteous indulgence!

I'm neck deep in this thread but lather it has been and plenty of posters have made a statement similar to: 'if the FD made this deal, they're mad!'

That is 'casting aspersions.'

And we can have our forums, but we also have to put up with other posters coming on and saying 'you're all a bunch of wankers.'

If you don't like comment on your comments - get a blog and disable the comments.

What self-righteous indulgence!

I'm neck deep in this thread but lather it has been and plenty of posters have made a statement similar to: 'if the FD made this deal, they're mad!'

That is 'casting aspersions.'

And we can have our forums, but we also have to put up with other posters coming on and saying 'you're all a bunch of wankers.'

If you don't like comment on your comments - get a blog and disable the comments.

What? Self-righteous? Have you got a good handle on the definition of that word? I just said I prefer more perspectives, not less.

The vast majority of posts have tooed and froed about what Hale offers, what he might be worth and whether he's worth having at the Demons. Very very few have talked about the FD as incompetent, and several have praised how they've performed in the last few years.

What self-righteous indulgence!

I'm neck deep in this thread but lather it has been and plenty of posters have made a statement similar to: 'if the FD made this deal, they're mad!'

That is 'casting aspersions.'

And we can have our forums, but we also have to put up with other posters coming on and saying 'you're all a bunch of wankers.'

If you don't like comment on your comments - get a blog and disable the comments.

Mate , no more indulgent than yourself either . We all "indulge" we are all opionated otherwise we'd sit back and say nothing and this forum wouldn't function nor indeed exist !

Now ... back to the star of this show, Hale. It's been mentioned here and there the clubs been interested for a while, indeed possibly even 3rd party fishing expeditions may have taken place. Was it his bag against us that raised an eyebrow or have we (mfc) had a passing interest far longer, possibly since early murmurings of Arden discontent surfaced . I seem to recall some posters mentioned him this time last year. Is this some sort of slow cooker deal?

I guess the other alternative is to close down football forums entirely because "the club knows what they're doing" mandatorily trumps every single other opinion.

This is the line I don't like.

No-one is saying that you cannot comment on the actions of the FD, but to put this line above in when someone comments on your comments is infuriating.

And it is self-righteous.

I should know...

According to Twitter, "NM holding out for second round pick for Hale. Demons more likely to provide it, Hawthorn with priorities elsewhere."

I'm sure it's boredom and footy withdrawals, but seriously, 17 pages on D. Hale? Never has so much been said about a possible trade since C. Moneybags Judd.

And to whoever compared this to the St Kilda trade of last year, please!

Ball was an experienced player and a key midfielder, and last year's draft wasn't getting the shite kicked out of it by Gold Coast. We're looking at trading draft places, when our list is already full of first round starts in the making. And maybe we'll trade a fringe player, but we won't be losing key members of our starting 18, and we won't be trading in bad characters who'll end up on rape charges (you'd hope).

Our club has done little wrong in the last three years. Don't see why they'd start screwing up now.

P.S.- Leigh Brown was very important to Collingwood this year, and he sucks a hell of a lot more than Hale probably could/will.

Fair obsrvation. I tend to agree with all of it.

Thats not what the people IMO, are concerned about. Did Adelaide give their 1st Rnd pick for Tambling?

No, they gave up their Bock compensation pick (end of first round) AND a third rounder.

Edited October 6, 201015 yr by Deemolition

What, as the new forward coach, to coach Hale, I presume'. At least Meeson collected footy's & coached the kids, what will Hale be good for,,, calling Cabs after functions.

Or doing rain dances over Summer.

You make me laugh mate-- possibly true.Just hope we don't give up any change to our first draft pick for him- if we do we are very stupid.

All this self indulgent twaddle and hypocrisy.

I'm sick of it.

Anyone else who has had enough, come join me on the thread I'm about to start -

E25's top 10 posts of 2010.

(this one comes in at number 10!)

All this self indulgent twaddle and hypocrisy.

I'm sick of it.

Anyone else who has had enough, come join me on the thread I'm about to start -

E25's top 10 posts of 2010.

(this one comes in at number 10!)

Well go and twiddle your fingers pal- or leave if you can't cope.

According to Twitter, "NM holding out for second round pick for Hale. Demons more likely to provide it, Hawthorn with priorities elsewhere."

*cough*

(for anyone who has had the misfortune of witnessing Sam Newman's chagrin-inducing attempts at forming an new catchphrase...)

Oh... Really?

This is the line I don't like.

No-one is saying that you cannot comment on the actions of the FD, but to put this line above in when someone comments on your comments is infuriating.

And it is self-righteous.

I should know...

My post wasn't about someone commenting on my comment. (I enjoy it when my opinion gets questioned.) It was about the general idea that robust discussion equates to some kind of anti-FD sentiment.

I don't think we're in a lather at all. We're really interested in how Melbourne intends to complement its list and David Hale is clearly their number one target at the moment. I'm not surprised the thread has reached 17 pages and I'm not sure it's been particularly difficult to pass over the sillier posts and get straight back to the considered, intelligent ones. There've been heaps.

Well go and twiddle your fingers pal- or leave if you can't cope.

And you're the cherry on top johnny boy!

Oblivious... :) you make me want to use emoticons

This is the line I don't like.

No-one is saying that you cannot comment on the actions of the FD, but to put this line above in when someone comments on your comments is infuriating.

And it is self-righteous.

I should know...

I fear that may be over the heads of quite a few.

Nicely done as usual.

What self-righteous indulgence!

I'm neck deep in this thread but lather it has been and plenty of posters have made a statement similar to: 'if the FD made this deal, they're mad!'

That is 'casting aspersions.'

And we can have our forums, but we also have to put up with other posters coming on and saying 'you're all a bunch of wankers.'

If you don't like comment on your comments - get a blog and disable the comments.

What a strange response to AW's post rpfc

Did you get out of bed on the wrong side this morning?

Not even worth debating

So one comment from that hack Hutchinson puts everyone here into 17 pages of lather? And we all cast aspersions on the competence of the FD?

I don't think you get it.

We do trust the FD. But I'd say, that many of the membership have sent a loud message to the FD, that we do not want to overspend on this 'player'.

I think the club has heard that message, & I'm sure they are just a tiny bit more cautious now.

Lets hope we can do it our way.

The whole can be greater than the sum of the parts. With Hale it's not just his raw football output - it's what he offers to the team - Jamar in the ruck and going forward, less defensive pressure on Watts and Jurrah, creation of crumbing goals, a target for midfielders under pressure. Kosi cops a lot of flak but clearly the Saints FD rate him - they just offered him a new 2 yaer deal - they kick a lot of crumbing goals and Riewoldt spends a lot of time in and out of the forward 50 - Kosi adds a lot of structural intangibles to their set-up.

I think the club has heard that message, & I'm sure they are just a tiny bit more cautious now.

Lets hope we can do it our way.

You must be joking ... surely.

I don't think you get it.

We do trust the FD. But I'd say, that many of the membership have sent a loud message to the FD, that we do not want to overspend on this 'player'.

I think the club has heard that message, & I'm sure they are just a tiny bit more cautious now.

Lets hope we can do it our way.

Wow. Really?

Now we're delving into self-indulgent fantasies.