Bombay Airconditioning

Yes, JKH. You're right he was poor. The names you've thrown up Michie/Newton/Riley all deserve another crack. We've got 8-9 games left?? I'd like Roos to try and get game time into those guys. Maybe say well play Michie/Riley/Newton for 4 games regardless of form, giving Stretch/ANB/JKH a rest then swap them back for the last couple. Maybe keep Stretch and rotate the others. Something along those lines.

His kicking needs some work.

Yes he did but he attacked the game all be it turned it over a lot. We're not playing finals and have an easy draw, I'd like to see him get a run of games. Others have had their chances. He manages to find himself in space with the ball. Needs to work on awareness and disposal. Has potential.

Purely speculation but let's be honest, - ex captain - senior player Plenty of opportunities for him to have played this year and has been left out. I think the coaches have moved on.

I honestly don't think Grimes is coming back.

Which leaders will stand up?

Exactly, yes he's made some errors but he's taking the game on, something we we're need.

Merrett will try and rough up Hogan.

Due to our lack of realisation we need to turn up mentally every week.

The Hawks seem to do alright without a dominant ruckman.

More depth? On top of who? Our team today carriers a couple of passengers. The first three named is the BOG are Jamar who is 8 weeks of retirement and Grimes and McKenzie who both are not AFL standard. Last weeks loss to the Bombers along with the Hawks pantsing of Sydney shows we are still some time away.

By manipulate do you mean dubious tribunal decisions?

Agree, I think it's highly likely. If Hawks offer to the Cats he'd have to consider it.

Even if Mcgovern didn't go down(still might be back in time)I think the Hawks have them covered. I'm still thinking Hawks will land either Danger or Treloar.

4 peat anyone?

Hawks still to play Carlton twice. Eagles and Richmond will find out the hard way too.

If our team all stood in centre of the ground and were yold... If you can't dispose of the footy leave now. If all you bring is bringing the ball to ground leave now. If you can't play hard contested footy leave now. If you don't understand that you need to come ready to play every week leave now. How many would be left.

The only thing he's gotten right was how he handled the tragic passing of Phil Walsh.

Sucked in Suns.

If Hampton could actually kick the footy he'd be a player.

Rightly or wrongly Grimes is a former captain of the club. He is clearly not part of the list moving forward and doesn't fall under depth player as it seems our kids will be given games before he gets another look in. Would anyone trade for him, I think it's unlikely. Assuming his contract was front loaded are we better off coming to an agreement at years end. Let's be realistic, the top clubs are ruthless hence that's why they're on top.

Who should we have gone for?

After we beat Geelong he was the messiah again, after losing to the Bombers he's back to being a very naught boy.....

I took one multi with North dogs Eagles Hawks dockers Giants dees crows saints Combined odds of $147.93. Dogs and saints are big chances I think.

That number was also speculative....at best.