Jesse Christ

Don't know why North fans are outraged by this- no problems with it. If it was a marking attempt- in real time looks similar to the wellingham incident. How much did Wellingham recieve? More intent in this one for mine, as there wasn't an attempt to punch the ball. Yet Trengove gets 3 for a legal tackle. Will never let that one go, it's like our measuring stick

Cue the Trade Joel McDonald thread, right olisik?

I'm content with the 4 weeks and the spanner in the works it produces for the Blues. Looking forward to Judd's next party trick- some kind of anal-play. Probably.

No value- we either match the offer or he walks.. edit- to talldefence

Can we trade you?

Names on a list aren't depth. We trade out Jamar- we will have Martin as first ruck. Martin goes down we have NO rucks- because Clark is a forward, Gawn and Spencil aren't ready and may never be. This thread is up there with the Michael Newton thread for lols

Hird was a star, and he wasn't KPF or KPD..

Well if you're on your way to MFC headquarters with this thread Nasher fill your boots lol

You were just listening to Finey on SEN, weren't you Keep13Alive?

Every player can't "hit heights" though, you must have your run of the mill blue collar workers. Jordy Mac is blue chip in the gritty stuff. Judy Garland, like Rivers are versatile backman who can plug holes and on their day can be more than handy. And they have to stay because there is no one else to play their roles.

You have to have Jamar on that list is he is first ruck and an AA(how quickly ppl forget) who has just been re-signed for 3 years Garland has to stay, No Jordie Mac- are you having a laugh? Rivers is a general down back, he stays- Nicho is the closest thing to a running defender we have- he stays, and your omission of Jones is disgraceful. Not a huge list to b honest

So you're upset at injuries? Boo- broken bones Hisss- rolled ankles! Something must be done about these mortal players and their fallible bodies... I am being facetious, in case you were wondering.. Injuries happen. Get over it.

With pick 3 & 4 we would be morons not to trade first pick if GC or GWS bid- which I still think they will unless we do a deal with them. Forget the fact that he is F/S for a moment, how much does our midfield need a lead by example, extracting, bullocking, ready to go youngster. It's all poker.

Losing Jamar robbed us of Matin forward- who kicked 2 in the first half and it could have been a breakout forward game for him- so quite unfortunate there. Injury to Bennell lost us a rotation, a proppy Grimes, no Watts down back who could have been a handy foil- had things gone our way make no mistake- we would have won. The main difference was Pav, and Freo having a forward target. We had none. Clark in- a fit Jamar or even a Sellar inclusion and the game could have been ours. Our team still needs a small forward. This is one of our highest drafting priorities. I think Bennells time at the MFC is over. Petterd looking shaky. Nice return from Green, Sylvia slowly getting back into it- Grimes and Martin battled hard and I'm LOVING Tom Mcdonald. Not too much to cry about today. Well apart from the loss. Richmond lost to GC, so think how their supporters will be feeling LOL!

Ninethmond

Which is why I think he'll be offered only a one year contract at the end of year- as protection of sorts for the young draftees coming in- and if he has a good year next year then we can see where we're at. The tricky thing is that GC/GWS may offer him more than that- so Moloney might find himself in a Bruce situation; back yourself and stay, or leave for greener pastures. FWIW I think he will decide to stay. Whether that is the wise decision, only time will tell.

No it wont. He will be free to play out the rest of his days sniping like the dog he is, remain exalted by all media people, and will probably retire from playing into a nice cushy little special comments guy and be thrown up to our faces every weekend. That sniggering little laugh of his makes me want to break stuff. Hate this bloke.

[censored]. Viney is worth a high end draft pick to us- the fact that his "daddy" works with us and is a club legend is inconsequential, but an added bonus at the end of the day. I can't believe that some on here would actually begrudge using a high draft pick on this kid. We bemoan our lack of culture, yet drafting this kid well do a good deal to fix this- with his style of play and workrate. If we pass on him (which we wont- and if you believe we will you are kidding yourself) it is unlikely we will get him back- and then you can have a sook while the sure thing kills it in the midfield for GWS/GC, and we may end up with another NQR, or gutter rat that could abandon the ship. Wake the f up!

Whilst we're on the topic of SEN- absolutely LOVE Finey! He is passionate, witty, very funny, intelligent and takes crap from nobody. Great host and love his show on my late night drives

Stick me in a freezer and thaw me out round 1 2013 ffs

took a while but I'm back at the house of pain!

Yeah, they can give us Selwood

Carlton should be targetting Cloak and I think he should be their main target. I think we are in the box seat for Boak and we don't necessarilly have to please him- we have to please Port- which we can do. Beggars can't be choosers- he wants to return to Vic- we will provide that whilst compensating his former club nicely. Done deal

Outside runners/ inside mids- whatever we drafted, for whatever reason, none of them have really worked out, have they? Let's not make this a thread on past draft woes, keep it Boak centric. We should chase him, and I elieve we are in the box seat with our picks.

You're basing this on a NAB cup win? Have your eyes been closed all season? We will get pantsed. Again. Cheers