Jump to content

whatwhat say what

Life Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by whatwhat say what

  1. interesting the austin bradtke is playing - he is soooo tall and skinny preuss, anb, c wagner, and lewis looking good
  2. i'm a big fan of the weed, so very happy with this confirmation of commitment he hasn't even played 30 games and he's already dominated a final and then played very well against two of the best performed sides of the last dozen years will be a serious player
  3. whatwhat say what replied to ding's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    That’s a lot of dosh for a flanker who has yet to show that much
  4. they talked about this on the real footy podcast a couple of months ago his body is clearly not made for afl
  5. He was, but he also had good form in the vfl leading up to his debut He had actually earned it
  6. whatwhat say what replied to dazzledavey36's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    He’s worth a first round / second round to the Swans and a second / third round to another club If he’s leaving the Swans he’ll have a share of suitors As others have said, he’s a classic nqr / good ordinary player
  7. It’ll be interesting to see if he goes straight down the coaching path or diverts to media He has an incredible football brain He’s been okay for us - our backline looks far more organized with him instructing His experience in the finals last year was invaluable
  8. he's barely fit enough to run out three-quarters of a vfl game and blows up after a half of afl his fitness level is coming from a long, long way back
  9. the lack of promo for this evening indicates a fairly lowkey set of inductees, i suspect?
  10. tom morris on the couch said that may and lever will defo be in for queen's birthday
  11. two games against the filth could be the selection panel's deciding vote! both should make it; both are super ruckmen
  12. i disagree - carlton's list is a hodge-podge mix that is pretty average too many tall defenders who lack strength (jones is easily the best of an average bunch, marchbank, weitering, plowman, plus goddard as a rookie) too many poorly skilled mids (as good as cripps is he's a terrible kick for the most part, dow is an awful kick, sps is super average, and fisher is tiny and not skilled enough to make up for it, matt kennedy and setterfield more failed gw$ recruits) too many tall forwards who don't like body contact (mcgovern, curnow, mckay, and to a lesser extent kerr, who won't make the side while the other three are around) no real small forwards providing defensive pressure (pickett and garlett are the only ones and they're perma-crocked, while silvagni at least tries to tackle but just gets brushed aside by bigger and smaller oppo) too many injury-prone veterans (murphy, daisy, kreuzer, casboult, simpson and docherty is not old but hasn't played for coming up three seasons) the likes of walsh, dow, weitering, o'brien, fisher and stocker should be good, but how many times have we said that about kids who show something in their first year? if i was plucking the eyes outta the blues list there's not many players i'd be super keen on: cripps walsh mckay charlie curnow marchbank maybe weitering, fisher and sps jones as a veteran, but he's no better / worse than frost, really o'brien, stocker you have no real idea on them at this point the rebuild continues on and they have adelaide's first round pick in 2019 and then nothing til the third round
  13. he's so clearly our best player at the moment it's not funny
  14. bolton dropped the selection committee who picked him in it - 'here's all the people who picked me, half of whom are still involved with the club, who now just sacked me'
  15. if lever is fit enough to play, he plays i personally don't think he should be, but really if he's going to do his knee again it could happen at afl, vfl, or during an innocuous training incident i'd be curious to know whether a player is statistically more likely to do a knee at training than during a game; the prevalence of players doing an acl in training seems more common - i can think of four off the top of my head so far this year vs only doedee early in the season then dunn in the vfl in a match for this year, tho i'm sure it's happened to more players...actually add ward in too
  16. this peptides vs carltank match be the worst game i've seen this year and i watched every minute of our mob's 1 point victory over gc17
  17. i'm also in the camp that doesn't think lever has enough footy under his belt yet; but, then again, they played hannan and jkh off not much more of a footballing base, so.... IN: May, Salem, Lever, Hore OUT: Spargo, Stretch, O Mac, J Wagner B: Hore - May - Lever HB: Salem - Frost - Hibberd ? Jones - Harmes - Fritsch HF: Petracca - T Mac - Hunt F: T Smith - Weideman - Garlett Foll: Gawn - Oliver - Viney I/c: Brayshaw - Hannan - JKH - Baker Emerg: Spargo - Stretch - O Mac - J Wagner if lever does get left out, j wagner would be the in i'd have for him
  18. that was AWESOME
  19. the filth are like meth coke; they aren't playing particularly well but they're not losing
  20. Both named in vfl
  21. Add Lever and Sparrow to the injury list - neither named at either level this week
  22. Lever not named either
  23. 1: rowell 2: anderson 3: serong ?
  24. jones is one of most consistent midfielders; if he wants to play on he should get another year he's having a better year than anyone outside of gawn, harmes and (borderline) oliver