jnrmac

If true that would be a very misguided idea Particularly as Joe still owes the Club $2.4m of the money he promised Paid $1.7m to creditors to escape $305m of debt in a bankruptcy settlement. He's a slippery man.

Most of the top 8 don't play like we play. It seems the trend is to play like we played in 2018. Territory with speed and unpredictability.

hmm OK memory playing tricks...

I was one of those. And judging by the way we played this year it is to Goodwin's instruction. Wait till the cavalry arrives then bomb it forward. No one in the top 8 this year seems to play that way.

So was Hunt

Probably the difference is that Gale hadn't been there that long and so therefore was not essentially 'part of the problem' From memory he was appointed in Dec 2015, the club performed poorly in 2016 and the review was commissioned. They won a flag in 2017. And interestingly from the terrific interview Speed said all the copies of the review were retrieved and shredded. Ho one was allowed to leave the room with a copy. It was definitely not a document for public consumption and nothing from the report was leaked into the media. Seems textbook to me. I don't have any faith in Pert from personal dealings in days gone by and he to me seems 'part of the problem'. His presence in an 'external' review would seem to undermine the process. I hope not and hope the Dees can get back on track.

You can read the PR announcement of her appointment here. https://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/114175/roffey-joins-melbourne-board You can read her credentials on her VU page: Kate was previously the Director of Deals, Investment and Major Projects at Wyndham City, where she has played a critical role in securing a new A League team for Melbourne’s West and developing the Public-Private-Partnership deal that will see Australia’s first privately-owned sports stadium built in Wyndham. Kate has extensive experience in developing major sports facilities and previously held an executive position at Tennis Australia leading the billion-dollar Melbourne Park Redevelopment upgrading of facilities for the Australian Open Tennis Championship. Kate has also been a strong advocate for creating visionary cities of the future and was the CEO of the Committee for Melbourne where she successfully led initiatives that ensured Melbourne continued to grow as a prosperous globally connected city.

Everything involving Pert is spin without substance

We've tried that, all duck no dinner..... Is the last part we've struggled with

When she took over as president it was rd 4 of 2021. We won a flag 24 games later which she contributed to with her stint on the Board. Well done. But from that point on we are in a worse position. She now leaves us with a review into the footy department and the Board and a fractured playing group. Not a leaders bootlace.

Have you spoken to Christian? "I haven't spoken directly to him" "I haven't spoken to the Petracca family for a while"

It's indesputible she has left the place in worse shape than she found it

There have been too many mis-steps by this administration in recent times. Kate's train wreck interview was symptomatic of how some at the club operate with a siege mentality. Fairly obvious who the next domino will be. We are lacking real leadership at the club so look fwd to seeing what Brad and hopefully Stephen Smith can do.

This is hilarious. Kate Roffey is giving masterclasses in how to message the media. Suggest you attend 🤪 Gary "best culture I've seen in 40 years' Pert might be a guest speaker.

You aren't allowed more than one visitor in ICU, if that

I would be pretty certain that the club didn't leak information from his exit meeting. Join the dots.

You can't. He is contracted (until Oct 31) and as yet remains innocent After Oct 31 he is probably gone

Standard procedure

That's garbage but there is an argument to say the club has been built around Max and the game plan is in essence kick it to Max down the line. I love Max but IMO its the cause of a lot of the onfield issues. Arguably its why the Grundy trade didn't work. The club and Max weren't prepared to compromise and Grundy had limited flexibility onfield.

They all left

Seriously this. How stupid are we to keep using the same imbecile for the same result

Not to be a smart alec but watching the incident live and watching him go back on it was blindingly obvious he was in immense discomfort and pain. I even said to my colleague "I can't believe they are letting go back on"

1. So the club has an exit interview with CP and the contents are leaked to the media? You would be pretty sure thats coming from the CP camp... can't imagine its in the club's interest to leak it. 2. CP could end the speculation immediately but he hasn't.

And how did that work out....

Please........... Athough its the kind of deal Melbourne would do. Petracca for Cerra and we'd throw in Pick 5 and future first.