daisycutter

can you clarify that if he nominates say $700k/yr for 2 years, that he could turn around and only sign for 1 year with the suns. Wouldn't this be in breach of the rules. And yeah i know that the afl has elastic rules. comments?

plus he can nominate a contract length of > 1 year, so he won't be a FA in 2020 if suns pick him in psd

carlton definitely gaming (screwing) the suns. if they value him at $700k they should have been prepared to offer a commensurate trade value. They did not, and they had the ability to. I hope suns pick him up in psd (probably a slim chance)

yeah but there are dh's and then there are mega dh's and mega dh's with mega injury concerns

he won't go into the nd

i think the afl have rules against unrelated dependent type pick swaps. swaps should be of mutual benefit in themselves and not be related to any "rigging" of the draft. can't remember rules exactly but there is some catch-all to prevent "funny business" which naturally the afl decide in private. i.e. give me an advantageous pick swap and i promise not to pick player x. of course this can be disguised in many cases, but in this case might look a bit obvious. just a thought

not only can't lose what you've already lost, plus will gain in 12 months time via compo pick if he sooks it up he can play neafl all year he sits it out at his own peril - no contract - loss of form etc (mccartney never recovered) suns can send a strong message i like it

still young (23) and 198cm

hint: "well placed sources" = demonland or other social media "sources"

all clubs don't have a chance he will only go into psd where carlscum have pick3 has said he won't go back to suns so that leaves only us, and his management have said they don't want to talk to us plus most clubs won't have any list spots left for psd anyway carlscum have gamed the system beautifully

i suspect that carlton have always planned to get a freebie via the psd pretty rough on suns to end up with nothing

surely you would do any front-loading at the last moment when everyone that will be is on-board

well we could fit elliot into our cap supposedly that must mean martin wants a lot more than elliot.....in which case he must be overpricing himself

a lot of cussing and swearing i'd imagine as you can't find the manual for that old clock radio with the non-intuitive time setting sequence

i'm scratching my head trying to understand what the new evidence is they seem to be just resurrecting the same old arguments that have previously been rebuffed and extensively argued nothing to see here except that the essendrug apologists will never cease (specially the essendon cheerleaders in the media ) zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

Can psd picks be traded along with draft picks? I don't think so, but worth asking

tic to op

What about 7, 10, Brayshaw from Fremantle for 3 and 8 ?

i dunno, he had a very average 2019 at the wanchors

weren't you seduced by juice newton too?......nuff said

agree a new hq for us is a top priority however, i think what we have at gosch's/aami (for the FD) is still better than what the aints have at the tired old linton st. facility. there again the aints do have the attraction of st. kilda school girls.

my post re linton st was sarcasm

this is sanfl seconds you do realise? and only 1 game in 12 games (sanfl 2nds, u18 and 2 games sanfl) he kicked 17 goals. take away the 6 in 1 game and you have 11 goals in 11 games hardly a prolific goal sneak. yes, he is a natural footballer type with x-factor but at 170cm i'd like to see a lot lot more of his capabilities and record to date far too easy to be seduced by a highlights video of one game.