praha

Jones > Rivers > Bartram > everyone else. Bruce is in that "everyone else". He's a hack of the highest order. Hacks like yourself praise other hacks, just like Bruce. He is a "daniher" player and a typical one at that; soft, weak and a "give it to me" type player. When this team is where Hawthorn are now, 3-4 years down the track, successful and strong, Bruce will be one of the lower tier players, if that. Overrated. Always has been and always will be. Reminds me of Tracey McGradey in the NBA. Good when the team is going well, no where to be seen where they are travelling bad. Hack hack hack.

lol Put Jones in there. He did one ruck contest and won it to our advantage, one of a few we got today.

I can remember more brilliant games by Jones then brilliant games by Bruce. There aren't any that are brilliant every week. I was just making a point. Bruce has been insignifcant since mid-2006. You're saying he's a quality player. Justify that. My point is, if a player that hasn't been brilliant in over a season can be called a "quality player", what would you classify a player that has been great the past year or so.

Whites career after the first 4-5 years >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> PJ's career after the first 4-5 years. Right now though, yes, PJ > White. That's a disappointing/worrying turnaround.

I thought Newton did OK given the circumstances. He was soft, but so was the entire team. He's only played a few games. You're all putting crap on him as if he is a leader and seasoned veteran. He'll be a player. He can take a mark and kick a goal. That's all we need atm.

I'll be there for Macca. If they put in another insipid performance, god help us all.

Sorry for "Debated" lol And to think I'm a professional writing major. Anyway. By your logic, any player who plays a few brilliant games for is automatically clasified as a high quality player. What exactly would you classify a player who has a brilliant game every week? I can remember. In fact, if not for Bruce, we wouldn't of played in the 2000 GF. It's sad that you cannot admit how overrated he is.

I'm glad to see there are some realists here. Positive fans = ignorant/moronic/dumb fans. You can't fix a problem without acknowledging it. No positives. Happy birthday indeed, Melbourne,

Bruce won't play. Clearly injured (not that he plays any better when fit). He's knee is gone, I don't care what anyone says. Davey isn't 100% either. Won't be surprised if both miss through "injury"

Debated finished!

Jones would make top 100 easy. He might even scrape top 50. Hasn't missed a beat since he debuted late 2006.

Carrol is the kind of player every team needs. A hard nut that can get under a players skin. Granted, he gets beaten a lot, but players who are suited to playing FB and on big oppositition forwards don't need prestige skills. They need the ability to stop the forward kicking goals. We all know what he's capable of. We saw it in 2006. 2007 he was under immense pressure because the ball was so often in the defensive end. Same thing today. Carroll around a fit Rivers and a tough Whelan and Bell is a good Carroll. Carroll when you have a hack in Miller next to him and forwards who are playing back does nothing for him. He's very underrated (but I try not to overrate him. He's not that good, either).

Here we go... What justifies him being a quality player? His consistent poor kicking? Or constant backing out of packs? How about going missing when we need him (ie. today). He is an overrated hack. Overrated by people like you.

Won't happen. One of them might, but Bruce will never get the sack. Yze is finished and Davey might get dropped.

Yes. Read my last post in another thread. Daniher and is moronic team of recruiters put together a team of hacks.

This has nothing to do with Bailey and everything to do with the rubble of a team that idiot Daniher constructed. Green should have been traded 3 years ago, Johnstone was traded too late, Yze should have been retired by now and Godfrey, Ward and Fergason should have been delisted 2 years ago so as to make room for other players. I blame this debacle on Daniher. He created a fire and left it to burn to the ground. I hate him. He did nothing for this club and genuinly feel sorry for Bailey as he has to deal with another mans mistakes.

Robertson - it takes one

It gave me a reason to leave Easter lunch with my future in-laws early.

Me thinks on thread is needed for Melbourne bashing.

He's a hack of the highest order. I've been saying it for years. So many people praise him but I never saw it. He can be a good player, but ultimately, he is soft. Reminds me of Woey.

I get the same thing. Sometimes it finished on that, sometimes it takes a few seconds to load. Believe me, that first appearence is better then what you're subjected to when it fully loads. How embarrassing.

Should be Demons Vs. Saints.

I wouldn't call any of it "having a dig", I'd call it writing about the hard truth. Melbourne aren't a shambles. They're a joke (as a business).

Somewhere in the MCG near a toilet and a food stall.

They've redone the website, but god is it bad. Do these people know anything about web design? It's difficult to navigate through, especially if you're not familiar with the internet and in parts it looks like a home-made website. What the hell?