monoccular

Sub had been activated by then - already struggling and now an extra man down? you forget out Brayshaw, Smith and in FullArton plus FullArton

Yes depth isn’t as good as we may have thought. However Smith cannot be replaced and Brayshaw retired after draft day and is irreplaceable anyway. Jordon is the one we would have fought harder for or offered more had we known Gus wasn’t going to play. Hibberd retired and Dunstan was ordinary

I guess after todays debacle there will be posters here calling for his immediate elevation to the seniors 🙄

… and the apparently unwanted Fullarton and AMW To each his own. I enjoy the banter. …. and (sounding like a broken record) a forward forward coach.

Of course nobody compels you to listen to the podcast.

Could Austin Wonnameri even pull this one out of the fire?

Unless and until we find a forward coach with forward experience and forward nous we will not be true contenders. Enough is enough.

Mc Adam has done about as much as Fullarton this year. 🙄 No. An arm wrestle involves two competitors.

Yet i am sure the AFL get very angry when some people suggest that they may be a corrupt boys’ club. JD - same with me. 2023 is the first time in my memory (a baby boomer who remembers the glory days) that I have not watched (since the time all have been televised) or attended any PF or GF. I usually attend a few neutral games at the G, but haven’t even watched one on TV. Occasionally look at parts of replays especially when Geelong, or either CFC get done in a close or controversial finish. They, through their smug promotion and protection of their favourites, have lost me.

Amazing win that - but seriously don't even think about stressing my heart like that again.

Geelong and Carlton seem never to get a 50 paid against for dissent, and it is often quite demonstrative and abusive.

and he hasn't been suspended yet ....

By all reports (haven’t seen a Casey game this year) AMW is starting to knock the door down. Hope he gets a gig soon - he could be a risk of itchy feet if he doesn’t. Sadly Fullarton doesn’t seem to have been a worthwhile trade - if he cannot get a game as a forward / ruck back up when we right now are in dire need of both then surely he never will.

A disgraceful bunch of money hungry hypocrites is a far more apt description IMO.

A good solid thrashing would really be better for us all.

Surely he has a hell of a lot of growth both physically and mentally now he is in an elite AFL programme. Now he may or may not make the grade but he has the body and seems to have the drive and attitude. PS is he here yet?🤗

I thought on Sunday how dispiriting it must be to play in front of a cheer squad of maybe a dozen scattered fans. I am sure WCW would give him a warm welcome.

Swagger is something that he does seem to have already, like JVR, and unlike the Shack and the Weed.

Fond memories of #30 defending solidly and kicking down the line. These days he would get repeatedly pinged for “insufficient intent” by the magic mindreaders in fluoro - the old fashioned white maggots never did. Valé

I don't bet of follow odds, but I winder if there has been any change since news that (A) JVR is out and (B) 22 is umpiring. Stats gurus - do we have data on win / loss ratio when that biased #22 is umpiring our games compared to when he is not?

MT64 - they have already lost me. I used to watch multiple games each week on TV, and even attend "neutral" games at the G. No more. Occasionally I watch the end of a game especially if Geelong, Collingwood or Carlton are getting done, but otherwise it is only MFC. I love footy, but hate the AFL especially when they go on about integrity etc. PS - now 2235 Thursday night - didn't even realise that there was a game on tonight. That is how much I despise the organisation known as AFL. But who would educate them? PS - does Nathan Brown update the odds to them during the game??

IF he gets a run this season, barring another catastrophic run of injuries, I would be very pleasantly surprised. Casey has a developing ruck - Verrall but a competent back up would be handy. Good to hear - he could try out for MCC Cricket and Lacrosse teams, in his "spare time". And Cowboy Neale played when? The 1960s game was very different, almost unrecognisable, to 2024. "Trained" twice a week that is had a few kicks and ran a few laps before a few beers, and a smoke for some I certainly like his aggression and he seems to like laying heavy tackles too. I hope he can get to the required fitness level. 6 months seems odd, to resettle a player across the continent. Do we know if extension is an option without going to the draft?? As above, love his aggression and tackling - yes I know it is a highlight reel. Already ahead of Schache and possibly FullArton (though I have not seen him in action).

As of 2145 Wednesday there doesn't appear to be anything on our club's website, which if I am looking correctly is pretty poor.

Thanks for clarifying. IMVHO Schache and BBB will definitely leave, and as mentioned somewhere earlier despite Tommy's miraculous resurrection I suspect he may want to retire while in the ones and not the twos. Tomlinson, especially if Tom leaves, could well be offered a reprieve. Fullerton I guess will remain as this forum's bunny. If Luker Kentfield shows any development, Fullerton will go lower in the pecking order.

I agree. But what is the contract status of both Fullarton and Schache? I thought that they both had over a year to run, yet neither can get a game even in times of need.