monoccular

I am sure we won't get any concessions for Smith, but certainly will for Angus

Well that is ludicrous and emphasises yet again the blatant hypocrisy of the AFL in their "head is sacrosanct" charade. And, isn't high contact (or in the back for that matter) in a ruck contest a free kick? I have certainly seen it paid.

So is this the starter post for the “Bowey traded” thread? 🤗 Let him go under the radar … do we care? And he wasn’t playing for the free when he was legged in front of goal but ignored by the maggot. If the dissent rule was interpreted as it was when first introduced there would have been at least four 50 meters against those whiners.

Cats fans are bloody spoiled - the only team (other than the NSW & QLD teams) who don’t have to share a home ground and get to always have 90+% of the crowd. And further their ground is not standard AFL shape which further enhances their home ground advantage.

Wells - do you mean a rest or a game at Casey? I thought that I read that McAdam had concussion. Please enlighten us, VFL Casey watchers.

CP5 has been heavily tagged especially when Oliver was out / below par, yet he was still very influential in the second half when the game was won. And who was his opponent and what did they do?

Is a ruckman kneeing a 7 foot opponent in the back of the head in a ruck contest "high contact"? No surprise that the umpire didn't award a free on the night, but is this reportable?

Paywalled. But even the title is truth enough

Maybe BBB was going to be genuinely rested this week - probably should have been last week. Perhaps Tony. But is it just a coincidence that Jefferson has appeared to have had one of his better games when BBB and Shack were not playing? And how much time did Fullerton play forward?

Is there any explanation and or concern regarding our poor conversion in 2nd and 3rd quarters - 2 goals 12 behinds from plenty more inside 50s? Was it a "one off" - a combined 5 goals 15 by half time and a goal free second quarter? Maybe just mutual pressure? * IF Bowey is deemed ready who goes out for him? I wonder if it would be Billings, maybe to sub, with Woey moving to share wing duties. Unused sub Laurie probably needs a full Casey game. And how good was Windsor's chase down tackle - and his conversion. He is having a far greater impact so early in his career than many could imagine or even dream of. Finally Harrison Petty seems to have found his mojo - his contested marking was the difference in the end. Looking forward, as always, to the insightful and positive analysis from you all. *addendum: Just checked Wheloratings - second quarter had the lowest pressure ratings for both teams …. so can we deduce that the zero goal quarter was NOT due to pressure. What other explanation?

6. Lever 5. Gawn 4. Petty 3. Langdon 2. Windsor 1. Oliver

It is hard to think of a better one. And just looking at the Frittata sealer, how much was that due to Petty's incredible closing and carefully judged spoil? Not recorded as a goal assist but it certainly was. Probably Harrison's best game - even despite his 6 goal haul v Tigers last year. His work up the ground was impressive and vital.

As I have said more than once before the VFL is an absolute dog’s dinner as a development / support / back up competition, and the stuffed suits at AFLHQ don’t give a rat’s [censored].

IF Bowey is really ready I would bring him in for Billings and play Woey on a wing / HF No other changes unless they think Laurie needs a full game at Casey.

That is high praise and will hopefully turn out to be spot on.

Welcome back Harry. Your contested marking tonight was first rate. So glad the selectors don’t decide according to the demo(n)cratic votes on this forum.

Pace +++ and that tackle ❤️💙 Cool head Usually a very good kick. Fantastic pick up.

Not just epic Daicos, but also epic Carlton defence, or non defence. And why shouldn’t they lose 3 on the trot. I see Colonwood have a freebie next week.

When #4💩 puts Cripps down and out for a week and actually gets suspended for a few months - then I will watch this game on replay.

And am I correct in saying that he also forced his own team mate Murphy into retirement?

Port 5 g 17 b in just short of a full game. Who has them as contenders?

Maybe Geelong could make him a short term Hawkins replacement ? Fits the age profile.

We all know who caused the retirements of Murphy and Gus - was said #4💩 anywhere near Rory's eye perchance?

They. already have a Tasmanian presence, and they have a coach who is said to support a Tasmanian presence. Nobody wants an uneven number of teams. Logic suggests that North relocate. Chook - AFL may well be heading for broke if the rumoured concussion class action succeeds.

Thanks Kev and all others including WCW Did I read it right that both Bowey and Melksham were in full training? Fabulous news if I am reading correctly. Would it mean that Bowey could be back this week or next, and Melk only a few weeks later presumably via a few at Casey