drdrake

Pick 20, we would be lucky to get pick 40 for him, he is needed on our list we have no other tall forward. Lets be honest, TMac hasn't been any good for the last 12 odd weeks, the start of the season amazing but has fallen away. B Brown isn't really setting the world on fire kicking some goals but yet to really have an outstanding game, M Brown isn't getting any younger, Daw isn't a forward.

WCE have big Salary Cap issues they tried to top up to win a flag but they now realise that their list is aging with not much coming through. Yeo is the last bloke they can afford to get rid off he is the bloke that wins his own footy and has some heart. Gaff, Shuey, Sheed just want easy football

You have to respect the WAFL and SANFL as top tier competitions until the late 1980s. They were equal to the standard of the VFL till the Eagles and Crows entered into the competition especially pre the 80s as we saw in the 80s Victoria clubs target WA/SA players to play in the VFL. Since the expansion of the AFL, the state league competitions have become the second tier competitions and you will see the VFL have their own Hall of Fame like the WAFL and SANFL that will recognise players who have earnt this at that level

Moving T McDonald to the forward line in 2018 was the start of our charge, we just gained confidence that we could out score out opposition, bit like the way Daniher coached, take the game on attack. We have built an amazing backline to compliment our mids and we just squeeze the life out of sides. We need T Mac or B Brown to really step up in the finals, you just need scoreboard pressure.

Hasn't our side been built by adding in players from other clubs, May, Lever, Brown, Langdon plus adding youth through the draft. It is a balance I get that but lets wait to see how we go in finals before we rule any one out. I'm not saying it will be Cerra, would love him as he adds something we need to improve our list in a really good age bracket, but I'm sure the list management team has a list of outside mids from other clubs that we want to target in trade week.

Brayshaw and second round pick

They still need to sell the club to you, Carlton have the bones of a very good side but you want to know who the coach will be. The way the Carlton Board has handled this review is shambolic with little respect to the people being reviewed. Yesterday highlighted this, Teague is gone but they just keep him on as an insurance policy should the coach of their choice R Lyon knock them back.

Was Cerra coached by Ross Lyon? Have no idea why a young player with so much potential would commit to a club that is an absolute basket case.

They have had to manage Nic Nat's game time from day 1, he actually had his best game for a long time on the weekend. He is a very good tap ruckman mainly at centre bounces when he can jump at the contest, outside that he has little influence on a game. Thank you Jack Watts, if we picked up Nic Nat in the 2008 draft we wouldn't have drafted Max in 2009.

Our back 6 is the best in the competition and will only get better. Lever/May/Petty/Tomlinson/Smith as your talls, then you have a really young attacking mid/smalls Salem/Rivers/Bowey/Hunt and I reckon there is a player at Casey that will slot in over time D Smith. Lever has had a good season but he needs to back 6 playing as a unit to enable him to play his role. The best thing with our backline you can see May playing for 3-4 more years the rest have 5-10 years left in them.

Not only Lever, Salem has had big impact the last couple of weeks, Bowey is getting the ball. To me Smith is in the side as a pure shut down defender, pretty sure he had Rohan on the weekend, can't remember seeing Rohan much on Saturday night except when he stood back and watch Max take the mark. I can't see any chances except if TMac is injured or sore, he didn't move well. The run would help his touch but just looked limitied in his movement. We need someone to tag Rich, I'm assuming Harmes will get first crack

It was interesting listening to Viney on the Footy Show yesterday. The question was what changed at half time, his answer was we were to along the lines of we were to predictable with our taps and clearance set up, Geelong was just picking us off. They changed this at half time to be more aggressive with the tap and clearance, hitting the ball forward and Max grabbing a few out of the ruck. Geelong was just picking Max off in the second qtr, I hate the hit that just drops the ball at the back of the centre circle, every time a team gets dominance in the centre they pick this tap off, when we get aggressive with our tap work it is less predictable. Tmac is a worry, if he can't run around he struggles, that is his strength, he looked like a block that couldn't accelerate. Hoping the run helped, you would almost add Melksham to tag Rich.

Sums up our issue, Oliver inside 50m to Geelong, Petracca no pressure kicks to Geelong viney no pressure kicks to Geelong, we can't kick

Will we get fined for tanking, we rather play port than bne, get the cross over and meet Geelong in the gf

Brayshaw, harmes just need to be replaced in this side

Stop that negative tap in the middle, hit it forward

I think both 1 v 4 and 2 v 3 will be played in Adelaide next week and maybe even a 3rd game. If Melbourne and Geelong win next week I reckon both will go straight to WA to quarantine for prelims. The other teams will either stay in Adelaide or head to Brisbane and quarantine for the semi finals and prelims If they win.

I think Jones in Break Glass in case of emergency and that emergency would be injuries. I think if you narrow your Finals squad you have the 22 from this week, the 3 that missed out plus AVB, Hunt and Weidermen.

I think this forum shows why Smith was picked, he has the ability to play on small/mid size forwards as well as big forwards. I think he will start on Cameron. We don't really get much stronger than this side.

This isn't a new role for him, he has been on a wing for the past couple of seasons. He needs to find the balance like Langdon has defensive running V attacking, seems to me he struggles to do both whether he doesn't have the tank to run both ways is the question. He was pushed out if the centre square group due to lack of defensive running, seems now he runs defensively but has little impact on the attack.

How can Williamstown compete in the finals, they won't be able to train until after the 4th Sept.

I agree with you on Cerra, have watched him a bit this year. If he is leaving Freo, why wouldn't we see if we can add Gus and some picks to get him. You have Cerra on the wing and it really completes our Midfield. The Dockers have some really good young players on their list getting a player like Brayshaw and a pick will add more than Carlton's first round pick. As a player who wouldn't entertain an offer from a team that is sitting on top of the ladder.

Yep, throw a pick in

I'm still on the offer up Brayshaw for Cerra. The wage wouldn't be to much different. I just see Brayshaw as a player that has some value that we can cover with others on the list. He would slot into the centre square next to his brother and Serong at Fremantle and Cerra would slot nicely onto a wing for us.

Strict guidelines will be, we want the finals from 2nd week. I reckon the AFL will have the week off after first week of the finals to allow all the 6 clubs left to get into WA to quarantine. They will be resigned to the fact that there will be games next week with no crowds, expect Essendon and GWS to head into Brisbane and AFL will be hoping Port and Geelong finish top 2.