praha

I have a feeling he will nominate 2 clubs, or 3 at the very most, and that Melbourne will be one of them. I agree that wearing number 3, new coach and MCG is attractive to him.

You have great contacts!

Pick 4, Robbo, CJ, Jeff White and Bruce. That's what would get Judd here, financially and by what WC would want.

CB and CJ won't cover Judd's contract. Trade rejected.

That still wouldn't cover the "cost". We'd need to throw in the pick, Robbo, someone like Davey or Sylvia and then a Dunn imo. WC wouldn't accept any less unless they get desperate.

I agree when you saying that Lyon may have influence in getting him to Melbourne (which won't happen). He seems to be the character that everyone loves. I'm sure many of you remember when Farmer almost left Melbourne to return to Perth and Lyon was apparently the main figure in getting him back. I have no doubt that had Lyon had more influence with Melbourne at the time of his depature he may not have even left (Farmer). In saying that, Judd won't be at Melbourne next year or ever, unless he makes it clear he only wants to play for us. I have a feeling the guy knows where his loyalty lies and it is killing him to say he wants to come home. I think it is possible he will come out and say he wants to play for us, and I don't think he would choose Carlton on Collingwood over us to be honest.

You live in Adelaide?????

I just got back from the Greek Islands and Ibiza. I have to say, as soon as they here an Australian or American accent, you're automatically hated. Plus, you have to look at the fact that these are three tall, well built men who probably had women all over them. I can't count on my fingers how many altercations I got into with Italians, Spaniad's and German's while I was over there.

I'd take McMahon and a 2nd round pick for Robertson in a flash. Make it happen!

We should pick up Paul Licura in the PSD when Collingwood de-list him. That'll up our toughness.....

My guess is you don't live in Melbourne????

You have to say that the last three REALLY dominant teams in one season over the past decade or so have been Carlton (95 - 2 losses), Essendon (2000 - 1 loss) and Geelong this year. Yeah, the Lions and Eagles dominated for a bit, but moreso in finals than in the finals. They were beatable, where as the three teams I just mentioned had been close to unbeatable throughout the season. My point? All three had exceptional backlines. No, I'll rephrase that. An OUTSTANDING backline.

Cheer Cheer the red and the white...

Haha good one! My dog seems to have more interest in AFL sometimes than he does.

Well I think we all know who would win that award :D

No one. The number should be retired. Just like 5 and should 2 should be as well.

Although I wouldnt mind seeing Geelong win, I think Eagles, Port and Sydney will all come good at the right time. I'll still put my money or the Eagles.

Really? I had spurs on my heels and I can tell you that I find it hard to believe he went the whole year playing with them, especially considering his position.

That receding hairline can't do him any favor's....

He probably writes more articles on Melbourne than on any other team...

The more past players you have at a club the better; it's the only way you're going to get unconditional passion for success and the club.

You'd never guess what I'm doing at uni

Viney isn't leaving Hawthorn anytime soon imo. Considering he has an ex-team mate at the helm of the club he probably has more on offer for him there and while I don't judge his passion for the MFC, he wanted to be here, he would be.

Sometimes he can write some really good stuff, but other times he writes just **** and blabbers on about the same stuff over and over again.

lol delusional