old dee

It grieves me to say the following because i go on and on about winning is the only thing and anything less is only a loss. However after our performances over the last 18 months I will be happy with a low level loss. i.e. anything below 6 goals will prove to me that craig is improving the side and I will be happy.

Think you are better off in QLD bbIt will be 13 degrees and showers at the G Add a 10 goal loss. Enjoy warmer QLD mate

Heard anything on Clark Satyriconhome?

MFC web site/s only comment on Clark is Indefinate. This looks strange to me there has been nothing said now for some time. The longer this goes on the more worried I get . It does not look good to me. I already smell nothing more in 2013. 2014 ??????????????? So far a dozen games in two year not his fault but low value for money at present. Has anyone heard anything?

Gee Rusty I am not that old mate, My father was on the kokoda track does that count.Do not agree with the Bombers / bananas. Bananas only bring joy the bombers never do!

You know rusty that all stems from the WW2 were the Poms put out the story that they were superior to the Germans in fighter planes because they ate lots of carrots which improved their eye sight.The reality is was 99% crap and Propaganda. To get an advantage you needed to eat massive volume of carrots over a long period of time and even then the affect was marginal. Sound familiar? Bomber PR department!

Banana I expect!

Spot on. I now see a glimmer of hope where there was none .I would add that I was thinking on the way there why I was bothering going!

Chippy my view has been for some time that neither are really mid field players.IMO because of lack of mid fielders we have been trying to make both into something they are not. IMO Trengove is a forward who can venture to the wing and Grimes is a half back. If we play them in those positions we will get maximium results from them. Obviously mine is not the popular view but there you have it.

Seems like ancient history now WJ

Actually C & B I think we will struggle to get more than four wins in total.However I agree with you. This attitude of wanting extra picks has landed us exactly where we are at present. There is nothing I would like more than to win six games , perform well in the others and be not due any extra picks. We have got to get over this "we are so badly off we need help attitude"

Your anger is clouding your judgement on this one jr.Mclean is a good footballer who should be playing in the midfield for the Dees.

Tell the GCS they can have him for Omeara

Jazza It maybe they way you have put it but Gerard Whately is not an AFL person is he? I still think they will get off with little penalty

Cough Cook cough

They can have him for Murphy, fat chance!Sylvia cannot be traded Redleg he is a free agent.

I actually think we are in that game in Darwin if we can get a couple of players back in the next two weeks. Brisbane may have had our measure the last couple of years but they have only won two more games. Brisbane is IMO the test If we can beat them we have turned a corner and Craig will have proved he can get more from this team than Neeld. Love to be going to Darwin.

That makes it easy TD Sellar is the one that has shown a bit Davis cannot get a game and Gillies well do I need to say any more.

You don't want much rpfc should a cake walk

August is supposed to be the month when the Bombers result comes out. If that goes the way a lot on here think it will go any PP for the Dees will be lost in the S--- fight that will be on about Essendon. I fully expect that for a change the Dees will be of like news value in August.

I heard that same segment It is not the worst idea I have heard. The down side may be is Craig as marketable to the sponsors and members as a Roos. It seems to me that we not only need a very good coach we also need a high profile successful coach to sell the club.

Where is he going mjt? I am not aware of any other positions on offer at the moment. If my memory is correct the only jobs up are Us, Lions and Eagles No one can talk to Williams till the end of August and with the tigers likely to be in finals then early September. And after that who's says he is better than Eade or Craig?

Me too rpfc

I understand, I just cannot get out of my mind that we gave Pedersen three years. It would seem a tragedy to me if we kept Pedersen because he has two years contract left. All things being equal I would keep Sellar of that trio He has played some useful games, Davis cannot kick and they clearly don't consider he is good enough after 2.5 years on our list without one game.

You just did