Demonland Player of the Year - Round 20

[dee-luded 2,959]

6 - Davey

5 - Bate

4 - Jones

3 - Jurrah

2 - Valenti

1 - McDonald

[Lord Travis 10,763]

6. Davey - Very Very good game. One of the most complete games he's played yet. He showed skill, dash, leadership, smarts, it was just a perfect display of what he will hopefully be able to keep up consistently for the next few years

5. Bate - Was really strong today, and brought his teammates into the game well

4. Jones - One of the best games I've seen him play. His kicking was alot better today, and his backing himself to break the lines paid off today

3. Rivers - Was the Rivers of old today, chopping off incoming passes and generally outsmarting his opponents

2. Morton - Was really solid down back again. Maybe he will develop into a mobile rebounding CHB in the Nathan Bock mould? Who knows at this stage! He is really starting to shine, and can be played in so many different positions. He's probably got the most potential of anyone on our list, and it shows. He'll be a star for us!

1. Valenti - He is a terrier. He ha a great hunger for the contest and doesnt let his size worry him at all. Good game by him today and he deserves a spot on a senior list, whether it's ours or not.

Apologies to Dunn, Moloney, Mclean, McDonald, and pretty much everyone else in the team.

Edited August 16, 2009 by Lord Travis

[45HG 1,559]

I also think Frawley deserves credit for a solid win.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,088]

2. Morton - Was really solid down back again. Maybe he will develop into a mobile rebounding CHB in the Nathan Bock mould? Who knows at this stage! He is really starting to shine, and can be played in so many different positions. He's probably got the most potential of anyone on our list, and it shows. He'll be a star for us!

Didn't see the game, so I can't give votes but i'd like to comment on this. I see Morton being played as a wandering wing type player. He's shown us that he is a very good defender, he popped up in the forward 50 a few weeks ago and kicked three, and with his engine he could keep running up and down the field all day. Imagine the match-up problem he would present. Do you tell one of your tall defenders to try to stay with him because they can match his size, or do you give the job to a smaller running player who might be able to keep up but could never out mark him. Very much the role that Richo was playing last year when they moved him out of the forward 50 and almost won him a brownlow.

[Doggo 32]

Morton took a couple of great marks deep in defence today, and showed real courage for such a skinny kid. Earlier in the year he was rightly criticized for squibbing a couple of marking contests. Today his courage in running back with the flight was unquestionable. He literally can play anywhere, and i can''t wait until his body fills out to allow him to fill a key post. He's going to be very dangerous!

[RalphiusMaximus 6,088]

Morton took a couple of great marks deep in defence today, and showed real courage for such a skinny kid. Earlier in the year he was rightly criticized for squibbing a couple of marking contests. Today his courage in running back with the flight was unquestionable. He literally can play anywhere, and i can''t wait until his body fills out to allow him to fill a key post. He's going to be very dangerous!

A Richo/Goodes hybrid. :D

[Wadda We Sing 10,685]

6. Davey.....unreal sublime accuracy

5. Valenti

4. Jones

3. Morton

2. Rivers

1. Jurrah

[Jaded No More 68,974]

2. Morton - Was really solid down back again. Maybe he will develop into a mobile rebounding CHB in the Nathan Bock mould? Who knows at this stage! He is really starting to shine, and can be played in so many different positions. He's probably got the most potential of anyone on our list, and it shows. He'll be a star for us!

I'd love to see him play as a key forward.

Super impressive marking from Cale "Kate Moss" Morton today. He has strong hands, even if I could snap them in half.

He is such an incredibly smart player, that even in some contests where I thought "he can't physically win this one", he ended up outsmarting his opponent and taking possession. Will be an absolute gun!

[Akum 2,660]

So good to see some of the less appreciated players such as Valenti, Bate & Dunn hitting their straps. All will be valuable to us in future, and there's no way we'll let Valenti go.

