BAMF

I have to admit. I'm really excited to wait till 8:30 for GNF to tell us who the tall forward that we didn't get is. Well done to everyone involved for keeping it so under wraps that nobody in the media or even the clubs involved even spoke about it.

Oh god. He isn't smiling. Its Jesse Hogan all over again.

Of course! Don't tell us now. Tell us at 8:30 because it's going to make all the difference! If you tell me now I might spill the beans and then the deal is off! 😂

Outrageous to think they got draft assistance only a few years ago.

Terrible I'm Tasmanian. I want a team. We won't retain players though. Hobart is a great place to grow up. It's a great place to move to once you hit your 30s and are ready to settle down. A 20 year old who moves here? Not good.

We lost as soon as he decided to leave. Happy with the trade. We should move this thread back to the main board and change the title to 'Deathride Fremantle'

Bring back the Scattergun!

I hate myself for saying this a bit. We lack depth in tall forwards and outside midfielders. Let grab Bruce and Hunter if they are cheap and try and squeeze the most amount of talent we can. We are in the window. Let's go for it. I don't give a [censored] about his tattoos or hair (yeah, I rewatched Moneyball last night. Great film).

Don't worry about it. You're awesome. I enjoy your posts.

Good thing the Sun's got that draft assistance a few years ago.

Sorry. We also have pick 52 (Melb). Can't edit my post for some reason (I would fix the typo too if I could).

Are GWS likely to even use pick 50 though? I haven't worked out how many ins and outs they have had this off season but at a glance it looks like they will have a heap of high picks this year. They might ask for our future third simply to spread their haul over multiple years?

I dislike Cornes. I hate his clickbait style. It seems unlike him to say this though. I'm not saying he is correct, but I believe that he genuinely thinks its true.

How many games should we have given Bedford to have 'treated him well'?

Imagine the game day threads when we have Hunter and Shache.

Means nothing.

The Dees have given Port Adelaide picks 33, 43 and 53 in exchange for pick 27. "We have today been involved in a pick swap that sees us improve our hand in this year's draft," Melbourne list manager Tim Lamb told Melbourne Media. "We have been able to do so by bundling three selections, including two that we did not intend to use at the national draft this year. "It has always been our philosophy to try and improve our draft hand every year and we're pleased to be able to acquire selection No.27 through this trade."

We have the following Second round pick (West Coast) Forth round pick (Saints) Forth round pick (Melbourne)

This hasn't been the process for a few years now. If you want to upgrade a player from the rookie list you just have to have an open list spot. Therefore, the pick doesn't actually get used.

I agree with the bold. I guess what we disagree on is what is 'much'. Pick 58 isn't anything of value at all. It's possible that pick 58 wouldn't be used at all. We used pick 65 last year on Woewodin as the last pick in the draft. A pick in the 40s isn't much. I guess we will find out soon enough.

I'm coming round to this.

Probably. I think the club is ready for Sparrow and Jordon to cover for Harmes contribution. This combined with Brayshaw getting more midfield time will just push Harmes down the pecking order. Still holding out hope that we are letting these players go to get salary space for Bowes and pick 7 but haven't read much about this recently.

Harmes is contracted for another 2 years though. Maybe it's a Scottie Pippen situation where he signed a great long term deal at the time but it ended up being massive unders? I would love to know the reasons why he is exploring options.

Nah, he is worth more that that. As far as I am aware, we have offered him a contract. I presume a 2 year one. GWS are offering more money and more years. He isnt homesick. He has been targeted as a need by a rival interstate club. He isn't worth much but its more than 58.

I disagree. I think a developing ruck is needed on a list. It's just a shame that Filipovic, King, King and Bradke turned out to be nothing. Now we have had to resort to bringing in Majak Daw for 1.8 years and being in the unfortunate position we are now where we have one 30 year old ruckman on the list. Happy to simply disagree on this one. We picked up Spargo, Fritsch, Petty and Baker that year. The first 3 were exceptional. Baker has been disappointing but provided better list balance. Miers as another forward didn't make sense at the time. I'm not sure he would have even got that many games on our list during that time. This is a big part of it. The Cats list was in a totally different shape to ours during this time. The cats had no end to mature bodies and depth. They lacked young talent and top end picks. They had no options but to churn through the later picks. We haven't gone through all the players drafted during that period but I'm sure you have had a look and know that there were a hell of a lot of players the cats picked that didnt make it. We had the young talent. We lacked the depth and mature bodies. Hence we took punts on the more mature players like Marty Hore, Tim Smith, Mitch Brown and Harley Bennell. These picks were always more likely to get 10 - 15 games instead of 0 like many of the cats. This is the crux of where we disagree (not that we really disagree that much). I don't think its a big deal that we haven't developed any late picks. We have nailed the trades. We have nailed the first round. We have nailed the second round. This has been our MO for years. We nail these 3 points and then use late picks for project players or backup depth. Even with the gift of hindsight we can only really agree that the difference in choices between Jason Taylor and Stephen Wells in late picks is Jack Henry over Dion Johnstone/Filipovic and Brad Close over Harley Bennell (yeah Atkins, but even that is debatable). It's hardly worth bringing up in every thread. Now we have the mature bodies. Now we have some decent depth coming through. Maybe JT will focus on youth with those picks?