Testing time for Demons?

[alpha33 277]

All four short term injuries are being tested this week. Should we play them or give them an extra week to recover?

Short term -

Kyle Cheney (hand) - test

Brad Green (hamstring) - test

Paul Wheatley (calf) - test

Austin Wonaeamirri (general soreness) - test

Out for the rest of the season -

Brock McLean (ankle)

Brent Moloney (shoulder)

David Neitz (neck, retired)

Jared Rivers (abdominals/groin)

Russell Robertson (Achilles)

[Redleg 38,024]

All three short term injuries are being tested this week. Should we play them or give them an extra week to recover?

Short term -

Kyle Cheney (hand) - test

Brad Green (hamstring) - test

Paul Wheatley (calf) - test

Austin Wonaeamirri (general soreness) - test

Out for the rest of the season -

Brock McLean (ankle)

Brent Moloney (shoulder)

David Neitz (neck, retired)

Jared Rivers (abdominals/groin)

Russell Robertson (Achilles)

Rest.

We should now play Weetra and Meesen for the rest of the year and give White, Yze and Holland the last game if they are not in the side by then.

That is proper list management. We should find out if these guys can play!

Injured senior players should now be rested and get right for next pre season.

[tooly 0]

Rest.

We should now play Weetra and Meesen for the rest of the year and give White, Yze and Holland the last game if they are not in the side by then.

That is proper list management. We should find out if these guys can play!

Injured senior players should now be rested and get right for next pre season.

We know Weetra can't play

[dees_rule_4eva 22]

We know Weetra can't play

Give the kid a break.

All four will play this weekend, albeit not with Melbourne. Cheney will be back for the Sandy reserves, and all of Green, Wheats and Wonna will play against the Dons.

[Rogue 585]

If fit, all should play, with Cheney at Sandy and the rest for the MFC.

We should now play Weetra and Meesen for the rest of the year and give White, Yze and Holland the last game if they are not in the side by then.

That is proper list management. We should find out if these guys can play!

No thanks. If they can't play at Sandy (or Sandy reserves), tell me again why we need to play them at AFL level to see what they've got.

Meesen is contracted for next year, so he can get a run then if you need to see a player at the top level. His form doesn't warrant leap-frogging Jamar, PJ, and White.

Weetra had a run in the NAB Cup and also got a couple of games, didn't do well, and has languished in the Sandy reserves for much of what's been an inconsistent season, even at that level.

[H_T 2,941]

Weetra had a run in the NAB Cup and also got a couple of games, didn't do well, and has languished in the Sandy reserves for much of what's been an inconsistent season, even at that level.

Yes, Weetra didn't do much at all, he's goose is cooked.

[Freddy Fuschia 666]

Brad Miller is out this week with a hamstring injury which was not reported earlier in the week. Ricky Petterd is not in the Sandringham team to play at the weekend. Last week itwas the same thing with Wheatley who was out with a calf injury that wasn't disclosed in the week's injury list. Presumably, these players' injuries happened after the list was issued but this has become such a commonplace occurrence that I'm starting to wonder about our fitness and training set up at the club.

This is one of the first areas the club should review IMO.

[titan_uranus 22,743]

So how long is Miller out for? 1 week? More?

[H_T 2,941]

So how long is Miller out for? 1 week? More?

If its a hammy, it would be more than one.