6. Colin Garland

5. Brock McLean

4. Cameron Bruce

3. Paul Wheatley

2. Brad Green

1. A Lottery... Brad Miller.

6. Colin Garland

5. Brock McLean

4. Cameron Bruce

3. Paul Wheatley

2. Brad Green

1. A Lottery... Brad Miller.

6 - Wheatley

5 - Garland

4 - McLean

3 - Green

2 - Bruce

1 - P . Johnson

6. Colin Garland

5. Brock McLean

4. Cameron Bruce

3. Paul Wheatley

2. Brad Green

1. A Lottery.. Brad Miller

Here are mine, I agree wholeheartedly.

6. Colin Garland

5. Brock McLean

4. Cameron Bruce

3. Brad Green

2. Paul Wheatley

1. A Lottery...Adem Yze

6- Garland

5 - McLean

4 - Wheatley

3 - Bruce

2 - Green

1 - Miller

Garland is a freak!!!

6. Brock McLean

5. Colin Garland

4. Paul Wheatley

3. Cam Bruce

2. Brad Miller

1. Brad Green

6 - GARLAND

5 - GARLAND

4 - GARLAND

3 - GARLAND

2 - GARLAND

1 - GARLAND

6 - Colin Garland

5 - Brock Mclean

4 - Cameron Bruce

3 - Paul Wheatley

2 - Brad Green

1 - Brad Miller

6 Mclean

5 Garland

4 Green

3 Bruce

2 Wheatley

1 bit of a lottery, Bate ,White, Yze was good, have to go with Miller

6- McLean

5- Garland

4- Bruce

3- Wheatley

2- Green

1- Miller

Thought that Sylvia was important in getting us back in it in the 3rd.

6- McLean

5- Garland

4- Bruce

3- Wheatley

2- Green

1- Miller

Thought that Sylvia was important in getting us back in it in the 3rd.

Yes, Sylvia was great in the 3rd.

By the way Id like to change my votes and give Garland a 7. 6 just isnt enough.

6. Sylvia

5. White

4. Morton

3. C. Johnson

2. Jr.

1. Neitz

6 - Garland

5 - McLean

4 - Bruce

3 - Bate

2 - Green

1 - Miller

I'm deducting votes from the idiot Melbourne supporter who started hurling fairly nasty abuse at an older Melbourne supporter whilst sipping on his can of Jim Beam and standing in the 'no standing' area in the last quarter.

6 McLean

5 Garland

4 Miller

3 Wheatley

2 Green

1 Bruce

Can anyone explain to me how Jeff White gets in the best players for Melbourne in the official stats?

Thought that Sylvia was important in getting us back in it in the 3rd.

I only saw the last quarter, so I can't comment on the whole game but there was one passage of play in the last with Sylvia that really worried me.

McLean had the ball in the back pocket/flank kick it up to someone (can't remember who) then got the ball again and kept running eventually until there was a ball up at around Melbourne's CHF.

That whole time, while Brock was running his guts out you could see Sylvia (this in on TV mind you) just jogging up following the ball but not getting in to lend a hand. It was lazy pure and simple.

Like I said, he may have starred for the rest of the game but that really worried me.

I only saw the last quarter, so I can't comment on the whole game but there was one passage of play in the last with Sylvia that really worried me.

McLean had the ball in the back pocket/flank kick it up to someone (can't remember who) then got the ball again and kept running eventually until there was a ball up at around Melbourne's CHF.

That whole time, while Brock was running his guts out you could see Sylvia (this in on TV mind you) just jogging up following the ball but not getting in to lend a hand. It was lazy pure and simple.

Like I said, he may have starred for the rest of the game but that really worried me.

He didn't star by any stretch. Was useful in our comeback, but really didn't have an influence on the game. Needs to really stamp himself in this second half of the year. Like I said, he was very good in that third qtr - but he needs to do it every week. Should look at Brock for an example.

My votes:

6 - McLean

5 - Garland

4 - Bruce

3 - Green

2 - Miller

1 - Wheatley

My real votes

6 - Colin Garland

5 - Brock McLean

4 - Brad Green

3 - That bloke that wears 32

2 - Paul Wheatley

1 - Brad Miller

Can anyone explain to me how Jeff White gets in the best players for Melbourne in the official stats?

God only knows. He was shocking!

6- McLean

5- Garland

4- Green

3- Bruce

2- Wheatley

1- Miller

My real votes

6 - Colin Garland

5 - Brock McLean

4 - Brad Green

3 - That bloke that wears 32

2 - Paul Wheatley

1 - Brad Miller

**falls off chair**

Y_M, I'm happy that you are not quite as deranged as I thought. Takes guts to write that up there. Kudos.

God only knows. He was shocking!

6- McLean

5- Garland

4- Green

3- Bruce

2- Wheatley

1- Miller

Have to agree on all!

6 - Colin Garland

5 - Brock McLean

4 - Brad Green

3 - Cam Bruce

2 - Brad Miller

1 - Bate

The weighted figure is 0.8103. I'll be back tomorrow with the updated leader board.

My real votes

6 - Colin Garland

5 - Brock McLean

4 - Brad Green

3 - That bloke that wears 32

2 - Paul Wheatley

1 - Brad Miller

wow. mucho respecto for giving credit where credit is due. (ive had a mexican themed weekend).

on another note, im not sure about wheatley...he got a lot of it, but didnt really use it. i thought pj and cj were pretty good.

brock gets a lot of it, but his opponent was tuck who i thought was arguably best on today...

brock gets a lot of it, but his opponent was tuck who i thought was arguably best on today...

Wonder if Richmond supporters think that Tuck was good, except he let McLean run wild...?

At the end of the day McLean is not a tagger, and his main role is not to stop his direct opponent. Of course he has to chase and man-up when the ball is going the other way (which he does, and he lays as many tackles as anyone), but if you play him on a damaging player, expect both players to get the ball equally.

It's a case of, would you rather the opposition tag McLean out of the game, or would you rather let McLean and his direct opponent do as they please?