Demon17

.. I wne tto the Sydney game and the team's performanace against Carlton for 3 1/4's was like a totoally different team was on the ground. Watts efferts in Sydney and agian against Carlton shows he IS coming along, and Neeld dropping him for a few weeks was just what he needed.,He does still make the 3rd decison instead of first, but that will come, and he is clearly being put into the middle of the action to imporve this. I was buoyed by what I saw to 3/4 time.

Agree. Also at the game in Sydney and he consitently opted for a second or third option rather than the quick first option, then gets caught. The younger players are trying their guts out and I apoloigse to Jack Watts, becasue althought he played in the backline (a smart move by the match committee) his possesion count, all of which were under pressuer was terrifc and was his best game in the circumstances.

I agree. Its really sad how the footy show - once mandatory vieiwng - is now just a cliche ridden sideshow for professional bogans like Crawford, Brayshaw and Brownless.. Don't get me started on Damian Barrett - has he ever told me somehting I didn't know!

Rome didn't exist in 1000BC - It was founded around 600BC by Romulus, although some historians belive the legend that Trojans escaping from that war founded it about 1100BC, I don't though

Agreed. It was Moloney and I was screaming to drag him as well. I loved Neelds immediate rsponse to a player who is still a prime mover. He won't do it again under Neeld and this should harden his resolve. Great coaching leadership.

I think we have definiteily seen the Neeld way last night. His decison to retain Tom McDonald after a shocker last week gives me great confidenece in his decision making and what he thinks the team needs. Proud of the re-build effort last night as was everyone else at the ground.

Success for any coach is first and foremost a function of the quaility of players and nothing else. This post assmues all lists are equal. Good players make good coaches - not the other way around.. As other posts have said recently, our list post-ND has been less than inspiring with a few excpetions. IMO the right people are at the helm now to get this sorted.

Thius is my highpoint of the season. We can build a forward line around him for the next 5 to 6 years. and a great coup by the club

Tell us something we DON'T know Aka. Terry Wallace said after the game the Dogs were at their worst since 1996 - he was being constructive. Doesn't say much about us but our upside is way better and our 3rd and 4th quarters showed the spirit, hopefully , we will turn around. The coaching panel will get the rest sorted in time. Go Demons

Our top 5 ball getters had 50 -ish % kicking efficiency yesterday, meaning we gave the ball back every second time we got it for this group. The heart and effort was great yesterday and the supporter turnout fantastic but this is killing us.

Tapscott was good last week and played a lot of game time. he would be ready to go, not a sub position.

Couch was great at casey last week, so maybe they are looking at him one more time. Morton was uninspiring and disposla was atrocious at Casey .

No. At the whole game today and he tagged Dolphins young ball magnet No.38. who was half his size to half time, playing off half-back.. Turned over a fair bit as well and some poor decisions. Unimpressive to say the least.

Bottom line is that Neale daniher and team left the list in basket case mode and no serious effort was made to recover apart from draft picks.since 2007. Neeld and his team now have the ability and skills to do this. IMO the right rein has been pulled and its now a time issue.

At the 20 minute mark of Q1 the tackle count was 15 to 5 our way and there was no way the Lions could get out of thier defensive 50. And we were 11 points up at the break. Small steps I know - but I saw this as a start and something I hadn't seen for a long time. They did this to the Pies in the NAB cup also.

Excellent post. I was at the game and I felt Neeld was speaking to ME and telling ME what I wanted to know and hear. Everyone else in the press can please themselves. The kerfuffle about the conference is just a sign that for once we get some honest emotion and thinking , not cliche-driven garbage the likes of Malthouse, Ratten and Co produced. As another poster said yesterday, don't look for Watts, Clark and Co as the answer. Neeld , Missen, Craig are the answer for us. The cattle will come and be developed. Some are already on board - MAGNER!

He came from Katandra - Goulburn Valley

A former Asst. Caoch at a top club(Read recent Premiers) told me the industry thinking is that good players make good coaches. I don't entirely agree as I think Neeld also brings something, but G is G is spot on and the future is bright if his list gets going. It won'y be the older ones - sadly. Trengove/Grimes appointment points to Neeld seeing the future this way as well and that this young group are up for it.

And in the Age article on North today the first 3 columns of the 6 column article were deveoted to the MFC timing. They will be fuming at the Roos. I work with a media expert and she says nothing happens by cooincidnece regarding announcements. Remember North were foolish enough to telegraph their announcement timing days ago. I would have been cross if the MFC had not done what they did with the leg up from the Roos.. Someone down here in media is a real pro. BTW - Trengove is the youngest at the time of his first game when he officially leads them onto the field , with Jack G., in late March.

If in doubt, see this mornings Age sports section

A great analysis Jaded. Its the same as 'great players don't necessarily make great coaches'. leadership is somehting special - Lyon, Viney, McDonald, Stynes, Barassi - Voss etc etc

Another great piece of work by the club with the Trengove/Grimes announcement timing trumping all other AFL announcements yesterday, getting great interviews, and coverage . Admittedly the age thing is a huge angle attractive to the media , but just a great positive story for the club - again so fay this year. Good job Cameron!

This isn't a democray nor a popularity conexst about hurting others feelings. Neeld has made the tough and correct choices here. Rivers will be a professional and suck it up. Guess what happens if he doesn't? I love the record angle with Trengove's age.

Couldn't have said it better. Same for Frawley although style of play is different.