[cooko 124]

6 Davey

5 Bate

4 McLean

3 Jurrah

2 Morton

1 Rivers

[Demon Tragic 0]

6. Davey

5. Frawley

4. Bate

3. McLean

2. Jones

1. Jurrah

[Pipefitter 2,168]

6 - Davey

5 - Mclean

4 - Mcdonald

3 - Jones

2 - Jurrah

1 - Moloney

[At Least I Saw a Flag 5,274]

Is it just me, or does Jonesy repeatedly make skill errors? He gets the ball really well, but doesn't do himself (or his teammates) with his disposal or tendency to hang onto the ball til he gets caught. My 11 y.o. daughter made the observation that he always make mistakes.

I though Davey was clearly BOG. Bater and Jurrah also good.

Also worried about McLean. Very slow. And when he goes to ground, takes ages to get up and get back in the game.

MacDonald was also ok, but i think he should call it a day at the end of the season.

Robbo, great guy and was a great player, but he too should call it a day. He doesn't look fit.

Frawley was good, Morton OK, Petterd will be a player, Dunn will keep his place and even PJ was ok yesterday.

[Craig Drinker 179]

6. Davey

5. Bate

4. Mclean

3. Rivers

2. Moloney

1. McDonald

[Guest]

6. Davey

5. Bate

4. Jurrah

3. Valenti

2. Rivers

1. MAcDonald

[45HG 1,559]

Brock Mclean having 4-5 bounces in one passage of play, priceless.

[Doggo 32]

Brock Mclean having 4-5 bounces in one passage of play, priceless.

I remember that, someone near me yelled out "BROCKIE... WITH PACE!"... LOL

He was doing the treadmill, but no-one went near him, so he kept going.

[Jaded No More 68,974]

Is it just me, or does Jonesy repeatedly make skill errors?

It's not just you, but to his credit his kicking the last two weeks has seen a real improvement.

He is finally lowering his eyes and hitting guys with slicing passes straight on the chest. Very pleasing to see, and could be the result of playing under less pressure than normal, but at least we know he is capable of such disposal quality.

I remember that, someone near me yelled out "BROCKIE... WITH PACE!"... LOL

He was doing the treadmill, but no-one went near him, so he kept going.

Not to harp on about the fitness thing again, but he seemed a lot better for the two weeks rest. He was refreshed and bouncing around with a lot more power in the legs.

Then some Freo toolbag dropped him in the tackle and slammed him into the ground (where the hell was the free? ) and he was limping a bit afterwards. I guess it's not a good Brocky game if there is no injury involved (yesterday there was blood too, so a complete game from him :D)

[Demonland 73,140]

Well, itooks like it's over ... Aaron Davey polled 35.719 (record for a game under the weighted system) and now has an enormous lead over Brent Moloney:-

144.055 Aaron Davey

90.172 Brent Moloney

71.561 Brock McLean

68.665 Cale Morton

61.028 Nathan Jones

60.559 Cameron Bruce

53.732 Jack Grimes

47.014 Colin Sylvia

46.415 Ricky Petterd

39.609 James Frawley

37.985 Brad Green

36.065 Jared Rivers

34.144 Matthew Bate

33.646 Matthew Warnock

31.414 Mark Jamar

24.467 James McDonald

20.529 Liam Jurrah

19.408 Brad Miller

17.363 Shane Valenti

14.404 Paul Johnson

11.207 Stefan Martin

10.053 Kyle Cheney

9.952 Addam Maric

8.827 Jamie Bennell

8.015 Clint Bartram

6.535 Neville Jetta

6.126 Russell Robertson

2.742 Lynden Dunn

1.488 Tom McNamara

0.613 John Meesen

[45HG 1,559]

I don't like the weighted system.

[H_T 3,049]

I don't like the weighted system.

I agree. You could have played 5 decent games in losses and had an average game in a win. Yet some player who had been average in those losses all of the sudden plays a blinder in a big win and yet scores more points overall.

[titan_uranus 25,043]

I'm wondering whether we scrap the weighting system, and replace it with a different one next year. For example, you could take votes the same way as we currently do (5-4-3-2-1), still pick 3 sets of votes randomly, then add up each player's votes from each person and divide by 3. Keeps the votes tighter so that one player doesn't balloon out like Davey did this week as a result of a massive win. Anyone else think that's any good?